New study shows federal proxy rule benefited shareholders

December 17, 2012
Joanna T. Campbell

(—A federal regulation established in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis improved shareholder value before a federal appeals court struck it down, according to a study by Joanna T. Campbell, a management professor at the University of Arkansas, and her colleagues.

The so-called proxy access rule, implemented by the federal in the summer of 2010, would have empowered shareholders to more directly affect the composition of a company's board. The measure stemmed from the Dodd-Frank Act, the intended financial regulatory overhaul of Wall Street that aimed to improve the current system.

In July 2011, the U.S. for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected the commission's proxy access rule, calling it "arbitrary" and "capricious." The commission subsequently announced that it would not challenge the court's ruling.

"Our findings consistently show that the rule benefited shareholders, especially for firms with lower board independence or greater CEO control," Campbell said. "The exciting aspect of this study is that it has significant public policy implications. The appeals court said the commission did not conduct a sufficient to show value creation as a result of this rule. That is exactly what our paper does. The results speak for themselves."

The study results appear in the in the December issue of . Campbell is the lead author.

The rule would have allowed shareholders who have held at least 3 percent of the firm's stock for at least three years to nominate their own candidates to the board. Their nominees would be limited to a quarter of the total membership of the board. For example, if the board is comprised of eight members, a large long-term shareholder could nominate up to two candidates.

"This would only guarantee their inclusion on the ballot, and they would be subject to the same election process," Campbell said.

The study examined the market's reaction to the original passage of the rule in August 2010. The authors found a large financial upswing in the stock price for firms with multiple shareholders who would benefit from the rule.

"Shareholders seem to be concerned about managerial power over the board," she said.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Business Roundtable, an association of chief executive officers, challenged the proxy rule in a federal lawsuit. The ruling by the three-judge federal appeals panel was considered a victory for corporate America. In light of the study's findings, it may be a loss for shareholders, said Campbell, who hopes to share the findings with the commission.

Campbell had four co-authors on the paper: Colin Campbell of Miami University in Ohio, David Sirmon of the University of Washington, Leonard Bierman of Texas A&M University and Christopher Tuggle of the University of Nebraska.

Explore further: Briefs: Fred Campbell to join FCC

Related Stories

Briefs: Fred Campbell to join FCC

December 2, 2005

FCC Chairman Kevin J. Martin announced Friday that Fred Campbell will serve as his legal adviser for Wireless Issues.

Court rules against Bush administration

March 20, 2006

A federal appeals court has overturned a clean-air regulation issued by the Bush administration, ruling in favor of environmental advocacy groups.

Yahoo shareholder pushes for its board nominees

March 21, 2012

(AP) -- One of Yahoo's major investors is urging shareholders to vote its four nominees on to the Internet company's board, launching a potentially nasty fight to transform the Internet company's board.

Recommended for you

Biologists trace how human innovation impacts tool evolution

November 24, 2015

Many animals exhibit learned behaviors, but humans are unique in their capacity to build on existing knowledge to make new innovations. Understanding the patterns of how new generations of tools emerged in prehistoric societies, ...

How experienced buyers can mitigate economic bubbles

November 19, 2015

(—Over the last decade, many people got a tough primer on the effects of economic bubbles, as the bursting of the 2007-2008 housing bubble sent shockwaves through most of the major world economies. But property ...

First Londoners were multi-ethnic mix: museum

November 23, 2015

A DNA analysis of four ancient Roman skeletons found in London shows the first inhabitants of the city were a multi-ethnic mix similar to contemporary Londoners, the Museum of London said on Monday.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.