We must stop evictions to end chronic homelessness, says researcher

Homelessness, a crisis that affects about 11% of Canadians in their lifetime, often begins with eviction. Once a person or family is evicted, they are set on a trajectory that can lead to chronic homelessness as they try to find affordable housing in an increasingly competitive market.

For example, consider a long-term tenant in Kitchener paying $1,300 for a two-bedroom apartment. If evicted—whether due to a landlord's decision to move in a family member, demolish the building or sell it—the tenant will be thrust into a housing market where the average rent for a similar unit is $2,327. This steep price increase is untenable for many, especially those earning minimum wage.

The risk of eviction is not just limited to those in precarious financial situations, but can impact renters across the board. This reality highlights the urgent need for stronger tenant protections to safeguard individuals and families from being unhoused.

In the metropolitan area of Kitchener-Cambridge-Waterloo, for instance, there are no neighborhoods with affordable one- or two-bedroom rentals for full-time minimum wage workers. All across Canada, the average cost of rent is increasing to untenable levels.

This situation is even more dire for seniors relying on fixed incomes, single parents and those on social assistance. For example, a single person's maximum monthly shelter allowance through Ontario Works is $390 and is $697 for a family of three. For international students without government support, the situation is particularly bleak.

As an eviction prevention worker, my work and the work of my colleagues is crucial for stopping people from falling into circumstances that expose them to further marginalization and hardship.

Systems of oppression

The most marginalized groups in society are often the hardest hit by housing instability. Statistics show that low-income individuals, particularly those who are Indigenous and racialized people, as well as people with disabilities, people with mental health and addiction issues, and newcomers, are disproportionately represented among those facing homelessness.

Systems of oppression impact the most marginalized first and most severely. Those who are poor, Black, Indigenous or people of color, elderly or living with disabilities face the greatest barriers to meeting their basic needs, including securing stable housing.

It's clear that current strategies are falling short of addressing the issue. The housing stability system often overlooks critical realities, such as the near-impossibility of securing new rental housing after being evicted from an affordable unit for those not earning a high income.

Social housing waitlists in many regions stretch to seven years or longer, and even below average market rent units may be out of reach or unsuitable for families with specific needs. This perpetuates the cycle of housing instability, leaving the most vulnerable populations with few options.

Ending chronic homelessness

Supporting low-income tenants through affordable housing must be a priority for addressing the growing housing crisis. To effectively combat short-sighted policies about who is eligible for financial support when rent payments fall behind, a more holistic approach is needed—one that considers the long-term consequences of eviction.

Since the removal of rent control on vacant units in Ontario in 1996, the availability of affordable housing has steadily declined.

A more compassionate and human-centered approach is needed to provide support to those at risk of eviction. To end chronic homelessness, we must stop evictions. Adopting a community-based perspective is essential to protect vulnerable tenants from the risk of homelessness.

The Region of Waterloo's new Property Tax Exemption for Affordable Housing Program is a promising step in the right direction. By incentivizing landlords to maintain affordable units, this program could help preserve existing housing stock.

However, a broader, multi-pronged approach that considers the well-being of entire communities is necessary to create lasting solutions.

Growing wealth divide

Renters in Canada generally have lower incomes and spend more money on housing than homeowners. In 2023, while Canadian homeowners saved 7% of their take-home pay, renters, on average, spent 9% more than they earned. The wealth disparity is stark, with homeowners' net worth being four times that of renters.

Multi-property owners have been the biggest buyers of Ontario properties since 2017. In 2021, 22% of Ontario's property purchases were made by those who already owned property.

It has become close to impossible for renters to save enough for a down payment and, even if they can, they don't have much of a chance to compete with investors.

As Brian Doucet, Canadian Research Chair in Urban Change and Social Inclusion at the University of Waterloo, has noted, housing is a human right and a lucrative business, a contradiction that lies at the root of the problem.

Simply increasing the housing supply won't resolve the issue if new units are unaffordable and cater primarily to investors rather than those in need. The construction of high-rise condos with expensive rental units will only exacerbate the issue. The focus should be on building housing that actually meets affordable housing needs.

Community-centered approach

To truly address the housing crisis, it is essential to prevent the loss of affordable units and protect vulnerable tenants from eviction. Incentives for landlords to maintain affordable housing are crucial, as is halting any development that results in a net loss of such units.

A long-term, community-centered approach is necessary—one that goes beyond quick fixes and addresses the root causes of housing instability.

The working conditions of those on the front lines of this crisis, like myself, also need to be addressed. Workers are often overwhelmed and burned out, but there is hope. My experience in eviction prevention has shown that meaningful change is possible through the collaborative efforts of peer support workers, outreach workers, lawyers, social workers, settlement workers and mental health specialists.

However, real progress requires a candid assessment of the current system's failures. By acknowledging these shortcomings, Canada can begin to create meaningful transformational change that genuinely improves the lives of the people who live here.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.