Could we intercept interstellar comet C/2019 Q4 Borisov?

Could we intercept interstellar comet C/2019 Q4 Borisov?
Artist’s impression of the first interstellar asteroid/comet, “Oumuamua”. This unique object was discovered on Oct. 19th, 2017, by the Pan-STARRS 1 telescope in Hawaii. Credit: ESO/M. Kornmesser

When 'Oumuamua passed through our solar system two years ago, it set off a flurry of excitement in the astronomical community. Here was the first-ever interstellar object that be observed by human trackers, and the mysteries surrounding its true nature and composition led to some pretty interesting theories. There were even some proposals for a rapid mission that would be able to rendezvous with it.

And now that a second —C/2019 Q4 (Borisov)—has been detected traveling through the solar system, similar proposals are being made. One of them comes from a group of scientists from the Initiative for Interstellar Studies (i4is) in the U.K. In a recent study, they assess the technical feasibility of sending a mission to this interstellar comet using existing technology, and found that there were a few options.

In many ways, C/2019 Q4 (Borisov) represents an opportunity to conduct the kinds of research that were not possible with 'Oumuamua. When that mystery was first observed, it had already made its closest pass to the sun, past Earth, and was on its way out of the solar system. Nevertheless, what we were able to learn about 'Oumuamua led to the conclusion that it was an entirely new class of celestial object.

In addition to those who ventured that it was either a comet or an asteroid, there were also those who theorized that 'Oumuamua could be a fragment from a comet that exploded when passing close to our sun, or even an extra-terrestrial solar sail. Another interesting find was the fact that similar objects likely pass through our solar system on a regular basis (many of which stay).

For these reasons, a mission to study such objects up close is desirable. As Dr. Andreas M. Hein—the of i4is's board of directors, the chairman of its technical research committee, and one of the co-authors on the recent study, told Universe Today via email:

"Investigating interstellar objects from a close distance would provide us with unique data about other star systems without actually flying to them. They might provide unique insights into the evolution and composition of other star systems and exoplanets in them. Interstellar objects are cool, as it's a bit like: If you can't go to the mountain, let the mountain come to you. It will likely take many decades until we can send a to another star. Hence, interstellar objects might be an intermediate solution for finding out more about other stars and their planets."

What's more, he claims, these objects have probably been traveling between star systems for hundreds of thousands (or even millions) of years. As a result, they have undoubtedly picked up material along the way or bear the marks of encounters with other objects or forces. In short, their composition and surface features can tell us a great deal about what is out there in the interstellar medium.

This is not the first time that i4is has proposed sending a spacecraft to rendezvous with an interstellar object. In 2017, Dr. Hein and several colleagues from i4is (who also co-authored this study) produced a paper titled "Project Lyra: Sending a Spacecraft to 1I/'Oumuamua (former A/2017 U1), the Interstellar Asteroid," which was conducted with the help of the asteroid-prospecting company Asteroid Initiatives LLC.

The project was so-named because of 'Oumuamua's origins, which astronomers concluded came from the general direction of Vega—the brightest star in the northern constellation of Lyra. After taking into account the speed with which 'Oumuamua was leaving the solar system at the time—26 km/s (93,600 km/h; 58,160 mph)—they determined that any proposal would be a trade-off between three factors.

Could we intercept interstellar comet C/2019 Q4 Borisov?
Artist’s illustration of a light-sail powered by lasers generated on the surface of a planet. Credit: M. Weiss/CfA

These included when a mission could launch, the velocity it could achieve, and the time it would take to rendezvous with the object. Under the circumstances, they felt that the best option was to wait for future technological breakthroughs—such as those being pursued by Breakthrough Starshot (a concept for a laser-driven interstellar solar sail).

These conclusions have proven very applicable, thanks to the detection of a second interstellar object passing through our solar system in as many years. In their most recent study, the research team once again used Optimum Interplanetary Trajectory Software (OITS), which was developed by team-member Adam Hibberd, to assess all available options for sending a spacecraft to rendezvous with an interstellar object.

These included the optimal launch vehicle (like NASA's Space Launch System (SLS) or SpaceX's Falcon Heavy) the optimal trajectory for the mission, and the best type of spacecraft. In the end, they determined that humanity has the capability of rendezvousing with an interstellar object using existing technology, and came up with a mission architecture that could make that happen.

This mission would rely on a heavy-launch vehicle and could alternately employ a two-ton (1.8 metric ton) or a 3 kg (6.6 lbs) CubeSat spacecraft. Depending on when it launched and what its preferred trajectory would be, it might also need to conduct a Jupiter flyby and Solar Oberth maneuver to catch up with C/2019 Q4 (Borisov). As Dr. Hein explained:

"Our results show that for both, 'Oumuamua and C/2019 Q4 (Borisov), we already have the technology to visit these objects. Regarding 'Oumuamua, we can launch a spacecraft toward it even beyond the year 2030. There is plenty of time to develop such a spacecraft. The case for C/2019 Q4 (Borisov) is a bit more tricky, as it is faster than 'Oumuamua. But even for this object, we could have sent a two-ton spacecraft to it with a Falcon Heavy if we would have launched it in 2018."

"Later missions are also possible, but require a bigger launcher. Future telescopes will be able to detect such objects much earlier and with adequate preparation, we can send a spacecraft on an encounter mission. So we have the technology to do this, and with the discovery of C/2019 Q4 (Borisov), we also know that we probably have plenty of opportunities to fly to such an object."

Once again, the presence of an interstellar object in our is a major source of excitement. In addition to all the opportunities to learn from them, C/2019 Q4 and 'Oumuamua confirm that objects from distant stars pass through our system pretty regularly; they also show that we are at a point where we can detect, track and study them.

But it is especially exciting knowing that in the future, we will be able to study them up close. In fact, the ESA is currently working on a mission that could very well be the one to rendezvous with a future interstellar object. It's known as the Comet Interceptor, a "fast-class" concept consisting of three spacecraft that will wait in space until a pristine comet appears, and rapidly catch up with it.

"We imagine two types of research," Dr. Hein said. "First, , for example, with a telescope taking pictures. Second, we can analyze material from the object directly by shooting an impactor into it and catching some of the particles from the dust plume that is generated with the main spacecraft. This would provide unique insights into the composition of the object."

As for what this research could reveal, Dr. Hein has some thoughts on that too: "I can only speculate, but we might see evidence that organic molecules, the building blocks for life, actually travel between star systems, and who knows? Maybe life itself might actually spread between stars in our galaxy."

Explore further

Newly discovered comet is likely interstellar visitor

More information: Adam Hibberd, et al. Sending a Spacecraft to Interstellar Comet C/2019 Q4 (Borisov) arXiv:1909.06348v1 [astro-ph.EP]:
Citation: Could we intercept interstellar comet C/2019 Q4 Borisov? (2019, September 18) retrieved 17 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Sep 18, 2019
does any nation have any resources in orbit or ready-to-launch capability
available to achieve rendezvous?

Sep 18, 2019
I was musing just today that it might be possible to have one or more basically equipped probes kept on standby to be available to launch toward interesting comets or object, and not just those from outside the solar system but any interesting incoming object.

Sep 18, 2019
does any nation have any resources in orbit or ready-to-launch capability
available to achieve rendezvous?
Yes, but we're looking at an all-nations, all-hands-on-deck, 40-50 billion dollar project. This is because the speed of thing means we're looking at 3 Earth-escape-velocity's worth of velocity. There's no orbital speed-boost; we're shooting off from the plane of the ecliptic from a dead standstill. That means a 5 or 6 stage system launched altogether into LEO, of strapped-together boosters of the biggest kind--and most   r e l i a b l e   available. Say, 10 for stage one, 5 for stage 2, 3 for 3, then smaller rockets topping out to stage 7.
Just getting this system up there for launching means some 20-30 big bosters.

Sep 19, 2019
res dan, i agree with your evaluation of possible capability

though i am of the opinion,
thatno single nation has the resources immediately available

any chance of success will be by a global collective effort

this will appeal to the efficiency-minded conservative who can see that this interceptor role will be part of a Global Defense against hooligan asteroids

addition to providing cost-effective repair services to malfunct satellites,vessels & habitats
space search & rescue missions
& i'm sure other useful functions i haven't even thought of yet

Sep 20, 2019
I was musing just today that it might be possible to have one or more basically equipped probes kept on standby to be available to launch toward interesting comets or object, and not just those from outside the solar system but any interesting incoming object.

You've been beaten to it;


Sep 20, 2019
the link you offered is an interesting proposal
by an international collaboration of concerned scientists

a positive beginning
but there is still all the actual engineering & technical developments to be accomplished

the next two steps will be the most difficult

first, someone has to approach the trumploon
& convince him he invented this idea
& that he will get all the headlines & glory

the second action needed is everyone reading these comments
who believes that action is needed?
should forward their opinions to all their network of contacts

try to convince all these people that they should contact their congresscritter
to explain how such projects would benefit the legislator's districts
most importantly, expanding their district's pool of campaign contributors

if the corrupt can be convinced to turn a meme into a reality?
with benefits to themselves?
not a damn thing will be able to stop that avalanche of progress

Sep 20, 2019
Could we intercept interstellar comet, Borisov

Not with a sail, we can't
Not for all the tea in China!

A super fast rocket maybe, if we spot this interstellar comet in time
But then what?

Sep 20, 2019
it seems to me. that the more effective method to avoiding catastrophe
would be to steer the comet or asteroid using a girdle of small drilling robots
that output providing cheap reaction mass
an efficient, cost-effective conservative means
to change the threat's course enough to be slowed by the Earth/Luna gravitational influence

just slow enough to nudge it Sol ward & eventually to be captured by one of the Venus Lagrange points
that the comet/asteroid material be safely parked unable to threaten the Earth again
, yet remaining available for future use

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more