Premiership referees more like to book foreign ethnic minority players

Oct 08, 2012

(—A major analysis of referee's decisions in the Premier League has shown that officials are around 15% more likely to book foreign players who are from the same background as the most sizable ethnic minority groups in the UK.

The analysis by researchers from the Universities of Birmingham, and used the extensive in-match dataset collected by OPTA Sportsdata for the 2006-07 and 2007-08 seasons covering 760 games in total.

This included time-stamped and spatial data on every single action (e.g. passes, tackles, crosses, dribblings, etc.) in each of the matches, as well as information about individual including their position, age, height and the type of game (e.g. local derby). Using such detailed data allowed the researchers to rule out the possibility that the higher level of bookings reflects a more aggressive style of play.

Instead they conclude these patterns point to the presence of what dub "implicit discrimination". This is the unconscious association between members of a social group and a negative attribute.

Dr James Reade from the University of Birmingham explains: "The results of the analysis were very clear that referees are more like to book foreign players who are from the same background as the most sizable in the UK.

We analysed a huge range of factors taking into account the player's style, age and position as well as data about individual matches. This means we are confident this is not the product of playing style but other factors.

We do not believe that this is deliberate discrimination on behalf of referees indeed they are probably completely unaware that this issue exists. Instead this comes from the unconscious mental association between members of a and a negative attribute."

The researchers were able to show that this is implicit discrimination, instead of a conscious form of discrimination based on, e.g., referees dislike for a certain group of players, by performing a detailed analysis of the types of offences being punished, where on the pitch offences occurred and the state of the game at the time. Two issues seemed to be particularly important:

The level of discrimination increased the more rushed the referee was in taking a decision, which happens when players are trying to put the ball back in play quickly to keep the game moving

The level of discrimination also increases when there is more room for debate on a decision. So discrimination was more evident in yellow cards given for fouls (which are always debatable) as opposed to those for excessive celebration or referee abuse which are not

Dr. Edoardo Gallo from the University of Cambridge adds:  "Psychologists have shown that implicit discrimination is the by-product of very rapid, unconscious cognitive processes that replace deliberate, conscious decision-making when there is no time to make a decision or it takes too much effort due to the ambiguity and complexity of the situation.

It is not surprising that referees resort to these rapid, unconscious decision-making processes during high paced games where some debatable decisions cannot even be resolved by expert pundits sitting in Match of the Day's comfortable studio..

The results of this research, which looked at two complete Premiership seasons, are clear and something we would like football authorities to consider: are top professionals that are doing their best, but they are humans and need to receive adequate support to avoid the pitfalls of fast decision-making in a complex setting."

Explore further: Why plants in the office make us more productive

More information: The paper: Punishing the Foreigner: Implicit Discrimination in the Premier League Based on Oppositional, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Stereotypes, bias and personnel decisions

Dec 03, 2008

In an article in the December issue of the journal Industrial and Organizational Psychology, Frank J. Landy questions research that is said to demonstrate that stereotypes about social groups bias personnel decisions. He arg ...

Recommended for you

Precarious work schedules common among younger workers

Aug 29, 2014

One wish many workers may have this Labor Day is for more control and predictability of their work schedules. A new report finds that unpredictability is widespread in many workers' schedules—one reason ...

Girls got game

Aug 29, 2014

Debi Taylor has worked in everything from construction development to IT, and is well and truly socialised into male-dominated workplaces. So when she found herself the only female in her game development ...

Computer games give a boost to English

Aug 28, 2014

If you want to make a mark in the world of computer games you had better have a good English vocabulary. It has now also been scientifically proven that someone who is good at computer games has a larger ...

Saddam Hussein—a sincere dictator?

Aug 28, 2014

Are political speeches manipulative and strategic? They could be – when politicians say one thing in public, and privately believe something else, political scientists say. Saddam Hussein's legacy of recording private discussions ...

User comments : 0