Zynga fires back in legal war with Electronic Arts

Sep 15, 2012
Zynga returned fire in a battle with Electronic Arts, accusing the videogame veteran of using unlawful tactics to squash competition from the newcomer which rose to stardom via Facebook.

Zynga on Friday returned fire in a battle with Electronic Arts, accusing the videogame veteran of using unlawful tactics to squash competition from the newcomer which rose to stardom via Facebook.

In a response to a suit filed by EA in a US federal court in San Francisco, Zynga rejected claims it illegally copied a "Sims" title and charged the chief of EA was "on the warpath" after Zynga poached some of its workers.

"Today we responded to EA's claims which we believe have no merit," Zynga general counsel Reggie Davis said in a release.

Davis said Zynga also filed a counterclaim addressing "anticompetitive and unlawful business practices, including and demands for no-hire agreements."

"This is a subterfuge aimed at diverting attention from Zynga's persistent of other artists and studios," EA spokesman John Reseburg said in response to an AFP inquiry.

"Zynga would be better served trying to hold onto the shrinking number of employees they've got, rather than suing to acquire more."

EA last month filed suit claiming Zynga's game "The Ville" illegally copied the life simulator "The Sims Social."

"The core legal issue is our belief that Zynga infringed copyrights to our game, The Sims Social," said Lucy Bradshaw, general manager of EA's Maxis label.

The Sims Social is among the life-simulation games from -based EA.

The Ville, one of the top games played on , has been described as "very similar" to The Sims Social but "not a complete clone" by a reviewer at the website Inside .

"The truth is that despite years of trying to compete, and spending more than a billion dollars on acquisitions, EA has not been able to successfully compete in the social gaming space and was losing talent, particularly to social gaming leader Zynga," the social games company said in its filing.

"EA sought, by threat of objectively and subjectively baseless sham litigation, what it could never lawfully obtain from Zynga—a no-hire agreement that would bar Zynga's hiring of EA employees."

Explore further: Facebook CEO wants more students to explore tech

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Suit says Zynga copied 'Sims Social' game

Aug 03, 2012

US videogames giant Electronic Arts said Friday it had filed suit claiming Zynga's game "The Ville" illegally copied the life simulator "The Sims Social."

Zynga chief operating officer leaves the game

Aug 09, 2012

Zynga's chief operating officer folded his cards on Wednesday, leaving the social games company just as heavyweight Amazon.com steps into the ring and rival Electronic Arts (EA) takes it to court.

Chief creative officer leaves Zynga

Aug 29, 2012

Another top Zynga executive has cashed in his chips as the social games company behind "Zynga Poker" and "Farmville" strives to improve its fortunes after a losing fiscal quarter.

Zynga sues French startup over "Ville" game

May 08, 2012

Zynga is out to strip "Ville" from the name of a social game made by French firm Kobojo on the grounds it piggybacks on a line of its titles including "CityVille" and "FarmVille."

US videogame maker EA in deal with Facebook

Nov 02, 2010

Electronic Arts said Tuesday that it has reached a five-year agreement with Facebook that calls for the social network's virtual currency to be the exclusive payment method for EA games.

Recommended for you

Alibaba prices IPO at $68 per share

7 hours ago

Alibaba, the Chinese e-commerce powerhouse named after a fabled, poor woodsman who discovers a thieves' den full of treasures, is ready to strike it rich on the New York Stock Exchange.

Larry Ellison releases helm of mighty Oracle ship

10 hours ago

Tycoon yachtsman Larry Ellison on Thursday stepped down as Oracle's chief executive, trusting a pair of lieutenants to steer the titanic business software firm he helped launch decades ago.

Alibaba's plan: Today, China. Tomorrow, the world.

14 hours ago

Amazon and eBay should watch their backs. As Chinese e-commerce powerhouse Alibaba readies what could be the biggest initial public offering ever on the New York Stock Exchange, it is quietly hinting at plans ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

MarkyMark
not rated yet Sep 15, 2012
Well EA is a well known dirty player so yea!

TehDog
not rated yet Sep 15, 2012
True, but in this case, having seen a whole bunch of comparison screenshots (this is quite old news) EA are right, ville looks and plays almost identically to the sims. All the tit-for-tat stuff that will now ensue make this popcorn time...
Oh, and this isn't the first time someone has cried foul over zynga's blatant plagiarism of others work, the difference is, EA have money.
Much more info and better informed comments to be found here -->
http://www.rockpa...a-stand/
TheQuietMan
not rated yet Sep 15, 2012
EA is where all good games go to die, ignored to death by their new owners. It is usually the kiss of death to be bought up by them.
Meyer
3 / 5 (2) Sep 15, 2012
Burger King hamburgers look a lot like McDonald's hamburgers. Pepsi looks and tastes like Coke. Copyright laws are broken if creating a game from scratch is considered infringement, no matter how much inspiration was gained from the original. That's competition.