Conflicting policies on flying under ash confuse

Jun 17, 2011 By SARAH DiLORENZO , Associated Press
Qantas planes maneuver around a Pacific Blue jet at Sydney International Airport in Sydney, Friday, June 17, 2011. Qantas is defending their decision to cancel flights after ash from a Chilean volcano moved over the southern Pacific. ((AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)

(AP) -- If you had hoped to fly Qantas between Australia and New Zealand, you were out of luck. The national carrier grounded planes after a plume of ash from a Chilean volcano moved over the southern Pacific.

But the suspension this past week didn't leave the island nation entirely cut off: If you booked on Virgin Australia or Air New Zealand, your flight ran as scheduled for much of the week.

Stranded Qantas passengers could only watch in frustration as competitors' customers boarded planes, but it also left them wondering what was going on. Was Qantas overly cautious or were its pilots less capable? Do Virgin and Air New Zealand have a greater appetite for risk?

"It's quite concerning that other are still flying, and Qantas can't do the same thing," said Briton Tina Gunn, who got stuck in Sydney on her way to New Zealand to see her daughter who was due to give birth to her first child any day.

All the airlines operating flights affected by the insisted that safety was their No. 1 priority. On Thursday, when the cloud between the two countries drifted to lower altitudes, Virgin followed its competitors and canceled some flights. Air New Zealand periodically suspended some domestic flights, but never stopped flying across the . On Friday, service between the two countries was returning to normal.

The difference in approach made passengers wonder: Was safety more of a priority for some?

Analysts say all three airlines are among the world's safest, and the different approaches - and the flak Qantas caught for not flying - simply lays bare the dilemma airlines face when they make decisions without perfect information. Little is known about how thick ash has to be to affect , and there are few good ways to measure the density of the clouds.

"The airlines you're talking about are airlines that all have outstanding safety records," said Arnold Barnett, a at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "We're talking about disagreements among the greats."

The last time a volcano caused widespread flight cancelations, there were no such comparisons to be made: In the days after last year's eruption in Iceland, European civil authorities closed airspace from Scotland to Hungary. Airlines complained bitterly that they were best placed to make decisions about safety and sent test flights into the air to prove that it was safe to fly.

More than 100,000 flights were canceled and 10 million passengers affected before the agencies relented.

In a less severe situation, Australia left the decision-making to individual airlines. Virgin and Air New Zealand have repeatedly said their safety procedures are robust, but Qantas had the best retort by keeping its planes on the ground.

Qantas has built its reputation on safety, and all week it never lost a chance to remind the public that it would never put "safety before schedule." It attached the hashtag "safety first" to all of its tweets updating passengers on cancelations. On Thursday night, it posted a video on YouTube, explaining the dangers of ash and how it makes decisions about when to fly.

But the carrier's reputation has been dented recently by a series of accidents. Most serious was the explosion of a Rolls Royce engine in mid-air last year. A handful of forced landings have followed and an oxygen tank once exploded, ripping a hole in a plane.

The airline still has never had a fatality, but the Qantas name may not be what it was when Dustin Hoffman's "Rain Man" famously insisted he would only fly the Australian carrier because it had never had a crash.

Did the ash cloud provide the airline with a chance to make a comeback?

"Qantas' prudence in this matter only reminds us that its safety record is among the world's most brilliant," Barnett said. "They might particularly feel that they don't want to take chances" right now.

Spokesman Tom Woodward said the airline was merely implementing a policy it has long had in place: to not fly when it doesn't know the density of the ash cloud, as it did not over this past week.

"Where we don't know the density of the ash, we won't fly through it, we won't fly below it, we won't fly around it," he said.

But Barnett noted that the Virgin group has never had a fatality either, and is admired throughout the industry.

"Virgin isn't taking chances," he said.

The airlines may have made different decisions, but the Civil Aviation Safety Authority said one thing united them.

"The outcome was the same: that no airplane would fly through the ash," said Peter Gibson, a spokesman for the authority.

Ash can stick to and clog engine parts, leading to overheating and eventual engine failure.

The ash from the Eyjafjallajokull (pronounced ay-yah-FYAH-lah-yer-kuhl) was even more dangerous to planes because its plume contained tiny glass crystals, according to Kenneth Button of George Mason University. When those crystals melt, they can coat engine parts and restrict air flow.

The Australian authority said it does not allow planes to fly through ash, but it's up to the airlines to develop plans for how to deal with a plume. The authority approves those plans long before any ash is in the air, so airlines aren't tempted to make snap decisions based on business concerns.

Barnett said it was important to note that there's nothing inherently dangerous about flying at a lower altitude - which some airlines did to avoid the cloud - though it burns more fuel. Short commuter flights - such as the well-traveled leg between Boston and New York - never get above 20,000 feet (6,000 meters), he noted, "and no one's suggesting those flights are unsafe."

But some companies might choose not to take to the air when they can't fly at upper altitudes because higher flight paths give them more time to deal with problems before a crash if anything were to go wrong, Barnett said.

Part of the difference in airline responses - and the debate in Europe over whether civil authorities were overly cautious - stems from the difficulty of measuring an ash cloud's density. European airlines have provided their civil aviation authorities with equipment that can do that, but other parts of the world, like Australia, don't have that capability.

There also is uncertainty over what density is dangerous. The International Civil Aviation Organization is currently tackling that question and hoping to provide global guidelines.

In the meantime, Barnett said you can't go wrong with an Australian airline.

"No one in Australia is taking serious risks," he said.

Explore further: Atmospheric boundary layer exacerbated mega heat waves

not rated yet
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Chile volcano ash grounds Australia, NZ flights

Jun 12, 2011

Ash from Chile's volcanic eruptions prompted Australian airline Qantas to ground some domestic services and some flights to New Zealand on Sunday, after plumes drifted across the Pacific.

Chile volcano grounds more flights

Jun 14, 2011

(AP) -- The drifting plume of ash from Chile's erupting volcano forced new cancelations of dozens of flights on Monday in Argentina, Uruguay and other South American countries, even as airlines in Australia ...

Flights grounded as ash cloud reaches Britain

May 24, 2011

Airlines halted dozens of flights on Tuesday after a plume of ash from an erupting volcano in Iceland blew over Britain, even forcing US President Barack Obama to revise his travel plans.

Chileans living near volcano urged to stay away

Jun 13, 2011

(AP) -- Chilean officials ordered most residents already evacuated from homes near an erupting volcano to stay in shelters and with family and friends Sunday due to the threat of deadly landslides. The ash ...

Iceland volcanic ash grounds flights across Ireland

May 04, 2010

Aviation chiefs grounded flights into and out of Ireland and Northern Ireland on Tuesday as ash from an Icelandic volcano drifted in, causing fresh travel chaos for thousands of passengers.

Recommended for you

Atmospheric boundary layer exacerbated mega heat waves

1 hour ago

The extreme nature of the heat waves of 2003 in Western Europe and of 2010 in Russia and Eastern Europe even surprised scientists at the time. NWO Veni researcher Ryan Teuling from Wageningen University says ...

Magnitude-7.2 earthquake shakes Mexican capital

Apr 18, 2014

A powerful magnitude-7.2 earthquake shook central and southern Mexico on Friday, sending panicked people into the streets. Some walls cracked and fell, but there were no reports of major damage or casualties.

User comments : 0

More news stories