Humor used in English-language terrorist propaganda magazines to reinforce identity, study shows
Humor is used in English-language jihadi terrorist magazines to reinforce identity and help groups bond, research suggests.
Published in Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression, the study shows Al-Qaeda, the Taliban, and Tahrik-e Taliban Pakistan (TTP) use humor in a similar way, using situational comedy, while humor in Islamic State (IS) magazines is dehumanizing and mocking.
Academics examined 82 jihadi magazines published in English. They found Al-Qaeda and the Taliban in particular use mockery and parody to galvanize the curious by placing emphasis on an "us versus them" mentality. This usually includes aggressive imagery of people or countries as animals.
These groups repeatedly used the term 'dog' to describe President Bush, 'donkey' to describe Americans and vermin to describe US troops. ISIS labeled Joe Biden as 'the Senile Crusader'. Former Israeli Prime Minister's surname 'Netanyahu' was turned into 'Rottenyahu' by Al-Qaeda.
TTP is more likely than ISIS, the Taliban and Al-Qaeda to resort to ironic and sarcastic humor. Al Qaeda is less likely than any group to use sarcastic humor, usually to ridicule enemies.
The research, published in the journal Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression, was carried out by Dr. Weeda Mehran from the University of Exeter and her MA students Megan Byrne, Ella Gibbs-Pearce, Archie Macfarlane, Jacob Minihane and Amy Ranger.
Dr. Mehran says that "propaganda is used to encourage jihad but it serves a much bigger purpose and humor is a key part. We found the use of three different types of humor—dehumanizing, sarcastic/and situational. ISIS was more likely to use dehumanizing humor—portraying rivals as robots or animals and mocking them. This sets them apart from other groups who are more likely to use sarcasm and irony.
"Situational humor is used strategically to enrich narratives of past events and develop a religious rationale for conducting jihad, as well as motivating individuals to carry out their own operations. This humor emphasizes the comradery and brotherhood of carrying out 'istishhadi' missions and depict perilous and dangerous operations & efforts as peaceful, even joyful.
"Jihadi media strategy uses situational humor to create solidarity—these are in-jokes often-only understood by those who understand the jihadi ideology and political outlook so it helps create a shared identity. Shared humor creates an environment that fosters internal cohesion and creates social bonding."
The study says the regularity of dehumanizing humor in ISIS's magazines reflects their overall aggressive and uncompromising stance on outsiders and opponents.
More information: Weeda Mehran et al, Humour in jihadi rhetoric: comparative analysis of ISIS, Al-Qaeda, TTP, and the Taliban, Behavioral Sciences of Terrorism and Political Aggression (2022). DOI: 10.1080/19434472.2022.2075028
Provided by University of Exeter