Sandy's lessons include: Put parks, not houses, on the beach

Oct 27, 2013
This is a before-and-after photo of Mantoloking, N.J., USA. "Before" image captured by Google; "after" image captured by NOAA's National Geodetic Survey. Click on the photo for a larger image. Credit: Google / NOAA

Just days before Hurricane Sandy hit the New York and New Jersey coastline on 29 October 2012, scientists from the City University of New York's (CUNY) College of Staten Island had produced the most detailed model to date of the region's potential for damage from big storms. So naturally, the morning after the floods receded from Staten Island, CUNY geology professor Alan I. Benimoff was out mapping the high-water marks in the flooded neighborhoods. There he discovered that his team's pre-Sandy model had been right on the money.

Sandy caused 40 deaths and massive damage in New York City—yet future storms could be worse, according to Benimoff and his colleagues. At the 2013 Geological Society of America (GSA) meeting in Denver, they will describe how the combination of rising sea level and more frequent, more severe hurricanes could bring Atlantic water much higher.

Their new flood model predicts that Staten Island and Long Island would again flood in low-lying areas, such as South Beach, with their working-class neighborhoods and beachfront boardwalks, and could even surpass Sandy levels. In Manhattan, the storm surge could extend past the low areas that flooded in Sandy, which included Battery Park subway tunnels, the Financial District, and a 14th Street electrical substation.

The researchers are geology professors Benimoff and William J. Fritz; Michael Kress, director of the CUNY Interdisciplinary High Performance Computer Center, vice president for technology systems, and professor of computer science; and undergraduate student Liridon Sela.

Since Sandy, Benimoff and Fritz, who is interim president of College of Staten Island, have been active in the community discussions about how—or whether—to rebuild on the most vulnerable parts of the . They have developed five recommendations for area policy makers, emergency agencies and residents.

In public discussions, Benimoff does not mince words. As a scientist, he says, he has an obligation to communicate data clearly to non-scientists.

"To paraphrase our governor: There are some parcels of land that Mother Nature owns, and when she comes to visit, she visits," Benimoff says. "The reality is that these particular barrier are uniquely vulnerable to storm surges. They have a lot of coastal and wetland that never should have been built on.

"What's more, they have a geometry of coastline where Coney Island and Sandy Hook make a right angle with Staten Island right at the apex, and the seafloor comes up very gradually. Water piles up in that corner and has nowhere to go but inland. That means any storm that comes perpendicular to the coastline of New Jersey is going to put us in harm's way."

The College of Staten Island scientists' five-point plan recommends:

  • Protect the existing natural barriers—the beaches and dunes;
  • Build them higher;
  • Rezone in the flood zone to prevent home construction. Buy these properties and turn them into parks, which will sponge up the inevitable floodwaters and partially protect the islands' higher lands. (There is precedent for this—after 157 people died in 1946 and 1960 tsunamis in Hilo, Hawaii, the most damaged neighborhoods were turned into parks.)
  • Be very careful about engineering solutions such as sea barriers because they will not only be expensive but also protect one stretch of beach at the expense of its neighbor. "Jetties, sandbars, seawalls—these are merely Band-Aids," Benimoff says. "You've got to face the music here."
  • Teach coastal residents how to survive a hurricane: Stay informed by watching weather forecasts. Evacuate early. Don't seek refuge in basements, which could flood. Know your area's high ground and, if faced with rapidly rising waters, go there.

Explore further: Muddy forests, shorter winters present challenges for loggers

More information: gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webp… ram/Paper227524.html

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Making storm warnings a more exact science

May 02, 2013

(Phys.org) —New Yorkers are famous for being unflappable, but in the fall of 2011 William Fritz was worried that the city had taken Hurricane Irene a little too much in stride. Like other climate concerned ...

Levees, removable walls in plan to protect NYC

Jun 11, 2013

(AP)—Mayor Michael Bloomberg is proposing removable flood walls for much of lower Manhattan, a permanent 15-to-20-foot levee in part of Staten Island and a system of gates and levees at a Brooklyn creek ...

Could Sandy happen again? Maybe, says geologist

Oct 17, 2013

Almost a year after Hurricane Sandy, parts of New York and New Jersey are still recovering from billions of dollars in flood damage. Tufts University geologist Andrew Kemp sees the possibility of damage from storms smaller ...

Recommended for you

Rising anger as Nicaragua canal to break ground

Dec 21, 2014

As a conscripted soldier during the Contra War of the 1980s, Esteban Ruiz used to flee from battles because he didn't want to have to kill anyone. But now, as the 47-year-old farmer prepares to fight for ...

Hopes, fears, doubts surround Cuba's oil future

Dec 20, 2014

One of the most prolific oil and gas basins on the planet sits just off Cuba's northwest coast, and the thaw in relations with the United States is giving rise to hopes that Cuba can now get in on the action.

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

TheGhostofOtto1923
1 / 5 (3) Oct 27, 2013
Peoplewho can afford to build disposable houses should be allowed to do so. But they should be paying into a fund to clean up the mess when they get destroyed. Which is what insurance is.

Maybe they could get a break for tethered designs which would float above the surges, although it would be hard to plan for all potentialities.
Neinsense99
1.5 / 5 (8) Oct 27, 2013
Peoplewho can afford to build disposable houses should be allowed to do so. But they should be paying into a fund to clean up the mess when they get destroyed. Which is what insurance is.

Maybe they could get a break for tethered designs which would float above the surges, although it would be hard to plan for all potentialities.

That would be one way to buoy spirits.
Some pics of a floating house: http://dornob.com...iwwqn8V6
TheGhostofOtto1923
1 / 5 (3) Oct 27, 2013
Peoplewho can afford to build disposable houses should be allowed to do so. But they should be paying into a fund to clean up the mess when they get destroyed. Which is what insurance is.

Maybe they could get a break for tethered designs which would float above the surges, although it would be hard to plan for all potentialities.

That would be one way to buoy spirits.
Some pics of a floating house: http://dornob.com...iwwqn8V6
Yeah Ive seen that. But it would have to be designed to withstand a surge and also hurricane-force winds.
Doug_Huffman
1 / 5 (9) Oct 27, 2013
Sandy's lesson will be ignored as Hurricand Hugo's lesson was ignored. Hugo turned Isle of Palms, SC into five miles of toothpicks and toilet-tissue that was cleaned up by FedGov and the insurance was used to rebuild vinyl-tacky mega-McMansions.

The Mayor charged the SCARNG to shoot 'looters' that were home owners trying to learn the condition of their properties. Her excuse was rattlesnakes and propane-tanks, real sewerage. I hope she's miserably dead.

As for "planning for all potentialities", someone needs to read a little, perhaps Taleb's Anti-fragile or Vilfredo Pareto's distribution https://en.wikipe...ribution
rwinners
1 / 5 (1) Oct 27, 2013
Long term changes in local US zoning laws need to be made pretty quickly. The problem is... that seaside property is currently valued at far higher than it will be worth in 50 years.
ryggesogn2
1 / 5 (10) Oct 27, 2013
If people want to build on a beach, let them
Use this as the model:
http://bbs.monoli...p;t=2879
http://www.monoli...h/photos
goracle
1 / 5 (7) Oct 28, 2013
Peoplewho can afford to build disposable houses should be allowed to do so. But they should be paying into a fund to clean up the mess when they get destroyed. Which is what insurance is.

Maybe they could get a break for tethered designs which would float above the surges, although it would be hard to plan for all potentialities.

That would be one way to buoy spirits.
Some pics of a floating house: http://dornob.com...iwwqn8V6
Yeah Ive seen that. But it would have to be designed to withstand a surge and also hurricane-force winds.

That design would be for inland waterways, but there are others that would be less vulnerable.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.