This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

fact-checked

trusted source

written by researcher(s)

proofread

Can we eat our way through an exploding sea urchin problem?

sea urchin
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Longspined sea urchins are native to temperate waters around New South Wales. But as oceans heat up, their range has expanded more than 650km, through eastern Victoria and south to Tasmania. Their numbers are exploding in the process, clear-felling kelp forests and leaving "urchin barrens" behind.

The species (Centrostephanus rodgersii) is now the single largest and most urgent threat to along the southeastern coast of Australia's Great Southern Reef.

What can we do? Here's one excellent solution: eat their roe, a buttery delicacy that can fetch hundreds of dollars per kilogram. Tasmania already has a government-backed urchin fishery. When combined with a mix of other tools, as outlined in our submission to the invasive Senate inquiry, harvesting urchins can put the brakes on this overabundant, range-extending marine species.

Today, the Senate handed down its findings, identifying investment in commercial harvesting as a frontline climate-ready tool to combat the urchin. It presents a win-win opportunity by maximizing socioeconomic and environmental returns for kelp ecosystems, while lessening the ongoing cost of control.

Dealing with urchins is urgent

Almost 200 marine species have been documented shifting range in Australian seas as heats the oceans. But longspined sea urchins are the most damaging so far.

The waters along hundreds of kilometers of coastline have now warmed above a winter average of 12°C. This is the temperature at which urchin larvae can develop during spawning. The ocean is warming faster than land, heating at a rate of 4°C per century.

The Senate inquiry shows the government is listening. The inquiry and accompanying five-year plan for control methods are based on more than two decades of scientific research.

The tragedy of the barrens

Urchins chew through entire forests of kelp. Once the big kelp is gone, they switch to feeding on tiny encrusting seaweeds that can regrow rapidly and persist in the face of intensive grazing. This creates "hyper-stable" urchin barrens.

The damage is dramatic, with the local loss of hundreds of kelp-associated species ranging from valuable abalone to the iconic leafy seadragon.

Barrens in southern NSW, eastern Victoria and Tasmania can now be measured in the scale of kilometers, with whole reefs turned into underwater deserts.

They expand fast, too. In Tasmania, early sightings off the northeast in 1978 have turned into a population estimated at 20 million around the eastern coastline. Barren areas now cover 15% of Tasmanian reefs. If left unchecked, 50% of reef habitat could be lost by the 2030s, as we've seen in southern NSW and eastern Victoria.

Correcting an imbalance of nature

Rock lobsters are a natural predator of urchins. They boost kelp bed resilience and even prevent barren expansion in some areas off limits to lobster fisheries.

The Tasmanian East Coast Rock Lobster Rebuilding Strategy focuses on rebuilding stocks to help combat the urchin. However, the lobsters' strong preference for local prey such as abalone, their negligible capacity to rehabilitate extensive barrens once urchins reach hyperabundance, and high recreational and commercial fisheries value, constrains the scale of effectiveness.

Another option is culling, where divers kill urchins underwater. The upshot is that kelp can grow back quickly, within just 18 months, if all visible urchins are culled. But it's extremely expensive and urchins can reemerge, meaning culling needs to be ongoing.

Strategies for urchin control.

An affordable, scalable, long-term solution?

Yes. Make it profitable. The main game here isn't the urchins themselves but their roe, known as "uni" in Japan. Urchin roe is a delicacy, renowned for its sweet, buttery, umami flavors and bright golden color. Premium roe returns top dollar in markets from across South East Asia, the United States and the Middle East.

If are viable, we can remove vast quantities of urchins from reefs in a low-cost urchin control program over large areas.

But there are challenges here too. Extracting the roe is labor-intensive. Roe quality can vary greatly, dropping as overgrazing ensues. To date, infrastructure, access to markets, and detailed knowledge of processing techniques has been a limiting factor.

Tasmania is showing it can be done. In 2018, the invested in a fledgling urchin fishery in conjunction with the abalone industry by offering harvest subsidies.

These gave urchin processors the financial certainty to invest. In a few years, annual urchin fishery yields have grown from 40 metric tons to 500 metric tons, all harvested by hand by divers.

To date, the fishery has created more than 100 jobs and boosted regional economies. It's starting to work too. The fishery has not only slowed the expansion of urchin barrens, but allowed recovery of kelp habitats in some heavily fished areas.

Expanding urchin fisheries

Tasmania's example shows the potential of fishery-led control of overabundant, problematic species. Making the most of it means adding value, such as by expanding the international market, developing new uses for low-grade urchin roe and selling waste products. If it's more profitable, divers will be able to travel farther from port and fish down urchin stocks.

We can also direct fishery efforts for better urchin control by offering subsidies to fish high priority areas.

Other states hit hard by urchins too, such as Victoria, could benefit from control-by-fishery.

Achieving national, widespread urchin control will require challenging coordination. We need to:

  • support dive fisheries to become the heavy lifter of urchin control
  • add extra urchin control measures on high-value reefs
  • begin restoring degraded barrens to a mosaic of urchin fisheries or kelp forests
  • boost populations of urchin predators on healthy reefs, to increase resilience in the first place.

If we do this right, Australia's control of the longspined sea urchin could be a global exemplar of climate-ready management of overabundant and range extending species, boosting rural economies and social well-being. As species keep moving, finding low- or zero-cost control measures will be essential to keeping ecosystems intact.

Controlling troublesome is often seen as a major cost to government. Our work and the work of many others has shown it doesn't have to be. Creating viable urchin fisheries turns a cost into a benefit.

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: Can we eat our way through an exploding sea urchin problem? (2023, November 4) retrieved 27 February 2024 from https://phys.org/news/2023-11-sea-urchin-problem.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Research uncovers key insight for restoration of globally important kelp forests

1 shares

Feedback to editors