New research says corn is most profitable cellulosic biofuel crop in Michigan

March 22, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- When deciding which crops to grow for cellulosic biofuels, return on investment is one variable farmers must consider. Currently, corn stalks and leaves offer the most profit according to new research by Michigan State University scientists.

But that could change if federal policy offers incentives to grow crops that offer more environmental benefits than .

Cellulosic biofuels use the leaves, stems and other fibrous parts of a plant to make fuels.

Scott Swinton, MSU agricultural, food, and resource economics professor, teamed up with MSU crop and soil associate professor Kurt Thelen and graduate student Laura James to analyze the economics of growing various crops for cellulosic ethanol. The results are published in the March-April 2010 edition of .

“Many farmers are curious about whether they should be growing crops for cellulosic biofuels,” Swinton said. “They need to know what they can earn for those crops, what the yields will be and what the costs are to produce crops for biofuels.”

The study, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, found that corn stover (stalks and leaves) is the most profitable cellulosic biofuel crop in the Great Lakes region, across a range of likely prices.

“For now, corn looks like the cellulosic bioenergy crop of choice,” Swinton said. “Of course that could change with environmental policy that rewards the water quality and climate change benefits from perennial crops such as switchgrass, and mixed grasses.”

Perennial crops offer more environmental benefits than corn, including lower amounts of greenhouse gases released, improved water quality and better wildlife habitat.

“Having more corn in the landscape does come at a social cost,” Swinton said. “However, without special subsidies, perennial grasses and poplar don't match the profitability of corn unless biomass prices rise to more than $90 a ton.”

The researchers calculated the cellulosic biomass prices and yields for potential energy crops in southern Michigan using price and cost-of-production data from 2006 to 2009 and yield values from published literature. They then compared those prices and yields to corn and production systems.

Great Lakes Bioenergy Research Center researchers are testing a variety of crops to evaluate yields under field conditions at sites in Wisconsin and Michigan, Swinton said. Results from these experiments will enable researchers to update and evaluate results from the current study.

The GLBRC, funded by the Department of Energy, is a partnership between MSU and the University of Wisconsin-Madison aimed at solving some of the most complex problems in converting natural materials to energy.

Explore further: With cellulosic ethanol, there is no food vs. fuel debate according to MSU scientist

More information: www.agronomy.org/publications/agronomy-journal

Related Stories

Biofuels: More than just ethanol

April 5, 2007

As the United States looks to alternate fuel sources, ethanol has become one of the front runners. Farmers have begun planting corn in the hopes that its potential new use for corn will be a new income source. What many ...

MSU to create genomic clearinghouse for biofuel crops

August 16, 2008

Michigan State University scientists, armed with a half-million-dollar federal grant, are creating an easily accessible, Web-based genomic database of information on crops that can be used to make ethanol.

Biofuels, like politics, are local

February 13, 2009

Field work and computer simulations in Michigan and Wisconsin are helping biofuels researchers understand the basics of getting home-grown energy from the field to consumers. Preliminary results presented today suggest that ...

Biofuel crop diversity adds value, researchers say

January 22, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Diverse biofuel plantings such as native prairie attract more beneficial insects than do single crops such as corn, Michigan State University scientists find. Therefore, biofuel policies should take such ...

Recommended for you

How bees naturally vaccinate their babies

July 31, 2015

When it comes to vaccinating their babies, bees don't have a choice—they naturally immunize their offspring against specific diseases found in their environments. And now for the first time, scientists have discovered how ...

New insights into the production of antibiotics by bacteria

July 31, 2015

Bacteria use antibiotics as a weapon and even produce more antibiotics if there are competing strains nearby. This is a fundamental insight that can help find new antibiotics. Leiden scientists Daniel Rozen and Gilles van ...

Out of the lamplight

July 31, 2015

The human body is governed by complex biochemical circuits. Chemical inputs spur chain reactions that generate new outputs. Understanding how these circuits work—how their components interact to enable life—is critical ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.