The mental health pros and cons of minority spaces in the workplace

January 11, 2019 by Christopher Begeny, The Conversation
Credit: Shutterstock

Many companies and organisations appear keen to support a more diverse workforce, where minority group members are made to feel welcome. One strategy involves creating special "spaces" at work, physical or otherwise, where minority employees can connect with each other.

Take Google for instance. They have several -focused employee-based resource groups (ERGs) including Gayglers, the Black Googlers Network and Hispanic Googlers Network. Other companies support similar groups, including at Netflix, Merck, Novartis, Intel and Comcast.

Similarly, some universities are working to support a more diverse student body by creating minority-focused spaces on campus. In the US for instance, the University of Connecticut has the Scholastic House of Leaders who are African American Researchers & Scholars (ScHOLA²RS). The University of Iowa has Young, Gifted and Black, and UCLA has the Chicanx/Latinx living-learning community.

As these minority-based spaces become more common, they also evoke heated debate. While opponents see them as creating division and segregation, supporters see them as an important resource for minorities. So are they helpful? Or might they cause more harm than good?

To shed some light on this issue, we've been examining how the opportunity to connect with and feel valued among fellow minority group members can shape mental health with regard to anxiety, depression and psychological distress. In a series of studies looking at this among racial/ethnic minorities and sexual minorities, we found a consistent and rather intriguing pattern of evidence.

Our findings indicate that while there are to feeling valued among minority group members, there can also be – perhaps counter-intuitively – some costs. This is partly because of the way that feeling valued within one's minority group appears to promote vigilance to the various forms of that exist.

Specifically, we found that when minorities frequently feel valued and embraced by members of their own minority group, they maintain lower levels of anxiety and fewer symptoms of depression overall. A clear benefit.

The costs of feeling valued

But at the same time the evidence shows that when people feel highly valued in their minority group they also place a special premium on that group membership. It plays a central role in how they define themselves as an individual overall.

With that membership being so central to their sense of self, these individuals are more likely to view their daily social interactions through the lens of their minority group membership. This means they are more vigilant to, and thus perceive and experience, more discrimination. And ultimately, these more frequent experiences of discrimination translate into poorer mental health.

So altogether our research shows that, in addition to the benefits of feeling valued, there can be some inadvertent costs.

Overall, does feeling valued among minority group members cause more harm than good? In short, the answer is no. In all our studies we find the benefits of being valued in one's minority group outweigh the costs. So, to be clear, this research consistently demonstrates that it is a good thing overall for minorities to feel valued and embraced by fellow minority group members.

Reducing costs

Google's ERGs and universities' minority-based communities are likely to provide important opportunities to experience a sense of value and respect among fellow group members. And, as our research indicates, this will almost certainly yield benefits for the health and well-being of and students.

At the same time, these institutions should be aware that such spaces might yield some unanticipated consequences. They may heighten minorities' vigilance to the forms of bias and discrimination that exist in the workplace or on campus, which can lead to stress and anxiety.

So what's the solution? We believe additional steps can be taken to help minimise the health costs associated with these minority-focused spaces, while preserving the benefits they yield.

For example, let's say a university's living-learning communities do ultimately heighten minorities' awareness of discrimination on campus. If the university also shows a true commitment to addressing that discrimination it could change a minority individual's discrimination experience, in ways that lessen its health impact. Moreover, if an institution is actively working to address discrimination then over time it will hopefully reduce the amount that minorities encounter.

Considering that minorities often face discrimination and experience disproportionate rates of certain illnesses, the results of our work can seem rather sobering. Even something so intuitively positive – being valued by others –- can sometimes be a double-edged sword.

But, double-edged or not, this sword is important to acknowledge. It provides us with a clearer understanding of the social and psychological determinants of minorities' – something we need if we are going to effectively address some of these persistent disparities.

Explore further: Repeated experiences of racism most damaging to mental health

Related Stories

Sexual-minority men more empathic towards fellow minorities

August 24, 2015

White sexual-minority men may be more empathic toward other minority groups compared to their heterosexual white peers. A new study from the University of Houston College of Education compared the attitudes of white heterosexual ...

Having the right name helps one to find housing

July 19, 2018

Discrimination against ethnic minorities on the housing market is declining—in Germany and other Western European countries and in the USA. But a new meta-study shows that applicants' surnames still influence the selection ...

Recommended for you

Apple pivot led by star-packed video service

March 25, 2019

With Hollywood stars galore, Apple unveiled its streaming video plans Monday along with news and game subscription offerings as part of an effort to shift its focus to digital content and services to break free of its reliance ...

How tree diversity regulates invading forest pests

March 25, 2019

A national-scale study of U.S. forests found strong relationships between the diversity of native tree species and the number of nonnative pests that pose economic and ecological threats to the nation's forests.

Scientists solve mystery shrouding oldest animal fossils

March 25, 2019

Scientists from The Australian National University (ANU) have discovered that 558 million-year-old Dickinsonia fossils do not reveal all of the features of the earliest known animals, which potentially had mouths and guts.

Earth's deep mantle flows dynamically

March 25, 2019

As ancient ocean floors plunge over 1,000 km into the Earth's deep interior, they cause hot rock in the lower mantle to flow much more dynamically than previously thought, finds a new UCL-led study.

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

24volts
5 / 5 (1) Jan 12, 2019
This is the absolute dumbest idea I have heard in a while. All employees should be treated the same regardless of race, sex, or religion. They are hired to do a job, not socialize with each other.
They can do any special groups they might want to be in on their own time.
granville583762
5 / 5 (3) Jan 18, 2019
If there saying, in between tea breaks they can down tools, stop work and go of with their friends
to a glorified tea room
the majority of this diverse working population are in for a rude awakening
the firm will go bankrupt
these diverse workers will have their second rude awakening
when they take these bankrupt boss's to court for diverse employment sacking
this is going to be interesting
especially for lawyers
where are lawyers going to get their money from bankrupt business
these diverse workers are certainly well on their way
to getting the employment popularity medal of the year

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.