Unpacking the past: Identifying a key evolutionary step in E. coli metabolism

Jan 28, 2014 by Stuart Mason Dambrot feature
REGRES. (1) Suicide F plasmids are transferred to the donor strain by conjugation, and multiple F plasmid integrant Hfr strains are selected. (2) Isolated Hfr strains are mated with an F recipient strain, permitting genome transfer and homologous recombination with the genomes of recipient cells. (3) A suitable selection or screening procedure for individual transconjugants displaying the phenotype of interest is applied. (4) Isolated strains are genotyped against a panel of known alleles. (5) Strains of interest, usually with the fewest donor alleles, are selected for whole-genome sequencing and can be used as donors for another round of REGRES, if desired. Credit: Copyright © PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1314561111

(Phys.org) —Evolution is a process that takes place over long periods of time over which genetics and ecology may interact, producing novel phenotypic traits. Researchers previously found that after roughly 31,500 generations had passed in a laboratory evolution experiment a rare metabolic innovation emerged in which Escherichia coli developed the ability to metabolize citrate (Cit+) in its growth medium. Through genetic analysis with a recursive genomewide recombination and sequencing method (REGRES), scientists at University of Texas, Austin have now identified a key mutation that they say demonstrates how improvement of an emergent trait can be as important to its eventual success as earlier mutations or environmental conditions that may have been necessary for it to initially evolve.

Dr. Jeffrey E. Barrick discussed the paper that he, Graduate Research Assistant Erik M. Quandt and their co-authors published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. "REGRES is a combination of tried-and-true genetic methods, known for decades, including conjugation," Barrick tells Phys.org. (Conjugation is a form of bacterial pseudo-sex for exchanging genes or mutations, in which a portion of the chromosome of one bacterium is transferred into another.) "The new aspect in REGRES," Barrick continues, "was creating a way for this process to be used serially – that is, to keep performing this transfer into a 'blank' ancestral genome, starting from a genome that had many evolved genetic changes." This so-called backcrossing procedure sequentially removed all mutations that weren't required for surviving the growth conditions used, which required being able to efficiently utilize citrate as a nutrient. The other technology that enabled REGRES, Barrick notes, was next-generation DNA sequencing, which allowed the scientists to fully track which mutations were removed by not being transferred at each step.

In one of the study's key findings, the researchers identified a mutation that converts a rudimentary form of the innovation into a refined trait that confers a decisive competitive advantage, by dissecting the genetics of this trait using REGRES. "We were very surprised that after starting with a collection of more than 70 mutations in the evolved Cit+ strain – most of which were related to improving growth on glucose as a carbon source – we were able to find just two mutations that conferred the ability to utilize citrate." Barrick explains that this was unexpected due to very compelling evidence that mutations which occurred before citrate utilization arose in this population made certain E. coli in this population more likely to be able to evolve the ability to use citrate. This evidence is from studies that re-played evolution from many genetic starting points in what he describes as "very elegant" experiments by Zachary Blount and Richard Lenski at Michigan State University1,2. In addition, Barrick states that the REGRES method was key to sifting through the more than 70 evolved mutations that could have been necessary for utilizing citrate.

"Our results imply that these earlier 'potentiating' mutations weren't absolutely necessary for expressing the beneficial Cit+ trait, as we first thought. Instead," Barrick points out, "they seem to make it possible for evolution to follow a tenuous path. We hypothesize that these mutations may actually be deleterious to E. coli growth without the earlier potentiating mutations rewiring bacterial metabolism in some unknown way." This would mean that if these mutations occurred in certain strain backgrounds (like the ancestor) that they would rapidly go extinct from the population – but with the potentiating mutations present, it appears that the first mutation that affected the CitT transporter protein and gave a weak ability to use citrate was ever-so-slightly beneficial for growth and survival.

Model for the evolution of citrate utilization in the E. coli long-term evolution experiment. (A) There were three major epochs in the evolution of this metabolic innovation: potentiation, actualization, and refinement. Weakly Cit+ cells were first isolated from the population after the rnk–citG actualizing mutation that amplified and activated the CitT transporter (shown as the citT allele). There was not an appreciable increase in the final cell density at the end of each growth cycle in the evolution experiment at this point (Top). After the dctA" refinement mutation, there was a substantial increase in population size because cells were able to fully use citrate, which we distinguish from the rudimentary Cit+ phenotype as the strong Cit++ phenotype (Middle). The evolution of Cit++ is statistically more likely from certain Cit genetic backgrounds that arose later in this population, presumably because they accumulated one or more potentiating mutations relative to the ancestor (3, 10). Key mutations are shown with their approximate timings relative to these evolutionary epochs and one another (Bottom). (B) Cit++ phenotype is not the product of all-or-none epistasis with potentiating mutations. The progression of citrate utilization phenotypes as they evolved in the LTEE in strains that contained key mutations in the context of earlier evolved alleles (Upper) and qualitative phenotypes of reconstructed strains containing only key evolved alleles in the ancestral genetic background (Bottom) are shown. The evolved citT mutation alone is sufficient for detectable but extremely limited citrate utilization, as observed in early Cit+ isolates (3). The citT and dctA" mutations together are sufficient for full citrate utilization characteristic of the Cit++ phenotype, even in the absence of potentiating mutations. (C) Mechanism of Cit++ refinement. When both the CitT and DctA transporters are expressed, due to the citT and dctA" mutations, their activities can be coupled so that the proton-motive force (H+) powers reuptake of succinate or other C4-dicarboxylate substrates for continued citrate import, yielding the Cit++ phenotype. It is possible that the unknown potentiating mutations make sufficient succinate available from glucose metabolism to power limited citrate import through CitT but that this does not result in a sustainable cycle. Copyright © PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1314561111

"Once this mutation was able to persist in the face of competition with other E. coli lineages in the population that were improving through other mutations," Barrick adds, "it gave enough time to get the second key mutation, which affects the DctA transporter protein. This mutation completed a cycle that enabled all of the citrate in the media to be efficiently utilized by this strain." This innovation gave the E. coli strain in question what Barrick describes as an "overwhelming" evolutionary advantage relative to its competitors that remained limited to competing for a lesser amount of the nutrient glucose.

An important conclusion of the study is that refinement of an emergent trait from a rudimentary form may be crucial to its evolutionary success. "Evolutionary innovations often seem to come out of nowhere, like the huge population expansion in this laboratory E. coli population when it evolved to be able to fully exploit citrate that had always been present in the growth medium for the preceding 15 years," Barrick tells Medical Xpress. "Our study shows that earlier mutations that may not have immediately obvious effects can be important for setting the stage for evolutionary breakthroughs. It's this exploratory mode of evolution – where there may not be any immediately obvious effects until a whole string of complementary mutations are put together – that can surprise us when we watch evolution happen in real time."

More specifically, the study's results imply that the DctA mutation was important for improving this rudimentary trait to enable full citrate utilization. "Once the REGRES results implied that only the DctA and CitT mutations were common to all backcrossed genomes, we were able to take the ancestral strain and add just those two mutations to it. Since this recapitulated a very strong ability to use citrate, we concluded that these were the key mutations required for the Cit+ phenotype." Moreover, he adds, the timing of these two mutations in the original population was also coincident with the earliest known weak Cit+ utilizers (CitT mutation) and a population expansion where E. coli with the refined Cit+ trait took over the population (DctA mutation) and grew to a much higher density than was possible without using this additional nutrient source.

Moving forward, Barrick says, the researchers remain very interested in identifying the potentiating mutations and/or ecological conditions that enabled the weakly Cit+ E. coli to persist in the population long enough for Cit+ refinement causing the population expansion to occur. "To solve this puzzle, we're trying to more precisely determine the order of the more than 70 mutations in the Cit+ strain that was examined in this study." They're doing this, he explains, by going back into the frozen "fossil record" of this population and sequencing the genomes of more bacteria. "We hope to eventually find a context of earlier mutations that makes the actualizing CitT mutation beneficial enough to explain why it did not go extinct when it occurred." Since the fitness effects of these mutations are much more subtle, Barrick adds, this is proving to be difficult.

"In the short term," he continues, "we're also following up on an interesting story related to a mutation that we discovered as a side effect of performing REGRESS. We found that a new mutation appeared during our backcrossing procedure that was not present in the Cit+ strain that we started with. It turns out that similar mutations eventually appeared many times in the actual long-term E. coli evolution experiment population, so it was beneficial for further refinement of the Cit+ trait to get one of these mutations." Interestingly, this mutation appears to reverse the effects of an earlier mutation that is present in these genomes, which appeared before citrate utilization ever arose. "We therefore have a case where becoming Cit+ changed E. coli metabolism so much that it made it beneficial to reverse the trajectory of earlier evolution. This sort of rewiring is a hallmark of evolutionary innovation."

Along with many other researchers Barrick and his co-authors continue to develop improved tools like REGRES to remix and edit the sequences of bacterial genomes. "For example," he illustrates, "it can still be difficult to go into the lab and reconstruct complex sequence rearrangements in a genome like the one that turned on expression of the CitT transporter."

Barrick notes that other areas of research might benefit from their study. "The REGRES methodology has several possible applications. It can be used, as in our study, to find which of many possible mutations in an evolved E. coli strain contribute to a complex phenotypic trait. One could also use the same approach to hybridize the genomes of two E. coli strains that have been evolved or engineered to have an industrially useful property, such as producing increased amounts of a biofuel. The hybrid genomes may acquire a collection of some mutations from each 'parent' that performs better than either of the original strains. A related use," he concludes, "would be to subtract deleterious mutations that sometimes accumulate over time in bacterial strains from a genome so that they're not a drag on its growth or production capacity."

Explore further: Human sense of fairness evolved to favor long-term cooperation

More information: Recursive genomewide recombination and sequencing reveals a key refinement step in the evolution of a metabolic innovation in Escherichia coli, Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences Published online before print on December 30, 2013, doi:10.1073/pnas.1314561111

Related:

1Genomic analysis of a key innovation in an experimental Escherichia coli population, Nature 489(7417):513–518 (2012), doi:10.1038/nature11514

2Historical contingency and the evolution of a key innovation in an experimental population of Escherichia coli, Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences, 105(23):7899–7906 (2008), doi:10.1073/pnas.0803151105

Related Stories

E. coli offers insight to evolution

Jun 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Evolutionary biologist Richard Lenski occasionally thinks of his 12 original flasks of E. coli as the experiment that keeps on giving.

Recommended for you

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

rkolter
5 / 5 (1) Jan 28, 2014
I thought 31,500 generations was an awful lot of generations and wondered how long the experiment ran. But, it appears to have run for 25 years according to the abstract. That's a genetics experiment that started in the late 1980's. Pretty cool stuff.
animah
5 / 5 (1) Jan 28, 2014
Crystal clear: Branches bearing detrimental mutations are more likely to die out, leaving the rest of their species tree unaffected.

However branches bearing beneficial mutations are more likely to take over their out-competed brethren.

This study proves once more that the larger statistical probability of negative mutations does nothing to disprove evolution, and the fundies are simply wrong.