Do black holes have hair? A new hypothesis on the nature of these celestial bodies

September 30, 2013

Black holes may be less simple and "clean" than how the most authoritative theoretical model describes them. This is what a group of researchers based at the International School of Advanced Studies, Trieste, and IST, Lisbon, claims in a new article appeared in Physical Review Letters. According to the scientists' calculations, these celestial bodies may actually have "hair".

A black hole. A simple and clear concept, at least according to the hypothesis by Roy Kerr, who in 1963 proposed a "clean" black hole model, which is the current theoretical paradigm. From theory to reality things may be quite different. According to a new research carried out by a group of scientists that includes Thomas Sotiriou, a physicist of the International School for Advanced Studies (SISSA) of Trieste, may be much "dirtier" than what Kerr believed.

According to the traditional model, black holes are defined by only two quantities: mass and angular momentum (a black hole rotation velocity). Once their progenitor has collapsed (a high mass star, for instance, that at the end of its life cycle implodes inwards) its memory is lost forever. All that is left is a quiescent black hole, with almost no distinctive features: all black holes, mass and angular momentum aside, look almost the same.

According to Sotiriou, things may not have occurred this way. "Black holes, according to our calculations, may have hair", explains Sotiriou, referring to a well-known statement by physicist John Wheeler, who claimed that "black holes have no hair". Wheeler meant that mass and are all one needs to describe them.

"Although Kerr's 'bald' model is consistent with General Relativity, it might not be consistent with some well-known extensions of Einstein's theory, called tensor-scalar theories", adds Sotiriou. "This is why we have carried out a series of new calculations that enabled us to focus on the matter that normally surrounds realistic black holes, those observed by astrophysicists. This matter forces the pure and simple black hole hypothesized by Kerr to develop a new 'charge' (the hair, as we call it) which anchors it to the surrounding matter, and probably to the entire Universe."

The experimental confirmation of this new hypothesis may come from the observations carried out with the interferometers, instruments capable of recording the gravitational waves. "According to our calculations, the growth of the black hole's hair," concludes Sotiriou "is accompanied by the emission of distinctive gravitational waves. In the future, the recordings by the instrument may challenge Kerr's model and broaden our knowledge of the origins of gravity."

Explore further: A Newtonian system that mimics the baldness of rotating black holes

More information:

Related Stories

Answers to black hole evolution beyond the horizon?

January 19, 2011

One of the most important predictions of Einstein's theory of General Relativity is the existence of black holes. The dynamics of these systems are not yet fully understood, but researchers from Queen Mary, University of ...

Theorists apply loop quantum gravity theory to black hole

May 31, 2013

( —Physicists Rodolfo Gambini and Jorge Pullin of University of the Republic in Montevideo, Uruguay, and Louisiana State University respectively, have applied the theory of Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) to a simplified ...

Recommended for you

NASA selects investigations for future key planetary mission

October 1, 2015

NASA has selected five science investigations for refinement during the next year as a first step in choosing one or two missions for flight opportunities as early as 2020. Three of those chosen have ties to NASA's Jet Propulsion ...

Dawn team shares new maps and insights about Ceres

October 1, 2015

Mysteries and insights about Ceres are being discussed this week at the European Planetary Science Conference in Nantes, France. NASA's Dawn spacecraft is providing scientists with tantalizing views and other data about the ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (4) Sep 30, 2013
The concept of "no hair" on a black hole simply means that it can only possess properties expressible by single quantum numbers: mass, angular momentum, net charge, and magnetic dipole moment. The black hole has no internal structure as that would require subordinate component parts which can interact with each other within the 'hole'.
Personally I believe 'gravity' waves' will never be quantized into 'gravitons' as that would be inconsistent with the mathematics of the continuum model for empty space/time.
5 / 5 (2) Oct 01, 2013
it might not be consistent with some well-known extensions of Einstein's theory, called tensor-scalar theories", adds Sotiriou.

This matter forces the pure and simple black hole hypothesized by Kerr to develop a new 'charge'

OK, they're trying to extend MOND theories to include charge. It seems they forgot GR already provides the Reissner-Nordstrom solution:


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.