Many Midwesterners will likely never believe in climate change. Here's how to encourage them to act anyway

Many Midwesterners will likely never believe in climate change. Here’s how to encourage them to act anyway
A farm in LaSalle County, Illinois. Credit: Eddie J. Rodriquez/

,The number of politically conservative Americans who are climate skeptics is growing, and the evidence suggests that they're unlikely to change their opinions.

This is particularly evident in the Midwest. Although 61 percent of U.S. adults are concerned about global warming, in many Midwestern counties more than half of adults are not at all worried about the issue.

Efforts to meet the dire calls of the UN's climate change report cannot neglect this region. Our work shows that there are some strategies that can encourage protective climate actions, even in skeptical regions like the Midwest.

Skeptics in the Midwest

The Midwest – defined here as the states of Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, Missouri and Minnesota – is a key contributor to climate change in the U.S.

Across the region, per-capita greenhouse gas emissions are exceptionally high. The typical Midwesterner emits about 22 percent more emissions than the national individual average.

The Midwest is also threatened by the impacts of climate change. Warming temperatures and rising humidity are leading to more heat waves and heavy rain. That puts additional stress on transportation and energy infrastructure, as well as introduces significant health risks. If the Midwest does not prepare for these events, energy demands and associated emissions in the region will likely increase, as will the number of deaths from climatic events.

Researchers have suggested a number of policies, individual actions and projects that could address the Midwest's significant contributions to and vulnerabilities to climate change. However, whether or not these actions are pursued appears to be highly tied to public attitudes toward climate change.

Over time, Americans have become further entrenched in their partisan view of climate change, with conservatives becoming increasingly skeptical. The percentage of Republicans who believe human activity contributes to rising global temperatures declined by 10 points between 2001 and 2016, while the percentage of Democrats who believe that increased.

Midwesterners who identify as either politically conservative or Republican appear to be highly skeptical of climate change. For instance, only 46 percent of Republicans in our home state, Indiana, agreed that climate change was occurring, compared to 80 percent of the Democrats.

Many Midwesterners will likely never believe in climate change. Here’s how to encourage them to act anyway
Chart: The Conversation, CC-BY-ND Source: Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development (2016)

Additionally, it would also be wrong to assume that only uneducated conservatives are climate skeptics. Rather, political orientation appears to moderate the influence of education on skepticism, meaning more educated conservatives are actually more confident in their skepticism.

This research suggest that attempts to change skeptics' minds would likely fail, both in the Midwest and in the country as a whole.

Preserving, not changing

If skeptics will not accept the reality of human-caused climate change and that it's here to stay, what can be done?

Conservatives appear to be particularly opposed to the idea that humans cause climate change. Past research suggests this may be a result of conservatives' preference for the status quo, preserving life as it is (or was). Rejecting humans' involvement also means rejecting the need to change society and your value system.

This perspective may actually make conservatives particularly open to a resilience approach to climate change. Resilience focuses on implementing household or community practices that reduce vulnerability to the impacts of climate change. For instance, the risks of flash floods from heavy rain can be reduced by installing water-absorbent green infrastructure, like permeable pavement and rain gardens.

This approach emphasizes preserving, rather than changing, society. It can be pursued without believing that humans are causing the environmental issues. In consequence, one can argue that efforts to increase climate resilience align with conservative attitudes. Preliminary research suggests conservatives support and undertake resilience practices at similarly high rates to liberals.

At Indiana University's Environmental Resilience Institute, we meet regularly with mayors, county commissioners and other local officials. Our conversations with conservative leaders about climate change are often met with statements that climate change is difficult to acknowledge. But the topics of most concern listed by public officials during these meetings – flooding, business development, workforce development, crime and blighted housing – can be aligned with climate resilience strategies.

Public leaders in Indiana are conducting studies on how to reduce the impact of flash flooding to protect the local economy and quality of life, converting streetlamps to LEDs as a crime-prevention strategy, installing green infrastructure to revitalize blighted neighborhoods and reduce runoff from , and introducing an electric car share program as a way to avoid dependence on foreign oil. These approaches are pursued to increase climate resilience, but many also decrease emissions.

Though our outreach is in still early stages, preliminary success suggests an important point: Efforts to address in one of the most skeptical, conservative regions of the U.S. may be better served by focusing on preparing for environmental changes, and not on what is causing them.

Explore further

Poll finds vast gaps in US climate views

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation: Many Midwesterners will likely never believe in climate change. Here's how to encourage them to act anyway (2018, October 22) retrieved 20 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Oct 22, 2018
An ignored fact is that those who are not unthinking propaganda followers from "colleges", living on their parent's money, looking toward a guaranteed big money job in a corporation have learned not to trust the Democratic Rackets. They know they aren't responsible for the faults and flaws of blacks. They know that illegal aliens are not legal immigrants. They know the sex deviances are not normal and not healthy. They know that a woman with the depraved indifference to kill life she brought about simply to narcissistically avoid a few months of inconvenience is not necessarily noble. And they know they are not "deplorable" for realizing the Democratic Rackets is just a sleazy power mongering fraud intended only to make the rich richer. Note, even this article is peddling surreptitiously the idea that Midwesterners can't see what's in front of them.

Oct 22, 2018
Most people don't even bother reading julianpenrod's posts, but considering that blatant racism is sprinkled in, perhaps they should read and Report.

Oct 22, 2018
Global warming is affecting the Midwestern U.S. like everywhere else, but folks there don't have to worry about hurricanes and sea level rise. Even so, I suspect their well-known compassion for others will continue to drive these numbers in the right direction over time.

Rapid Intensification

Hurricane Willa bearing down on Mexico right now could be the new poster child for rapid intensification. I read it went from a tropical storm to a Category 5 in just 48 hours. As rapid intensification becomes the new normal, additional millions of folks still clinging to homes around the gulf coast will be plenty goddamn worried about global warming. All gulf coast states are already above 50%.


Oct 23, 2018
A 1-star rating from Surveillance_Egg_Unit, also a racist.

Oct 23, 2018
I say we make a law that states only get as much money from the Federal Government as they put in in taxes. Let's do that for a while and see how the Midwest gets along.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more