Exaggeration, exaggeration, exaggeration: Parties over-egg claims on education

Jun 26, 2013

The report, led by Professor Anthony Heath from The University of Manchester, says governments mostly fail to introduce policies which can be rigorously evaluated.

The report, published this month in the Oxford Review of Economic Policy, praises Labour 's policy on further and Education Maintenance Allowance.

The Blair and Brown administrations he says, also presided over narrowing inequalities of for secondary school students.

And it accepts that New Labour acted on its promises to prioritize education: education spending as a percentage of GDP, grew from 4.5% in 1996/7 to 6.2 per cent in 2010/11.

However, the report draws no firm conclusion on the key areas of educational standards and university tuition fees.

And it is also unclear, it adds, if the narrowing inequalities were down to autonomous developments in society, the continuation of previous education policies not reversed by Labour, or new initiatives.

Only a 2008 evaluation of the 'literacy hour' and a 2004 evaluation of EMAs, which convincingly show positive results, were robust, it says.

The reports co-authors include Dr Alice Sullivan from Institute of Education, University of London, Dr Vikki Boliver, Durham University and Dr Anna Zimdars, King's College London.

Professor Heath, Professor of Sociology at the Institute for Social Change in the School of Social Sciences, received a CBE in the Queen's Birthday Honours list this month.

He said: "New Labour has claimed that its 13 years in power have boosted standards, which is hotly challenged by the Conservatives.

"But the biggest story is how both sides over-claim about their respective successes and failures and the poor quality and lack of decent statistical data.

"But it does seem that on balance, there was little change over time in British levels of educational attainment relative to those in other countries

"We would not rule out, however, the possibility that absolute standards did rise modestly."

He added: "Despite the resources devoted to policy evaluations by the New Labour government, which declared a belief in 'evidence-driven policy', much of evidence is disappointingly uninformative

"The problem with official evaluations is that they range from researchers drawing appropriately tentative conclusions in the face of difficult methodological issues, to essentially puff-pieces for government policies.

"The changes in the definitions, and the incentives for schools to play the system, mean that little confidence can be placed on official pronouncements about the magnitude of any increase in standards.

"We are also inclined to be skeptical about the effectiveness of measures continued from previous Conservative governments such as testing, league tables, and parental choice.

"There is no independent evidence that these have done anything to drive up standards."

Explore further: Startups should seek quality—not quantity—in partnerships, study finds

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Historian bids to solve education whodunnit

May 02, 2013

A political historian from The University of Manchester is bidding to solve the mystery of why the UK's colleges of education suddenly disappeared in the 1970s.

Proposed exam reforms 'unlikely to drive up standards'

May 09, 2013

A report by Oxford University's Centre for Educational Assessment says there is little evidence to support government claims that standards of examinations have fallen in England, and argues that the government's ...

New Zealand women buck global voting trend

Jun 25, 2013

Research carried out at Victoria University has found little difference in how men and women cast their party vote at the 2011 New Zealand general election, except in the case of one political party.

National education policy -- oh, how it's changed

Aug 18, 2012

The way legislators, experts and other opinion leaders discuss the role of parents and schools in reducing educational inequalities has changed dramatically since the Elementary and Secondary Education Act first passed in ...

Recommended for you

Insider trading study shows stronger enforcement

Oct 23, 2014

The first major study of the enforcement of Australia's insider trading laws has shown the number of insider trading cases brought by the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) is increasing, ...

The unexpected benefits of adjustable rate mortgages

Oct 22, 2014

Using loan level data matched to consumer credit records, researchers have been able to determine that a reduction in mortgage payments of as little as $150 a month spurred a reduction in mortgage defaults and an increase ...

User comments : 0