# Novel methods to support decision making processes

##### Jan 24, 2013

Mathematical analysis based on numbers and numerical estimates is widely used in decision making everywhere from public administration and business to environmental conservation. Methods for decision analysis evaluate different alternatives with regard to several criteria. The more attributes and possible options, from which to make decisions there are, and the larger the amount of available data, the more complex the analysis gets – and it begins to escape the grasp of decision makers.

Aalto University researcher Antti Punkka has studied in his doctoral dissertation for the Department of Mathematics and Systems Analysis how to improve multi-criteria decision and efficiency analysis by asking decision makers relevant and easy questions and producing decision recommendations that are transparent and straightforward to understand.

In multi-attribute situations there are rarely univocally optimal solutions, and this requires including the decision maker's preferences and values in the analysis models.

The new model finds the right alternatives

Punkka has studied so-called additive value functions, which are in their simplest form familiar from product comparisons where a range of products are reviewed against each other according to certain criteria. Traditionally these methods require exact numerical values as .

Punkka, on the other hand, has come up with models that are based on rank-based information about the alternatives. These models promote the consideration of the decision maker's preferences and values.

The models Punkka has created give recommendations for decision making also when the properties of the alternatives and the preferences of the decision make are expressed in the form of incomplete ordinal information – not as exact numerical values. The decision maker can for instance recognise two best alternatives according to certain criteria, not having to consider, which of them is better.

The model lists the preferences of multiple decision makers

The models developed in the dissertation have proven to be useful in situations where the same model is used to depict the preferences of several decision makers. The methods have been used for instance to support traffic infrastructure maintenance planning.

"A decision maker can compare, say, the value of the effects of reducing road salting as relative to the value of increasing accidents. The models we have created do not necessitate numerical statements in comparing these values."

"In organisations in which decision processes need to be transparent – for example in ventures within public administration – preferences are not defined and decisions made by a single decision maker but groups," Punkka points out.

"My research and the algorithms I have developed could raise the bar in the quality of the recommendations models give to decision makers. The should be in line with the preferences and values of the decision makers. We strive to make the use of the models increasingly transparent, all the way from defining preferences and modelling them mathematically to presenting results."

A model to measure the efficiency of decision making units

Punkka and his colleagues also combine in an unprecedented way the properties of rank-based computation to efficiency analysis. In it the efficiencies of decision-making units are compared based on the ratio of their multi-criteria output and input values.

The developed methods enable for example analyses of how sensitive the decision-making units' efficiencies are to the relative values of different output and input criteria

"Our methods will surely receive a lot of attention: they provide a variety of completely new approaches to efficiency analyses," trusts Punkka.

Antti Punkka's dissertation "Rank-based information in multi-attribute decision and efficiency analysis" available online (pdf).

Explore further: Optimising the future with mathematics

## Related Stories

#### Managerial role associated with more automatic decision-making

Aug 22, 2012

Managers and non-managers show distinctly different brain activation patterns when making decisions, according to research published Aug. 22 in the open access journal PLOS ONE.

#### Carpal tunnel syndrome patients prefer to share decision-making with their physicians

Aug 08, 2011

Patients receiving treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) prefer to play a more collaborative role when it comes to making decisions about their medical or surgical care, according to the findings of an August 3rd issue ...

#### FDA could analyze public health consequences of its decisions better

May 09, 2011

A new report from the National Research Council lays out a framework for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to systematically evaluate and compare the public health consequences of its decisions concerning a wide variety ...

#### Numerous factors weighed when patients cannot make their own decisions

Mar 22, 2010

Living wills and surrogate decision makers account for only a portion of the many factors weighed by physicians when making medical decisions for hospitalized patients lacking the capability to make their ...

#### Shared decision-making between doctors and patients can reduce antibiotic use

Jul 30, 2012

A training tool that helps physicians involve patients in decision-making can reduce the use of antibiotics for acute respiratory infections, according to a study published in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal). ...

#### Patients and clinicians must share healthcare decisions, say experts

Mar 22, 2011

Clinicians have an ethical imperative to share important decisions with patients, and patients have a right to be equal participants in their care, say a group of experts today.

## Recommended for you

#### Optimising the future with mathematics

3 hours ago

How will science address the challenges of the future? In collaboration with Australia's chief scientist Ian Chubb, we're asking how each science discipline will contribute to Australia now and in the fu ...

#### Strong teams attract crowds for international cricket

Mar 06, 2014

The strength of the team—not the promise of a close contest—is the biggest draw to crowds in international cricket, new research has found.

#### Improving radiation therapies for cancer mathematically

Mar 05, 2014

In a paper published in December in the SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, authors Li-Tien Cheng, Bin Dong, Chunhua Men, Xun Jia, and Steve Jiang propose a method to optimize radiation therapy treatments in cancer patien ...

#### Computational study finds maximum packing density of 55,000 different shapes

Mar 05, 2014

A team of researchers at the University of Michigan has used computational and analytical analysis to find the maximum packing density of 55,000 uniquely shaped particles. In their paper published in the ...

#### Secret to the perfect pancake is discovered

Mar 04, 2014

In a collaboration with Meadowhall Shopping Centre, students from the University's Maths Society (SUMS) developed, trialled and tested a formula which enables pancake-lovers across the world to rustle-up ...

##### BishopBalderdash
1 / 5 (1) Jan 25, 2013
A nice attempt to get around Arrow's impossibility theorem
##### Doug_Huffman
2.3 / 5 (3) Mar 22, 2013
I believe that sortition moots Arrow with all other elites.

## More news stories

#### The business of fear: Can our favorite products provide emotional support?

Worried that you could be in a car accident? Insurance company X can protect you and your family. Afraid you will lose your children to drunk driving? MADD can help you educate them to avoid drinking and driving. According ...

#### New analyses verify the use of fire by Peking Man

Zhoukoudian Locality 1 in northern China has been widely known for the discovery of the Middle Pleistocene human ancestor Homo erectus pekinensis ( known as Peking Man ) since the 1920s. By 1931, the suggestion ...

#### They're grrrreat! How do brands create loyalty that lasts a lifetime?

From a very young age, children are targeted with advertising messages that emphasize fun and happiness, especially for food products and toys. But what happens to these beliefs once the child is grown? According to a new ...

#### Time versus money? Placing a value on buyer's remorse

From a product's price to its convenience, ease of use, and number of overall features, many factors play into getting the most "bang for your buck." According to a new study in the Journal of Consumer Research, when it com ...

#### Emotional expressions in ancient funerary art served as therapy for the bereaved

Emotional expressions on Greek tombstones from the Hellenistic period (323-31 B.C.) help increase our understanding of social communication and cultural values. This is the conclusion of a doctoral thesis ...

#### How Twitter shapes public opinion

How exactly does Twitter, with its 241 million users tweeting out 500 million messages daily, shape public opinion?

#### Robots, hands-free wizardry wows at high-tech fair

A "toddler" robot that sees red, a digital master chef and a suitcase that never gets lost—new technology at the world's biggest high-tech fair has the potential to change lives.

#### Researchers identify decision-making center of brain

(Medical Xpress)—Although choosing to do something because the perceived benefit outweighs the financial cost is something people do daily, little is known about what happens in the brain when a person ...

#### A new way to tune X-ray laser pulses

(Phys.org) —A new system at SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory's X-ray laser narrows a rainbow spectrum of X-ray colors to a more intense band of light, creating a much more powerful way to view fine ...

#### California mulls how to regulate 'driverless cars'

California's Department of Motor Vehicles is wading into the complex question of how to regulate the use of cars that rely on computers—not people—to drive them.