Research shows crows comparable to humans when it comes to waiting

September 15, 2011 by Deborah Braconnier, weblog

Corvus brachyrhynchos or Corvus caurinus. Image: Wikipedia.
( -- In a new study published in Royal Society's Biology Letters, researchers have discovered that crows and raven birds show the same ability to complete delayed exchange tasks as monkeys and humans do.

The researchers, led by Dr. Valerie Dufour from the Universite de Strasbourg, began their study by training 12 to exchange tokens for food. They gave each bird a piece of food. Keeping their giving hand closed, they showed the birds the reward in their other hand. After a waiting period, the researchers opened their giving hand again. The birds then received the reward if they gave back the initial piece of food.

The maximum waiting period the researchers used was five minutes and the quality of the reward varied in each exchange. What the birds did during the waiting period varied with some birds leaving the food on the ground or hiding it and checking on it during the time period.

This study shows that the are able to wait before making a decision and that this behavior is not limited to only humans and . While the researchers believed that the birds would be able to wait a few seconds, they were surprised that the birds were able to wait as long as they did.

The destructive behavior, such as hiding the food and checking on it, enabled the crows to wait a longer period of time. Those birds with the longest all displayed this particular destructive behavior.

Explore further: Crows demonstrate their cleverness with tools (w/ Video)

More information: Corvids can decide if a future exchange is worth waiting for, Biol. Lett. Published online before print September 14, 2011, doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2011.0726

Evidence for time-dependent calculations about future rewards is scarce in non-human animals. In non-human primates, only great apes are comparable with humans. Still, some species wait for several minutes to obtain a better reward in delayed exchange tasks. Corvids have been shown to match with non-human primates in some time-related tasks. Here, we investigate a delay of gratification in two corvid species, the carrion crow (Corvus corone) and the common raven (Corvus corax), in an exchange task. Results show that corvids success decreases quickly as delay increases, with a maximal delay of up to 320 s (more than 5 min). The decision to wait rests both on the quality of the prospective reward and the time required to obtain it. Corvids also apply tactics (placing the reward on the ground or caching it) that probably alleviate costs of waiting and distract their attention during waiting. These findings contrast previous results on delayed gratification in birds and indicate that some species may perform comparably to primates.

via ABC

Related Stories

Crows demonstrate their cleverness with tools (w/ Video)

April 22, 2010

( -- New Zealand scientists studying New Caledonian crows have found they can use three different tools in succession to gain a food treat. The crows are known to solve problems and fashion and use tools in the ...

Parrots display teamwork and decision-making skills

May 19, 2011

( -- In a new study published in the journal Animal Cognition, Dr. Dalila Bovet from Paris West University Nanterre La Defense showed how African grey parrots are capable of cooperating and performing tasks as ...

Not so bird-brained: Clever crows recognise faces

June 29, 2011

Humans who dismiss birds as featherweights may revise their opinion when learning of crows which not only can identify the face of someone who is a danger but also teach others about the threat.

Bird can 'read' human gaze

April 2, 2009

We all know that people sometimes change their behavior when someone is looking their way. Now, a new study reported online on April 2nd in Current Biology, a Cell Press publication, shows that jackdaws—birds related to ...

Feed the birds: Winter feeding makes for better breeding

February 6, 2008

Keep feeding the birds over winter: that’s the message from research by the University of Exeter and Queen’s University Belfast, published today (6 February 2008) in the Royal Society journal Biology Letters. The study ...

Gulf Oil Spill Could Affect Maine Bird Populations

July 20, 2010

( -- Even though the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico isn’t likely to directly affect Maine coastal habitats and wildlife, it likely will affect some of the birds that are iconic in Maine, including the common ...

Recommended for you

Why haven't cancer cells undergone genetic meltdowns?

January 15, 2019

Cancer first develops as a single cell going rogue, with mutations that trigger aggressive growth at all costs to the health of the organism. But if cancer cells were accumulating harmful mutations faster than they could ...

Big genome found in tiny forest defoliator

January 15, 2019

The European gypsy moth (EGM) is perhaps the country's most famous invasive insect—a nonnative species accidentally introduced to North America in the 1860s when a few escaped from a breeding experiment in suburban Boston. ...

Gene expression study sheds new light on African Salmonella

January 15, 2019

Scientists at the University of Liverpool have taken another step forward in understanding the bacteria that are causing a devastating Salmonella epidemic currently killing around 400,000 people each year in sub-Saharan Africa.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 15, 2011
The image of the birds waiting for the better food is pretty interesting. Can someone tell me why hiding the food and checking back later is considered 'destructive' behavior? I would have preferred if they had defined it first.
5 / 5 (1) Sep 15, 2011
This concurs with other long-standing evidence that birds are highly intelligent.
1 / 5 (2) Sep 15, 2011
Humans make the mistake of equating a creature's consciousness with its physical size, and consciousness plays a vital role in intelligence.
not rated yet Sep 15, 2011
Nature did not give birds and other animals a useless brain. Birds have proven that they can use their brain to survive the harsh environment ( I am thinking of a 20 to 30 g chickadee that survives the canadian winter) they live in and compete for food and shelter and that is no easy task.
not rated yet Sep 16, 2011
i tell you what...

the chicken trained to play tic-tac-toe would do a better job at finding old links than physorgs search engine.

i love physorg but the search kinda sorta SUCKS!

there was a very interesting article here about how bird brains have been stigmatized as "weird".

they are simply and profoundly more efficient as they have to be light enough for flight and smart enough for fast 3-d navigation as well as all other survival skills.

i have seen sparrows hover in front of motion detectors outside of a grocery store causing the door to open, enter the foyer and then repeat the same behavior with the inner door, successfully infiltrating the GOLD MINE!

try to use search to find the article and if you are successful tell me what terms you used...anybody?
not rated yet Sep 17, 2011

Interesting what I did find. Sufficiently so that I am not going to tell you how I did it.


Where a very similar post or rather a PAIR of posts was made with half of the new post in each. And not by Eric_B, well not by that name. Or even by just ONE name.

The first half was by eric_in_chicago who has a very large time overlap with Eric_B and is clearly the same person.

The second half was by Bob_B, who is still posting here, and thus also apears to be Eric_B.




Got any more sockpuppets Eric-Bob_B_in_chicago?


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.