Cutting costs to the bone

Aug 15, 2013 by Ida Gudjonsson

A new and cheaper method for screening ancient bones to determine whether they contain DNA has been described in a PhD thesis by a conservator at the University of Stavanger's Archaeological Museum.

This approach could overcome a major problem of identifying useful genetic material in large collections of without resorting to extensive and expensive laboratory studies.

Hege Ingjerd Hollund proposes a combination of three – microscope examination, inspection with ultraviolet light and infra-red spectrometry (a form of chemical analysis).

"No single way of checking produces an adequate result," she explains. "I believe combining different approaches will give the best outcome."

This solution is proposed in the thesis she has had accepted by the Free University of Amsterdam, which makes her one of the few Norwegians with a PhD in conservation of ancient remains.

"These methods are not only fast and simple to do, but they also preserve the piece cut or drilled from the bone," she says. "This can therefore be reused in other analyses."

Preserved

The three methods provided different information about the deterioration of a bone and how well preserved it is.

Hollund uses various parameters for the level of preservation when studying bone samples. The results of each screening can be used to assess the probability of DNA being present.

Two modern cow bones (left) and a prehistoric human bone under ultraviolet light. The leftmost sample has been burnt, and shows what deteriorated bone looks like. Credit: Hege Ingjerd Hollund

Her approach will also provide information on the challenges presented by a bone – whether it is contaminated, for example, by organic material from the soil or by bacterial DNA.

She has tested the proposed solution with a large and varied range of materials, analysing 425 samples of bone or teeth from people and many types of animals.

The latter range from the dodo, an extinct Mauritian flightless bird, to the aurochs – the ancestor of and also extinct.

DNA screening can have a number of applications, including monitoring how well bones are keeping in museum collections. That would make it possible to determine the best storage methods.

Success

Hollund's method could increase the success rate in searching for DNA, agrees associate professor Anne Karin Hufthammer at the University of Bergen and an expert on prehistoric bones.

"A way of screening such remains to find out whether they contain genetic material would be incredibly valuable for the archaeological community," she emphasises.

Hufthammer also acclaims the fact that the approach proposed by Hollund makes it possible to use the screened or teeth samples for other analyses.

"Let's say we carry out a DNA analysis of a prehistoric tooth and fail to find . We're often interested in doing other types of analysis, but that's not possible today."

Complicated

DNA analyses are costly and complicated, and scientists have accordingly long wanted to find good methods for screening .

Genetic material in such relics has often deteriorated greatly, and pollution in the form of modern DNA from bacteria or archaeologists who have touched them can create problems.

Hollund's proposal is welcomed by Jørgen Rosvold, who analyses prehistoric deer and reindeer bones in the Snow Patch Archaeology Research Cooperation at the science museum of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU).

"If we can limit the number of bones we take samples from in order to locate DNA, we'll save both time and money," he confirms. "That would be very useful."

Explore further: A word in your ear, but make it snappy

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Toward more effective paleolgenetic analysis

Jan 17, 2007

DNA preserved in bones undergoing fossilization deteriorates up to 50 times faster when stored in a museum than when the bones are buried in the ground. This has just been shown by a paleogenetics team led by Eva-Maria Geigl ...

Searching for an ancient syphilis DNA in newborns

Jul 03, 2012

The ancient bones of newborns are very useful to recover the ancient DNA of the bacteria causing syphilis, the Treponema pallidum pallidum. This is the conclusion reached by a study led by Universitat Autono ...

Exploring dinosaur growth

Jun 28, 2013

Tracking the growth of dinosaurs and how they changed as they grew is difficult. Using a combination of biomechanical analysis and bone histology, palaeontologists from Beijing, Bristol, and Bonn have shown ...

Recommended for you

A word in your ear, but make it snappy

1 hour ago

To most, crocodiles conjure images of sharp teeth, powerful jaws and ferocious, predatory displays – but they are certainly not famous for their hearing abilities. However, this could all change, as new ...

User comments : 0