# Study shows rhesus monkeys able to add numbers together for a reward

##### April 22, 2014 by Bob Yirka report

(Phys.org) —A team of researchers working at Harvard Medical School has found that it is possible to teach rhesus monkeys to perform simple addition. In their paper published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the group describes studies they undertook to teach lab monkeys to add symbols together in order to receive a reward, the results of which have shown that other primates besides humans are capable of performing simple math.

Scientists know that many animals are capable of making numerical estimates—they can tell if they are being invaded by a few predators or many, for example. They also know that some primates have shown a rudimentary ability to add numbers together—to understand that multiple that hold value hold more when combined, for example. In this new effort, the researchers have found that at least one primate—rhesus —can actually add values together to form a result which can be used for comparison with another value.

To learn about the monkey's abilities, the researchers taught several of them to memorize values associated with the digits 0-9, along with 16 letters, and then to assign value to each of them (by giving them a treat if the picked the one with higher value). Then, to find out if they could add, the researchers presented two previously associated characters alongside another single one. To receive a treat a monkey had to add the value of the two symbols then compare the result against the value of the single character and then choose which had the greatest value. The researchers report that the monkeys were able to choose correctly approximately 90 percent of the time.

Of course, the team realized the monkeys may have simply memorized the value of all possible pairings, instead of actually adding, so they introduced a whole new set of characters. Once the monkeys had been trained to associate values with them, they immediately, on their own, applied the math skills they had learned on the first experiment, proving that they were in fact adding the values together to reach a sum, which had a value all its own.

The researchers noted that that the monkeys did less well when the values of two symbols were closer together, suggesting that at least part of their were based on making estimates—a finding that could prove useful to researchers looking to understand how it is we humans are able to make mathematical calculations.

More information: Symbol addition by monkeys provides evidence for normalized quantity coding, Margaret S. Livingstone, PNAS, 2014. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1404208111

Abstract
Weber's law can be explained either by a compressive scaling of sensory response with stimulus magnitude or by a proportional scaling of response variability. These two mechanisms can be distinguished by asking how quantities are added or subtracted. We trained Rhesus monkeys to associate 26 distinct symbols with 0–25 drops of reward, and then tested how they combine, or add, symbolically represented reward magnitude. We found that they could combine symbolically represented magnitudes, and they transferred this ability to a novel symbol set, indicating that they were performing a calculation, not just memorizing the value of each combination. The way they combined pairs of symbols indicated neither a linear nor a compressed scale, but rather a dynamically shifting, relative scaling.

## Related Stories

#### Monkeys have better basic counting skills than originally thought

March 31, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- In a recent study published in Nature Communications, it appears that Old World monkeys have the ability to count better than was originally thought. The research also shows that when presented with counting ...

#### Primates too can move in unison

January 28, 2013

Japanese researchers show for the first time that primates modify their body movements to be in tune with others, just like humans do. Humans unconsciously modify their movements to be in synchrony with their peers. For example, ...

#### Study shows capuchins less receptive to others who refuse to help when asked

March 6, 2013

(Phys.org) —A team of Japanese and British researchers has found that capuchin monkeys behave less receptively towards people they observe who refuse to help when asked by another person. In their paper published in Nature ...

#### Fossil find adds three million years to oldest known old-world monkey

March 19, 2013

(Phys.org) —Researchers from the United States have identified fossilized remains found in Kenya seven years ago, as those belonging to an old-world monkey (Cercopithecidae) and relative of modern proboscis and colobus ...

#### Monkeys can point to objects they do not report seeing

November 19, 2013

Are monkeys, like humans, able to ascertain where objects are located without much more than a sideways glance? Quite likely, says Lau Andersen of the Aarhus University in Denmark, lead author of a study conducted at the ...

#### Watching primates make social decisions in the lab and in the field

February 19, 2014

Both in the lab and on a tropical island, primate behaviors can shed light on social-decision making.

## Recommended for you

#### Conservation ecologists lay out a set of guidelines for how de-extinction can be made more ecologically responsible

August 25, 2016

Can the woolly mammoth be brought back from the dead? Scientists say it's only a matter of time.

#### Carp demonstrate rapid de-evolution to get their scales back

August 24, 2016

(Phys.org)—A team of researchers with members from France, Hungary and Madagascar has found that a type of carp bred to have fewer scales and subsequently released into the wild in Madagascar a century ago has devolved ...

#### Chimpanzees choose cooperation over competition: Study challenges distinctiveness of human cooperation

August 22, 2016

When given a choice between cooperating or competing, chimpanzees choose to cooperate five times more frequently Yerkes National Primate Research Center researchers have found. This, the researchers say, challenges the perceptions ...

#### Probing how CRISPR-Cas9 works: Study examines DNA targeting dynamics in live cells

August 26, 2016

A study in The Journal of Cell Biology by scientists at the University of Massachusetts Medical School reveals important new details about the inner workings of the CRISPR-Cas9 machinery in live cells that may have implications ...

#### Shifts in the microbiome impact tissue repair and regeneration

August 26, 2016

Researchers at the Stowers Institute have established a definitive link between the makeup of the microbiome, the host immune response, and an organism's ability to heal itself.

#### Moth takes advantage of defensive compounds in Physalis fruits

August 26, 2016

Researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Chemical Ecology found that the specialist moth Heliothis subflexa benefits from secondary plant components by turning the original defensive function of these compounds into ...

##### betterexists
1 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2014
Not only Reward; Add Mild Electric Shock as Punishment too in case of errors; That will speed up the process of learning!
##### betterexists
1 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2014
Not only Reward; Add Mild Electric Shock as Punishment too in case of errors; That will speed up the process of learning!

Monkeys should pay for this NUISANCE Research!
##### betterexists
1 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2014
This kind of research should be in the domain of kids as a hobby. Nothing more!
##### betterexists
1 / 5 (2) Apr 22, 2014
People with Brain Size of a Monkey do this kind of B.S Research!
##### Returners
1 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2014
Ripley's Believe it or Not presented a film of a dog which supposedly could do multiplication and bark out the answer.
##### Sonhouse
not rated yet Apr 22, 2014
Maybe they are training them to work at McDonalds.....