The coronal veil: Are the sun's magnetic arches an optical illusion?

The coronal veil: Are the sun's magnetic arches an optical illusion?
Coronal loops on the Sun are captured in ultraviolet light using the 171 ångström channel of the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) instrument on NASA’s Solar Dynamics Observatory. Credit: NASA/SDO

From afar, the Sun appears blank and featureless in visible light. But through a solar telescope in different wavelength, it is revealed to be much, much more.

In extreme ultraviolet light, the Sun resembles a rumpled ball of yarn. It teems with giant radiant arcs known as coronal loops soaring through the Sun's corona, or outer atmosphere. Coronal loops are considered fundamental to the Sun's workings. Understanding how they form, change, and move is one of the key goals to understanding our closest star.

At least that's what researchers have long assumed. In a recent paper, solar physicist Anna Malanushenko and her co-authors argue that some coronal loops may not be what they appear to be. Instead, they may sometimes be created by folds or wrinkles in much larger "sheets" of solar material that the authors call coronal veils.

"If this is really correct, then we will have to change the entire way we look at and interpret coronal loops," said Malanushenko, a scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado, and lead author of the paper published in The Astrophysical Journal.

Ever since capturing the first images of coronal loops in the late 60's, scientists have hypothesized what their 3D structure might be. The conventional model saw them as magnetic "tubes" formed by the Sun's . The tubes themselves are invisible; what we see is the bright solar material that flows through them like water through a garden hose. This "garden hose" model of coronal loops fit well with known physics and there was no reason to doubt it, at least at first. But eventually, observations that didn't fit began to pile up.

Just as Earth's air gets thinner at higher altitudes, the Sun's bright plasma, or electrically charged gas, gets thinner with height. That's why it grows dimmer with height, and if coronal loops truly are tubes of plasma, so should they. But many loops maintain a consistent brightness, with no obvious explanation.

The coronal veil: Are the sun's magnetic arches an optical illusion?
This ultraviolet image of coronal loops on the Sun was taken using the 335 angström channel of the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly telescope on NASA’s Solar Dynamics Observatory. Earth is shown to scale. The image shows solar plasma at temperatures around 4.5 million degrees Fahrenheit (2.5 million degrees Celsius) colorized in blue. In this image, loops extend far from the solar surface without expanding much with height, which is counter to the expected physics according to the “garden hose” model of coronal loops. Credit: NASA/SDO

If coronal loops trace the Sun's magnetic field lines, they should balloon as they move away from the Sun as that magnetic field expands to fill space. "But they don't get nearly as wide as we think they should," Malanushenko said. "Most of them stay too thin and we don't understand why."

Something wasn't adding up, and Malanushenko started to question the observations themselves. After all, the Sun's corona is "optically thin," or translucent, like fog or smoke. She wanted to understand the optical tricks that could occur in that kind of environment.

Malanushenko decided to simulate the process of observing coronal loops with a computer. She repurposed a 3D simulation of the Sun originally used to study flares, then wrote a program to "observe" it. She fired up the simulation, and her program took 2D "images" of it, just as telescopes give us 2D snapshots of the real Sun. Sure enough, the snapshots revealed bright arcs—artificial coronal loops on a simulated Sun.

But unlike the real Sun, Malanushenko could pause the simulated Sun and look at its 3D structures behind them. And she found something markedly different from garden hose-like tubes.

"I don't have words how to describe it, because this is not like anything that we see on Earth," said Malanushenko, "I want to say this formation looks like clouds of smoke, or maybe a veil or curtains that are wrinkled."

Malanushenko created a simple model to illustrate how a veil could produce the illusion of coronal loops. The shadow created against the wall represents the 2D image we see in solar telescopes. The veil's folds and wrinkles create a pattern of darker and brighter strands, in some ways similar to the image cast by real tube-like strands.

The coronal veil: Are the sun's magnetic arches an optical illusion?
This simplified model compares the “garden hose” model of coronal loops (left) to the coronal veil model (right). In both images, the ball represents the Sun, and the shadow represents the image of the Sun that would be observed by telescopes. On the left, individual strands or tubes connect one part of the Sun’s surface to another. The shadow reveals obvious loop-like structures. On the right, a more complicated “veil” or translucent sheet connects one part of the Sun’s surface to another. The shadow still creates the impression of loop-like strands that in some places resemble those created by the garden hose model. Credit: Anna Malanushenko

"But many of the strands that you see here, they're just a projection effect. They're not real," Malanushenko said.

Malanushenko and her co-authors are quick to clarify that not all are visual illusions. There were many instances where garden hose-like structures do really form, even in the simulation that Malanushenko studied.

"It would be exciting if we could say 'Our thinking was all wrong, we have a totally new paradigm,'" said Jim Klimchuk, a solar physicist at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center and coauthor of the paper. "It's not that way at all—but these veils, I'm sure they do exist, and now it's a question of proportions: are veils more common or are loops more common?"

One thing the co-authors agree on is that there's now plenty more work to do.

"Now, do we have any idea why those veil structures are produced?" asked Malanushenko. "No! We literally just discovered them. Now we need to explain them, and we don't have a good explanation yet."

Explore further

A solar illusion: Coronal loops may not be what they seem

More information: A. Malanushenko et al, The Coronal Veil, The Astrophysical Journal (2022). DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac3df9
Journal information: Astrophysical Journal

Citation: The coronal veil: Are the sun's magnetic arches an optical illusion? (2022, June 16) retrieved 27 June 2022 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors