Amazon rainforest conservation victories spill losses to neighbors

October 4, 2018, Michigan State University
Brazil's savannah is a biodiveristy hotspot, but doesn't command the conservation attention the rainforests garner. Credit: Ramon Felipe Bicudo da Silva, Michigan State University

New research suggests that protecting the Amazon rainforest from deforestation may just be shifting the damage to a less renowned neighbor. The unintended consequences are profound.

Efforts to rein in agriculture activities in the Amazon have led to an 80 percent reduction in rainforest destruction between the early 2000s to 2015. Yet in this month's Journal of Geographic Sciences Michigan State University (MSU) researchers show that farming and ranching have caused 6.6 times more destruction of in the nearby Tocantins State of the Cerrado in central Brazil, without a corresponding uprising of concern.

"We are not saying reducing rainforest destruction in the Amazon shouldn't get attention," said Yue Dou, a research associate in MSU's Centers for Systems Integration and Sustainability (CSIS). "But attention has to be paid in the major destruction of another area which also has significant biodiversity."

Cerrado is a Brazilian savanna of varied, wooded grasslands that cover more than 20 percent of the country. Amazon's rainforest terrain of towering, ancient broadleaf trees, has a wide appeal and international fascination. The Cerrado, though a global biodiversity hotspot, hasn't commanded the same attention. Both areas of Brazil have been farmed aggressively. Two supply-chain agreements placed bans on purchasing soybeans grown on Amazonian lands after 2006 or beef raised on Amazon land deforested after 2009 vastly slowed deforestation. Researchers calculated that the policies reduced deforestation from 22,766 square miles to 11,013 square miles in the Amazon.

Yet destruction in the Cerrado surged as soybean farmers and cattle ranchers sought new places to produce highly demanded foods. In the state of Tocantins alone the conversion to agricultural land increased from 465 square miles to 3,067 square miles from 2007 to 2015.

The authors of "Spillover effect offsets the conservation effort in the Amazon" note that the reasons behind the hidden impacts are complex and can be difficult to understand—so it's hard to realize success in one part of the country can be spilling over with setbacks in a neighboring area. Colonization, road building, available infrastructure and effectiveness of law enforcement are among the many moving parts that cause people to cut down natural vegetation and farm. Comparing rainforest to Cerrado also is challenging.

That's why scientists worked with the telecoupling framework capable of examining many different factors. Telecoupling framework integrates many different scientific disciplines to allow scientists to holistically understand ecological and socioeconomic interactions over distances.

"In our increasingly complex world, we need to look at problems in new ways that can reflect subtleties and truths that are counterintuitive," said Jianguo "Jack" Liu, CSIS director and co-author. "Progress in sustainability must be genuine and we can't allow ourselves to be blinded by success in one place at the expense of invisible impacts on other places. The helps to bring together many different kinds of information to fully understand important change in our telecoupled world."

Explore further: Parts of Amazon on the verge of forest-to-grassland shift

More information: Yue Dou et al, Spillover effect offsets the conservation effort in the Amazon, Journal of Geographical Sciences (2018). DOI: 10.1007/s11442-018-1539-0

Related Stories

Parts of Amazon on the verge of forest-to-grassland shift

September 3, 2013

The stability of the Amazon rainforest, and the ecosystem's resilience to widespread deforestation, may be much lower than previously thought. The replacement of stands of trees with grassland changes evapotranspiration rates ...

Amazon deforestation leaps 16 percent in 2015

November 28, 2015

Illegal logging and clearing of Brazil's Amazon rainforest increased 16 percent in the last year, the government said, in a setback to the aim of stopping destruction of the world's greatest forest by 2030.

Recommended for you

Machine learning-detected signal predicts time to earthquake

December 18, 2018

Machine-learning research published in two related papers today in Nature Geoscience reports the detection of seismic signals accurately predicting the Cascadia fault's slow slippage, a type of failure observed to precede ...

The full story on climate change requires the long view

December 17, 2018

The science is clear that human activities over the last century have contributed to greenhouse-like warming of the Earth's surface. Much of the global conversation around climate change fixates on what individual countries ...

Does saving energy save the climate?

December 17, 2018

To stop climate change, saving energy matters less than switching to renewable energy. Indeed, says Anthony Patt, it isn't clear whether saving energy makes much of a difference at all.

Do you know the carbon footprint of your food choices?

December 17, 2018

Shoppers greatly underestimate the difference their food choices can make to climate change, but they'll favour items with a lower carbon footprint if they're given clear information on the label, according to new research ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.