Flooding caused by old data

October 11, 2018 by Adam Dove, Carnegie Mellon University Department of Engineering and Public Policy
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Water is a powerful force, and as such can pose a major threat to our infrastructure. Thanks to our changing climate, that threat is greater than ever. U.S. stormwater infrastructure—including sewer lines and curbside grates—is designed using precipitation data gathered the Federal government and used by State Departments of Transportation (DOT). But according to Carnegie Mellon University Civil and Environmental Engineering (CEE) Ph.D. student Tania Lopez-Cantu and Associate Professor Costa Samaras, these data may not be sufficient for designing and building adequate infrastructure—increasing the risk of flooding.

In a recent study published in Environmental Research Letters, titled "Temporal and spatial evaluation of stormwater engineering standards reveals risks and priorities across the United States," Lopez-Cantu and Samaras reviewed the State DOT design manuals of the 48 contiguous and the District of Colombia. DOTs use these manuals to guide their planning and construction. But according to this research, some of these manuals are based on out-of-date , and none directly account for future change, which could spell trouble for many state residents.

"As greenhouse gases from human activities have increased in the last few decades," says Samaras, "our air has gotten warmer, and warmer air can hold more water. Many cities and communities are experiencing heavier rainfall, and stormwater infrastructure can't seem to keep up—which can lead to dangerous flash flooding and infrastructure failure."

But could precipitation really have changed that much? As part of their research, the team examined precipitation levels provided in Federal government documents that are used for infrastructure design, for each individual state spanning from 1961 to the most recent updates starting in 2004. In this period, 43 states showed statistically significant precipitation changes in more than 90% of the study area. This means that any infrastructure installed before the most recent update to these manuals might not be equipped to handle present and future climate conditions. Considering that the majority of U.S. infrastructure is, on average, 20 years old or older, the problem isn't just widespread—it's nearly universal.

Using this analysis, the team sorted states into four categories in order to prioritize which states should update their stormwater design manuals first. The highest priority states were chosen based on three criteria:

  • They experienced a 10% or greater increase in precipitation between 1961 and 2000.
  • They published their most recent design manuals prior to the release of the last precipitation document.
  • They were in the lower half of their regional index, which compares if states in the same climate region are designing the same stormwater infrastructure for a 25-year storm versus a 50-year storm, for example.

"Under higher return periods," says Lopez-Cantu, "many states in the Northeast and upper Midwest were found to be in high priority categories. These states should update their design standards to ensure new drainage infrastructure performs under current and projected precipitation levels."

The team found that stormwater infrastructure risks would go up in all states under climate change. If these manuals are not updated with the most recent data, as well as planning for a future climate for all infrastructure, it is likely these high-priority areas—and eventually all other areas as well—will face severe street flooding.

Explore further: Making climate models simple

More information: Tania Lopez-Cantu et al. Temporal and spatial evaluation of stormwater engineering standards reveals risks and priorities across the United States, Environmental Research Letters (2018). DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/aac696

Related Stories

Making climate models simple

December 14, 2017

For many years, climate change has been a looming threat on the minds of infrastructure engineers. But recently, this threat has become much more apparent to the general public. Many effects of climate change can be damaging ...

Changes are needed to fund US water infrastructure

September 19, 2018

Water infrastructure in the western United States was funded in the early and mid-20th Century by federal financing through the Bureau of Reclamation, but such financing has declined in recent decades and there has been increased ...

Recommended for you

Antarctic ice shelf 'sings' as winds whip across its surface

October 16, 2018

Winds blowing across snow dunes on Antarctica's Ross Ice Shelf cause the massive ice slab's surface to vibrate, producing a near-constant set of seismic "tones" scientists could potentially use to monitor changes in the ice ...

New understanding of Mekong River incision

October 16, 2018

An international team of earth scientists has linked the establishment of the Mekong River to a period of major intensification of the Asian monsoon during the middle Miocene, about 17 million years ago, findings that supplant ...

World Heritage sites threatened by sea level rise

October 16, 2018

From Venice and the tower of Pisa to the medieval city of Rhodes, dozens of UNESCO World Heritage sites in the Mediterranean basin are deeply threatened by rising sea levels, researchers warned Tuesday.

Was life on the early Earth purple?

October 16, 2018

Early life forms on Earth may have been able to generate metabolic energy from sunlight using a purple-pigmented molecule called retinal that possibly predates the evolution of chlorophyll and photosynthesis. If retinal has ...

New interactive scenario explorer for 1.5 degrees C pathways

October 16, 2018

IIASA and the Integrated Assessment Modeling Consortium (IAMC) have made the scenarios underlying last week's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 1.5°C Special Report publicly available in an interactive online ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.