Professionals often attribute applicants' success to personal traits, not circumstance

Jul 24, 2013

Professionals evaluating graduate school or job applicants frequently attribute applicants' credentials to their personal qualities rather than their circumstances, according to research published July 24 in the open access journal PLoS ONE by Samuel Swift from the University of California, Berkeley and colleagues from other institutions.

Higher grading schools and that make it easier to succeed can play a significant role in inflating applicants' qualifications. In this study, participants were presented fictitious examples of graduate school applicants with high GPAs from schools with higher grade distributions than students who had lower GPAs from lower-grading schools.

The researchers found that participants were more likely to select applicants with high GPAs from higher-grading schools than those who had lower GPAs from lower-grading schools, and their higher grades were also more likely to be attributed to the applicants' individual traits, rather than the school they attended. Similar results were seen when participants were asked to evaluate managers up for a promotion in a business scenario. The study concludes, "Our results indicate that candidates who have demonstrated high performance thanks to favorable situations are more likely to be rated highly and selected. Across all our studies, the results suggest that experts take high performance as evidence of high ability and do not sufficiently discount it by the ease with which that performance was achieved."

Swift explains, "Professionals' admissions and hiring did not differentiate the truly skilled from the fortunate and made their evaluations and selections accordingly. Results from both experimental lab studies and field data from tens of thousands of real MBA admissions decisions show that the good fortune of a favorable situation is just as important as skill and effort in getting hired or admitted."

Explore further: Gypsies and travellers on the English Green Belt

More information: PLoS ONE 8(7): e69258. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0069258

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Med school enrollment on rise in 2012

Oct 26, 2012

(HealthDay)—The number and diversity of students applying to and enrolling in medical schools in the United States increased this year, new data shows.

Recommended for you

Gypsies and travellers on the English Green Belt

Oct 17, 2014

The battle between Gypsies, Travellers and the settled community over how land can be used has moved to the Green Belt, observes Peter Kabachnik of the City University of New York.

Cadavers beat computers for learning anatomy

Oct 16, 2014

Despite the growing popularity of using computer simulation to help teach college anatomy, students learn much better through the traditional use of human cadavers, according to new research that has implications ...

Mongolian women 'want status over big families'

Oct 16, 2014

A new study suggests the aspirations of women in Mongolia have rapidly shifted. Before the rapid economic transition of the 1990s, the wealthiest women in the Communist-style era had big families. However, ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

jshloram
5 / 5 (1) Jul 24, 2013
How could anyone find this conclusion surprising. It is my experience that successful people attribute success (especial their own success) to "personal traits". To admit that they have been fortunate would suggest that they don't deserve their success.
zaxxon451
not rated yet Aug 05, 2013
How could anyone find this conclusion surprising. It is my experience that successful people attribute success (especial their own success) to "personal traits". To admit that they have been fortunate would suggest that they don't deserve their success.


Good point. Their mindset also enables them to demonize the poor.