Japan's gadget failures: The futures that never happened

Nov 11, 2012 by Miwa Suzuki
Home electrical appliances collector Kenichi Masuda displays Toshiba's "Walking Type Toaster WT-2" (L) and "Snack-3" cooking machine in Tokyo. For Masuda, these quixotic gadgets show the bravery and idealism of Japanese companies in a high-growth era. Japanese consumer electronics evolved from this trial-and-error period to sweep the world in the late 20th century

It gave us the Walkman, the pocket calculator and heated toilet seats, but Japan's path to innovative greatness is littered with failures such as the TV-shaped radio and the "walking" toaster.

These and other retro appliances are part of a treasure-trove offering a glimpse of futures that never happened on Japan's journey to becoming a worldwide byword for invention during the late 1950s and early 1960s.

"Way back before Cool Japan was an Uncool Japan," said Kenichi Masuda, 49, referencing the marketing slogan Tokyo uses to sell itself at home and abroad.

Masuda has made a life's work of gathering the also-rans in the race to consumer supremacy.

Witness Iwatsu Electric's "Both Phone"—two telephones attached back to back with only one receiver, apparently to allow someone to make calls from either side. But only one at a time.

Marvel at Fuji Electric's double-decked electric fan—the "Silent Pair", which definitely is a pair, but not exactly silent.

Browsing Masuda's collection sends the viewer through a portal to a different time, a period when the "three sacred treasures"—the television, refrigerator and washing machine—were status symbols to which all self-respecting housewives in booming Japan would aspire.

But for those who could not afford a real television—Japan's first domestically-produced set cost the equivalent of three years' salary for a mid-1950s high school graduate —the next best thing was readily available.

Kenichi Masuda shows off Hitachi's grand piano-shaped electric fan "Piano" in Tokyo. It gave us the Walkman, the pocket calculator and heated toilet seats, but Japan's path to innovative greatness is littered with failures.

The "Sharp Cinema Super" is a radio in the shape of a television and cost 10,900 yen—a little more than a month's salary for an elite public servant of the time.

"The delight of having the impression of would, however, fade quickly with this still screen, " said Masuda, adding: "I bet the man who bought this was scolded by his wife."

Panasonic's television-shaped gas stove GSF-1 is the most expensive model among a range of gas heaters the company sold over 30 years.

"Is there any real meaning in this? No, but this shows how people admired television sets," he said as he showed AFP the stove, one of the 2,000 items he has amassed over nearly three decades.

Other marvels include the "satellite-type" washing machine—a round metal pod with a handle that stirs dirty laundry in water and detergent.

The product was launched in 1957, amid public excitement over the Soviet Union's Sputnik, the world's first artificial satellite.

Sharp's "Quicky"—a pair of electric scissors and Toshiba's prosaically named "CK-31A" electric can opener were both failures.

Hitachi's "Piano" is a desk-top electric fan that is, for no discernable reason, shaped like a miniature piano and is supposed to emit a gently scented breeze.

Not to be confused with typical hotel "conveyor belt" toasters, Toshiba's "walking-type toaster" has a slit entrance for the slice of bread, which is then "walked" vertically down inside the toaster on metal rails.

File picture. A campaign girl shows off a Sony mini disk Walkman MZ-R50 at the Japan Electronics Show '97 in Chiba in 1997. At the time a sleek new invention, the Walkman looks oversized and ugly in comparison to devices now on the market.

When the toast eventually emerges at the other end, it feels like a major achievement.

"This didn't sell. There's no way 's small kitchens had room for a product whose size and price were twice those of common models," Masuda said.

His personal favourite in this category is Toshiba's "Snack-3", a device that can warm milk while toasting a slice of bread and frying an egg.

Would-be consumers might have seen through this one.

"People may have wanted to have Western-Style breakfast at the time... though you would become tired of that fairly quickly," he said.

For Masuda, these quixotic gadgets show the bravery and idealism of Japanese companies in a high-growth era that was crowned by the 1964 Tokyo Olympics and the launch of bullet trains.

"They are adorable. You can see how they came about from companies pouring so much effort in to pleasing customers. It's just that sometimes, these efforts backfired," said Masuda.

"But they were serious products made by adults for adults."

Japanese consumer electronics evolved from this trial-and-error period to sweep the world in the late 20th century—with Sony's standing as perhaps the epitome of Nippon Know-how.

But then it all went wrong.

For Kenichi Masuda, 49, these quixotic gadgets show the bravery and idealism of Japanese companies in a high-growth era that was crowned by the 1964 Tokyo Olympics and the launch of bullet trains.

Household names that appeared almost indestructible in the 1980s—Panasonic, Sharp and Sony—are shadows of their former selves, struggling to keep up with their South Korean and Taiwanese rivals.

For Masuda, these companies lost their nimbleness and their playful sense of adventure when they got too large.

"As they grew bigger and bigger, they became mindful of 'marketing,' 'profitability', 'safety' and the like. They may have become too slow to act," he said.

"But companies in this period were vigorous and had a 'go-for-it' spirit. They weren't afraid of failures."

So how do they get back to their roots?

That, admits Masuda, has him stumped.

"If I knew that, I'd be a company president."

Explore further: WellPoint 2Q tops Wall Street expectations

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Toshiba shares jump as it drops Japan TV operations

May 17, 2012

Toshiba shares surged almost six percent Thursday after saying it had stopped making televisions in Japan where a strong yen has hurt exports as slow demand and falling prices also ate into earnings.

Japan Inc. faces 'tectonic changes': analysts

Apr 02, 2012

Sharp's announcement that it will team up with Taiwan's Hon Hai Precision on a liquid-crystal display deal is the latest example of the "tectonic changes" rippling through hard-hit Japan Inc.

Toshiba to launch first glasses-free 3D TV

Aug 24, 2010

Japanese electronics giant Toshiba plans to market the world's first 3D television that does not need special glasses later this year, a report said on Tuesday.

Recommended for you

Why let your sales force influence product prices?

10 hours ago

From the outside, you might not notice the ongoing tension within many large businesses: the battle between salespeople, on the one hand, and marketers and product managers, on the other. Because the salespeople ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

alfie_null
4 / 5 (1) Nov 11, 2012
The inevitable result of becoming large. Owners of companies that are large have different expectations. Taking risks isn't part of those expectations.
VendicarD
4 / 5 (1) Nov 11, 2012
Sony certainly isn't afraid of taking risks.

Witness the grandeur of the Sony Rolly.

http://www.youtub...dKi77G20
ch2co
not rated yet Nov 11, 2012
Sorry guys, the walking toaster was a success, back in the '40's and 50's but made in the good old USA. Had a friend who had one, double slicer at that. Made GREAT toast.
TheBoss
not rated yet Nov 11, 2012
Sony certainly isn't afraid of taking risks.
Witness the grandeur of the Sony Rolly.
http://www.youtub...dKi77G20

Sadly the Sony rolly was only released to japan. I wish companies would be inventive again. If i seen a cool unique product on the shelf i would buy it. There is hardly any competion on the market it's starting to become stagnate.