New Yorkers bring fish farms to urban jungle

April 27, 2012 by Sebastian Smith
Children arrive at a community center in the south Bronx for a session with the Society for Aquaponic Values and Education (SAVE) on April 19. SAVE teaches aquaponics to about 80 children each week in this socio-economically disadvantaged neighborhood.

So you recycle, drive a small car, and try to eat organic. But what about running an eco-sustainable fish farm combined with a naturally fertilized vegetable patch in your kitchen?

Christopher Toole and Anya Pozdeeva, two former New York bankers who founded the Society for Aquaponic Values and Education (SAVE), are there to help.

"We call it 'beyond organic,'" Pozdeeva, 39, said.

Aquaponics is a technique with ancient roots for breeding tank , recycling their effluent-filled water to fertilize vegetation, then allowing this naturally cleaned water to drip back into the tank below.

It's a perfect, miniature eco system that will let you grow healthy food right in a cramped apartment with almost no specialist equipment.

"We built our system just from trash cans," said Pozdeeva, a slender woman who emigrated from Russia's Siberian region 20 years ago and still speaks English with a gentle accent.

If growing fish to eat in your New York apartment sounds unlikely, then Toole and Pozdeeva are even unlikelier urban eco pioneers.

Just a short time ago they were bankers working crazy hours among the skyscrapers of Manhattan, a far cry from the gritty Bronx where they are based today.

Christopher Toole leads a group of children to teach them aquaponics at a community center in the south Bronx in New York, on April 19. Toole and his wife Anya Pozdeeva, two former New York bankers, founded the Society for Aquaponic Values and Education (SAVE)

After the 2008 financial crash floored the banking industry, Toole, a vice president at Sovereign Bank, discovered he had a serious eye problem, which he says was stress-related.

And both of them were severely disenchanted with their careers.

"They know how to squeeze every drop out of you and then throw you away," Pozdeeva said.

"We wanted two feet on the ground," said Toole, 47, and striking-looking with a bushy gray beard and pork pie hat.

Instead, he put two feet in the water.

Toole knew a little about fish from childhood summers with his scientist father out at Woods Hole in Massachusetts, a famed marine biology research center in the Cape Cod area. Aquaponics, he reckoned, would let him marry sustainable food production with what he hopes will be an equally sustainable business model.

Risky? Yes.

Christopher Toole teaches aquaponics, a technique for breeding tank fish, recycling their effluent-filled water to fertilize vegetation, then allowing this naturally cleaned water to drip back into the tank below, at a community center in the south Bronx on April 19.

"But understanding risks is something they teach you a lot about in banking," he said.

Each week Toole and Pozdeeva teach aquaponics to about 80 children at SAVE's base at a community center in the south Bronx, one of the most socio-economically disadvantaged neighborhoods in the United States.

During a recent session, the couple got youngsters to help in everything from cleaning fish tanks to planting mint, cabbage, and other greenery.

The children, more familiar with the Bronx's concrete jungle, were quick to get involved.

"I'm afraid he's going to come up and bite me," a small girl giggled as she put her hand into the top of a barrel containing large tilapia.

"Well, he's afraid you're going to go down and bite him," reasoned Toole.

When two boys turned from gardening duties to a mud fight, Pozdeeva calmly stepped in. "Dirt is precious," she reminded. The boys got back to gardening.

Toole breeds several fish in his trash can farms, but tilapia do best.

Christopher Toole teaches children about aquaponics, a technique for breeding tank fish, recycling their effluent-filled water to fertilize vegetation, then allowing this naturally cleaned water to drip back into the tank below, at a community center in the south Bronx on April 19.

They require just five to 10 gallons (19 to 38 liters) of water and by nine months are big enough to eat. Besides, they can be entirely vegetarian and seem to like duck weed, a grainy green plant which Toole and Pozdeeva scoop up from ponds in the Bronx's big Van Cortland Park, then drop into their tanks.

"It's illegal, but on the other hand it's choking the pond, so you could argue we're doing it as a favor," Toole said of the freelance weed harvesting expeditions.

In addition to the teaching, Toole and Pozdeeva sell tiny tilapia fingerlings to customers at $5 a head via their website, Facebook and other sites.

SAVE is barely a year old. But Toole and Pozdeeva clearly have many more fish to fry.

Toole is eyeing partnerships with chefs, other urban fish breeders, and consultancy work for newcomers. But having escaped the banking world, he doesn't want to end up serving a new master, or "selling our soul," as he puts it.

There seems little danger of that.

Pozdeeva has discovered that mushrooms, growing on a simple piece of cardboard, thrive in the same warm, dark, damp conditions that tilapia like. And Toole is excited about branching out into honey production.

"Right now I have 10,000 bees in our living room," he says. "So I'm not just sleeping with fish, but with bees."

In fact, all that could stymie their green revolution, it seems, are New York's notoriously tight rules on pets in apartment buildings.

"We basically need to keep it kind of quiet," Pozdeeva said about their domestic fish colonies. "But that's the good thing about fish."

Explore further: The case for oversharing

Related Stories

The case for oversharing

June 24, 2010

There's been a lot of squealing of late over our rapidly eroding privacy on the Web, with the finger of accusation pointed directly at those sneaky Facebook folks. Founder Mark Zuckerberg is now the Snidely Whiplash of the ...

Facial recognition techniques studied by BBS team

September 15, 2010

Rapid improvements in facial-recognition software mean airport security workers might one day know with near certainty whether they're looking at a stressed-out tourist or staring a terrorist in the eye.

New study puts eco-labels to the test

December 7, 2011

A new report released today by the University of Victoria ranks eco-labels intended to distinguish seafood produced with less damage to the environment. It is the first study to evaluate how eco-labels for farmed marine fish ...

Action needed to keep fish on the menu in 2050

April 23, 2012

The latest study suggests we may still be able to eat as much fish as we do today 40 years from now. But for that to happen, we'll have to change our ways, say scientists.

Recommended for you

Study suggests fish can experience 'emotional fever'

November 25, 2015

(—A small team of researchers from the U.K. and Spain has found via lab study that at least one type of fish is capable of experiencing 'emotional fever,' which suggests it may qualify as a sentient being. In their ...

A huge chunk of a tardigrade's genome comes from foreign DNA

November 23, 2015

Researchers from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill have sequenced the genome of the nearly indestructible tardigrade, the only animal known to survive the extreme environment of outer space, and found something ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

0.6 / 5 (25) Apr 27, 2012
But having escaped the banking world, he doesn't want to end up serving a new master, or "selling our soul," as he puts it.

Much respect for this man Christopher Toole for teaching children, resisting bankers and working towards a better future.
I give you a hand a bow and a hug.
3 / 5 (2) Apr 27, 2012
I'm a very big fan of aquaponics, and would love to see more articles along these lines. However, I would also hope to see more of a specific science angle, given the thrust of this site. For example, they mention a couple of things about tilapia, but I wish they'd say more about why tilapia are kind of the "wonder fish" for aquaponics, and depending on where you are located, why there might be restrictions on their use and/or possession. They could also at some point detail the regional non-tilapia options, since people are doing aquaponics around the globe.

Urban farming is but one valid angle, there are many others, including the benefits "3rd world" communities are realizing from building aquaponics systems.

Overall, very good article. More please.
2 / 5 (4) Apr 27, 2012
1 / 5 (1) Apr 28, 2012
I'm with Stephen, "Here's an idea. Why don't we grow food in blimps - a Chia zepplin?"

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.