Crows are capable of distinguishing symbols, study finds

Oct 10, 2011 by Deborah Braconnier report
Large-billed Crow (Corvus macrorhynchos) in Kullu- Manali District of Himachal Pradesh, India. Image: J.M.Garg, Wikipedia.

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new study published in Animal Behavior shows that crows are capable of recognizing symbols designed to represent different quantities and is one of many different studies currently looking at the behavior and intelligence of crows.

The new study, conducted by a team of led by Shoei Sugita from Utsunomiya University, looked at eight jungle crows. These are a larger, bigger-beaked relative to the American crow. The idea behind the first experiment was to determine if crows were able to determine which container held hidden food based on a symbol on the lid of the container.

The birds were presented with two opaque containers, one with food and one without. The symbols used were the number “two” and the number “five.” The container with the number five on the lid was the one holding the food. When the birds were presented with the containers they had a 70 percent success rate in choosing the container with food.

Other experiments changed up the and used things like shapes and other numbers and the overall results found were that the crows were able to choose the symbol representing food anywhere from 70 to 90 percent of the time. Altogether, the researchers performed 20 different experiments.

The study confirms, according to the researchers, that crows are able to distinguish between quantities of items. Other studies on crows conducted at the Utsunomiya University over the last few years have also determined that crows are capable of distinguishing between the human faces of men and women.

Other studies are currently being conducted on the behaviors and of crows and the researchers hope the information learned will aid other researchers in designing ways to help control the crow populations in the larger cities of Japan where flocks of have become aggressive and bold enough to take food right out of a person’s hand.

Explore further: Scientists announce Top 10 New Species from 2012

More information: Quantity discrimination in jungle crows, Corvus macrorhynchos, Animal Behaviour, Volume 82, Issue 4, October 2011, Pages 635-641. doi:10.1016/j.anbehav.2011.05.025

We investigated whether jungle crows can select a given quantity of items (printouts of shapes and symbols) when simultaneously presented with smaller or larger quantities. We presented jungle crows with the choice between two sets of discrete homogeneous quantities (two versus five) in a fixed configural pattern during training. When crows could discriminate five items (15 out of 20 correct choices in two blocks of 10 trials each), they received control tests for non-numerical cues such as element configuration, shape, and total filled area and novel quantity (3 versus 5, 4 versus 5, 5 versus 6, 5 versus 7 and 5 versus 8) tests. During training, jungle crows learned the discrimination task relatively quickly. Additionally, the selections were generally not controlled by the non-numerical cues, indicating that the crows were responding to quantity. Jungle crows selected the familiar larger quantity in smaller sets (3 versus 5 and 4 versus 5) and the novel larger in larger comparisons (5 versus 7 and 5 versus 8) except that of 5 versus 6 quantities. These results suggest that jungle crows have a natural tendency to select the larger quantities and that decisions were affected by the numerical ratio and stimuli magnitude, indicating the use of analogue magnitude mechanism for numerical judgement, as is observed in other animals.

Related Stories

Not so bird-brained: Clever crows recognise faces

Jun 29, 2011

Humans who dismiss birds as featherweights may revise their opinion when learning of crows which not only can identify the face of someone who is a danger but also teach others about the threat.

Crows demonstrate their cleverness with tools (w/ Video)

Apr 22, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- New Zealand scientists studying New Caledonian crows have found they can use three different tools in succession to gain a food treat. The crows are known to solve problems and fashion and ...

Wild crows reveal tool skills

Jan 11, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new study using motion sensitive video cameras has revealed how New Caledonian crows use tools in the wild, Oxford University scientists report.

Crows can use 'up to three tools'

Aug 05, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- New experiments by Oxford University scientists reveal that New Caledonian crows can spontaneously use up to three tools in the correct sequence to achieve a goal, something never before observed ...

Recommended for you

Scientists announce Top 10 New Species from 2012

4 hours ago

An amazing glow-in-the-dark cockroach, a harp-shaped carnivorous sponge and the smallest vertebrate on Earth are just three of the newly discovered top 10 species selected by the International Institute for ...

New cave-dwelling arachnids discovered in Brazil

16 hours ago

Two new species of cave-dwelling short-tailed whipscorpions have been discovered in northeastern Brazil, and are described in research published May 22 in the open access journal PLOS ONE by Adalberto Santos ...

Do songbirds hold key to stuttering?

21 hours ago

A tiny Australian songbird may hold the answer to discovering the biological source of stuttering, which affects 3 million Americans and is notoriously difficult to treat.

User comments : 10

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

seb
4 / 5 (2) Oct 10, 2011
I saw a report, I think it was on Nature of Things, where they ran experiments with wild crows proving that their young learned things from their parents, such as facial recognition of "bad people", and retained that information to adulthood, or something along those lines.. That as in USA somewhere

It was very interesting, and combined with the above article, it goes to show that mankind is truly not as unique as we assumed as far as brains go.

Isaacsname
5 / 5 (2) Oct 10, 2011
It's not just corvids. For example, I've seen seagulls who were fed snacks from different brightly colored bags with different designs walk into a store, look over a selection of snacks, snatch their favorites and run out. By constant reinforcement and exposure due to tourists feeding them they developed a brand recognition. Not just corvids and gulls either...
sigfpe
not rated yet Oct 10, 2011
@Isaacsname How did you know they were picking their favorites?
Isaacsname
5 / 5 (1) Oct 10, 2011
@Isaacsname How did you know they were picking their favorites?


Because they chose the same thing from a selection every time, black and yellow bag of popcorn. Normally gulls will grab whatever they can, whenever they can, they're also very curious.

http://www.youtub...5B3Fsstg

Astricus
5 / 5 (2) Oct 10, 2011
In my home town in Ireland we have a tight knit family of Crows that has been in the same area for generations. The Crows have their own language. They converse about food, they squabble etc. They have words (sound pattern ) for "Cat" . They also teach the younger crows through demonstration.
Maybe the Japanese should learn their lingo and "Cry Cat"
Cave_Man
not rated yet Oct 10, 2011
Crows are probably as smart as most inner city youth gangs, when I walk outside sometimes they start squawking their little heads off, and they change rhythm and tone when I do different stuff that they understand.

One small species of tweeting birds even picks up patterns from human speech I think, you always hear their newest phrase from "tweet tweet.......TWEET!" to "tweet........tweet TWEET......tweet" etc etc, I really doubt it's random or a mating call, you can tell mating calls from rudimentary communication fairly easily.

Try whistling at a chatty bird sometimes and see if you can understand how it reacts. Sometimes they actually tweet a sarcastic "Stoopid"
sherriffwoody
not rated yet Oct 11, 2011
My cows can distinguish symbols, I go out to the paddock and hold up different signs for what I want the cows to do. e.g. I have a sign for move to the gate, another for hay time, another for move down the race. The picked up suprisingly fast all things considered. I believe animals, in some ways, are smarter than we give them credit for. The learn times of day habits and food sources pretty fast, even those that are supposed to be a little retarded.
Isaacsname
not rated yet Oct 11, 2011
Man, I have a bird feeder next to my window with a small speaker from my computer mounted next to it. I bring up soundboards for all the various animals that come to feed, from birds to chipmunks. Very interesting reactions sometimes.
You guys should try it.
DavidMcC
not rated yet Oct 17, 2011
Isaacsname, have you tried rock music?:
http://www.youtub...vwXRQyh0

:)
Sinister1811
1 / 5 (1) Oct 17, 2011
This comes as no surprise. Parrots are capable of distinguishing between symbols also. Studies have also shown that crows are capable of using tools. They may not look it, but certain types of birds are actually quite clever. There's even recorded instances of escaped pet birds teaching wild birds to talk, which is fascinating (if I could just find the article referring to this).

More news stories

Wildlife losses now stabilising

Efforts to conserve biodiversity in the UK, Belgium and Netherlands may be working, despite the widespread perception that wildlife is in terminal decline, a new study suggests.

Unlocking secrets of cell reproduction

Research published in Open Biology today identifies, for the first time, nearly all the genes required for reproduction of a cell in a living organism.

Weird science: Crystals melt when they're cooled

(Phys.org) —Growing thin films out of nanoparticles in ordered, crystalline sheets, to make anything from microelectronic components to solar cells, would be a boon for materials researchers, but the physics ...

Researchers forward quest for quantum computing

Research teams from UW-Milwaukee and the University of York investigating the properties of ultra-thin films of new materials are helping bring quantum computing one step closer to reality.

Cold plasma successful against brain cancer cells

For the first time, physicists from the Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics (MPE), biologists and physicians demonstrated the synergistic effect of cold atmospheric plasma - a partly ionized ...