In bubble-rafting snails, the eggs came first

Oct 10, 2011
A rare bubble-rafting brown janthina snail, Recluzia cf. jehennei. Scientists believe the bubble float evolved from an ancestral egg mass. Credit: Denis Riek

(PhysOrg.com) -- It's "Waterworld" snail style: Ocean-dwelling snails that spend most of their lives floating upside down, attached to rafts of mucus bubbles.

Scientists have known about the snails' peculiar lifestyle since the 1600s, but they've wondered how the rafting habit evolved. What, exactly, were the step-by-step adaptations along the way?

University of Michigan graduate student Celia Churchill and coauthors believe they've found the answer to that intriguing question. In a paper published in the Oct. 11 issue of , they show that bubble rafting evolved by way of modified egg masses.

The bubble-rafting , members of the family Janthinidae, secrete from their "foot," a broad, muscular organ at the base of the snail's body. But instead of using slime to get around or to communicate chemically, as other types of snails do, they trap air inside quick-setting mucus to make bubbles that glom together and form rafts on which the snails spend the rest of their lives.

"We had a pretty good idea that that janthinids evolved from snails that live on the sea floor," Churchill said. The question was, which specific group of snails gave rise to the janthinids, and how did the janthinid lineage make the transition from bottom dwellers to surface surfers?

To find the answer, Churchill and coauthors first sequenced DNA from janthinids and other snail families thought to be closely related to them and used techniques of molecular phylogenetics to identify the ancestral lineage. They discovered that the rafting snails are descendents of snails called wentletraps that parasitize corals and sea anemones. The researchers then asked which specific habits of wentletraps might have morphed over time into raft-building.

Janthina janthina, a bubble-rafting violet snail. This is the most common janthinid species. Credit: Denis Riek

"We thought of two possibilities," said Churchill, who did the work under the direction of Diarmaid Ó Foighil, a professor of ecology and evolutionary biology and a curator of mollusks at the U-M Museum of Zoology. "The first was that bubble rafting evolved from juvenile droguing." In many species of marine snails, the juveniles produce a mucus thread called a drogue that helps them drift from place to place like a kite on a string. Adding air-filled mucus bubbles to the drogue thread could result in something resembling a bubble raft.

The other possibility was that rafts represent modified egg masses. In wentletraps, which belong to the family Epitoniidae, females remain on their hosts, attached by stretchy mucus threads to tethered egg masses. These egg masses typically have egg capsules in various stages of development, from newly encased embryos to empty husks, and the researchers reasoned that in an intertidal species, the empty husks might trap air, making the egg mass and attached female temporarily buoyant. As in the drogue scenario, adding mucus-filled bubbles to this ephemeral raft could lead to development of permanent bubble rafts. Either way, getting to the surface would give the snails access to a completion-free food source: floating jellyfish.

To know which scenario was correct, the researchers needed to find a transitional form---a janthinid with characteristics that fall somewhere between the bottom-dwelling epitoniids and the permanently-rafting janthinid known as the common purple snail (Janthina janthina). They got a break when they received a preserved specimen of the rare rafting snail Recluzia from Australia.

Two female bubble-rafting violet snails, Janthina exigua. Scientists believe the bubble float evolved from an ancestral egg mass. Egg capsules are attached to the underside of the floats. Credit: Denis Riek

"I started to dissect it, and when I pulled the float away I noticed that there were tiny Recluzia on the float and egg capsules of the large female," Churchill said. These hitchhiking juveniles suggested a life history consistent with the egg mass hypothesis. They also suggested an explanation for how the rare Recluzia manages to survive.

"Immediately we started thinking about dwarf males, which are known from a variety of molluscan groups," Churchill said. "If Recluzia has a life history strategy where males remain with females, that might explain how Recluzia can persist at such low densities. When there aren't very many females, remaining with one of them may be the best mating strategy for a male."

The hitchhiking snails were so tiny it was impossible to confirm that they were male, but a recent photograph taken by another researcher clearly shows a larger snail, presumably male, associated with the float of a large female.
Was Recluzia truly the transitional form the researchers were seeking? Or might the transitional form be a species of Janthina, whose juveniles build their own floats, rather than hitchhiking on females' floats---a life history more in line with the juvenile droguing hypothesis? To answer that question, Churchill compared physical characteristics of Recluzia and Janthina with those of the ancestral epitoniids. Recluzia, she found, shares six characteristics with epitoniids; Janthina has none. This finding points to Recluzia as the transitional form, strongly supporting the egg mass hypothesis.

Churchill and colleagues went on to reconstruct the path that led from egg mass to bubble raft. In the scenario they propose, the ancestors of janthinids lived on the ocean floor, and females formed tethered egg masses with associated males, just as a number of present-day epitoniids do. The egg mass then became modified for buoyancy, resembling a typical Recluzia float, which serves as raft, egg-storage area and platform for juveniles. In the next step, all individuals began making their own floats, so the hitchhikers were lost, but the floats continued to serve as rafts and (in females) egg mass carriers. The present-day species Janthina cf. prolongata and Janthina exigua exemplify this lifestyle.

Finally, the rafts lost their egg-carrying function altogether and came to serve only as floatation devices, as they do in Janthina janthina, in which the female doesn't produce an egg mass at all, but broods the eggs inside her body until they're ready to hatch.

Churchill is working with the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute's Sea Education Association to create student SEA Semester projects aimed at learning more about the ecology and behavior of rafting snails.

Explore further: Aging white lion euthanized at Ohio zoo

More information: Paper online www.cell.com/current-biology/a… -9822%2811%2900886-4

Related Stories

Further Secrets of the Snail Love Dart

Mar 28, 2006

How do you make love to a snail? Slowly, violently and with a mucus-coated love dart. McGill University Biology Professor Ronald Chase knew that ‘love darts’ – sharp, slimy projectiles fired at prospective ...

Tiny snails survive in bird's digestive system

Jul 12, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- In a recent study published in the Journal of Biogeography, researchers from the Tohoku University in Japan show how 15 percent of the Tornatellides boeningi, or tiny land snail, are able to s ...

Sea snails break the law

Apr 24, 2007

Lizards gave rise to legless snakes. Cave fishes don’t have eyeballs. In evolution, complicated structures often get lost. Dollo’s Law states that complicated structures can't be re-evolved because the ...

Marine snails get a metabolism boost

May 03, 2011

Most of us wouldn't consider slow-moving snails to be high-metabolism creatures. But at one point in the distant past, snail metabolism sped up, says a new study of marine snails in the journal Paleobiology.

Recommended for you

Ninety-eight new beetle species discovered in Indonesia

6 hours ago

Ninety-eight new species of the beetle genus Trigonopterus have been described from Java, Bali and other Indonesian islands. Museum scientists from Germany and their local counterparts used an innovative approa ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

voyoeall
1 / 5 (2) Oct 10, 2011
Fashion is a "art". Imitate, conformity "the primary stage", and it ought to be set to reaches state from the fashionable tide of appealing to the cobwebs in the essence of it, extract and true meaning, to enrich their aesthetic and grade, made the exclusive oneself stunning "template". Fashion is not Wholesale cheap MLB Jerseys passive follow but in the control of the senses and expert.
Now I also didn't expect to wholesale cheap NFL hats learn and fashion is all about, and character picture design. In fact still general a pronoun, in a word, is hair design, make up and dress collocation. I like all the beauty in the things that fashionable definition is wide, not only on the outside dress sense. Also includes the self-discipline, life taste, the inherent quality and so Wholesale cheap NCAA Jerseys on.
kevinrtrs
1 / 5 (7) Oct 11, 2011
Suggestions, presumptions, everything except that it's impossible to verify because it presumably took place in the past. So it has to remain sheer speculation on the part of the researchers. It cannot be shown to be true - or falsified for that matter since no one can go back into the past and say that it is so or not. Just because they WANT it to be evolved doesn't make it so.
Doug_Huffman
1 / 5 (5) Oct 11, 2011
Well said Kevin.

Natural history cannot be falsified and it is not science but narrative, just like what the witchdoctor uses to explain his world.

It's he-said-she-said and did-not-did-to for not quite grown-ups.
aroc91
not rated yet Oct 11, 2011
Suggestions, presumptions, everything except that it's impossible to verify because it presumably took place in the past. So it has to remain sheer speculation on the part of the researchers. It cannot be shown to be true - or falsified for that matter since no one can go back into the past and say that it is so or not. Just because they WANT it to be evolved doesn't make it so.


Suggestions, presumptions, everything except that it's impossible to verify because it presumably took place in the past. So it has to remain sheer speculation on the part of the believers. It cannot be shown to be true - or falsified for that matter since no one can go back into the past and say that it is so or not. Just because they WANT it to be created doesn't make it so.

Fixed that for you, kevin. No need to thank me.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.