Dark matter clusters could reveal nature of dark energy

September 10, 2018 by Jon Cartwright, Horizon: The EU Research & Innovation Magazine
Gravitational lensing in galaxy clusters such as Abell 370 are helping scientists to measure the dark matter distribution. Credit: NASA, ESA, the Hubble SM4 ERO Team and ST-ECF

Scientists are hoping to understand one of the most enduring mysteries in cosmology by simulating its effect on the clustering of galaxies.

That mystery is dark – the phenomenon that scientists hypothesise is causing the universe to expand at an ever-faster rate. No-one knows anything about dark energy, except that it could be, somehow, blowing pretty much everything apart.

Meanwhile, dark energy has an equally shady cousin – dark matter. This invisible substance appears to have been clustering around galaxies, and preventing them from spinning themselves apart, by lending them an extra gravitational pull.

Such a clustering effect is in competition with dark energy's accelerating expansion. Yet studying the precise nature of this competition might shed some light on dark energy.

"Many dark energy models are already ruled out with current data," said Dr. Alexander Mead, a cosmologist at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada, who is working on a project called Halo modelling. "Hopefully in future we can rule more out."

Gravitational lensing

Currently, the only way dark matter can be observed is by looking for the effects of its gravitational pull on other matter and light. The intense gravitational field it produces can cause light to distort and bend over large distances – an effect known as gravitational lensing.

By mapping the dark matter in distant parts of the cosmos, scientists can work out how much dark matter clustering there is – and in principle how that clustering is being affected by dark energy.

The link between gravitational lensing and dark matter clustering is not straightforward, however. To interpret the data from telescopes, scientists must refer to detailed cosmological models – mathematical representations of complex systems.

Dr. Mead is developing a clustering model that he hopes will have enough accuracy to distinguish between different dark-energy hypotheses.

"An analogy I like a lot is with turbulence. In turbulent fluid flow you can talk about currents and eddies, which are nice words, but the reality of how fluid in a pipe goes from flowing calmly to flowing in a turbulent fashion is extremely complicated."

Fifth force

One of the more exotic theories is that dark energy is the result of a hitherto undetected fifth force, in addition to nature's four known forces—gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak nuclear forces inside atoms.

A more common hypothesis for dark energy, however, is known as the cosmological constant, which was put forward by Albert Einstein as part of his general theory of relativity. It is often believed to describe an all-pervading sea of virtual particles that are continually popping into and out of existence throughout the universe.

One way to rule out the cosmological constant hypothesis, of course, is to prove that dark energy is not constant at all. This is the goal of Dr. Pier Stefano Corasaniti of the Paris Observatory in France, who – in a project called EDECS – is approaching dark-matter clustering from a different direction.

Instead of attempting to model clustering from data, he is beginning specifically with a dynamical – that is, not constant – hypothesis of dark energy, and trying to predict how dark matter would cluster if this was the case.

Pushing the limits

There are, in principle, infinite ways dark energy can vary in space and time, although many theories have already been ruled out by existing observations. Dr. Corasaniti is focussing his simulations on types of dynamical dark energy that push at the edges of these observational limits, paving the way for tests with future experiments.

The simulations, which trace the evolution of numerous, "N-body' dark matter particles, require supercomputers running for long periods of time, processing several petabytes (one thousand million million bytes) of data.

"We have run among the largest cosmological N-body simulations ever realised," Dr. Corasaniti said.

Dr. Corasaniti's simulations predict that the way dark energy evolves over time ought to affect clustering. This, in turn, alters the efficiency with which galaxies form in ways that would not be the case with constant dark energy.

The predictions his models are making could be tested with the help of forthcoming telescopes such as the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope in Chile and the Square Kilometre Array in Australia and South Africa, as well as by satellite missions such as Euclid (EUropean Cooperation for LIghtning Detection) and WFIRST (Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope).

"If turns out to be a dynamical phenomenon this will have a profound implication not only on cosmology, but on our understanding of fundamental physics," said Dr. Corasaniti.

Explore further: Researchers study gravitational lensing around an extremely dense galaxy cluster

Related Stories

Mapping dark matter

July 24, 2017

About eighty-five percent of the matter in the universe is in the form of dark matter, whose nature remains a mystery. The rest of the matter in the universe is of the kind found in atoms. Astronomers studying the evolution ...

New insights on dark energy

October 2, 2017

The universe is not only expanding - it is accelerating outward, driven by what is commonly referred to as "dark energy." The term is a poetic analogy to label for dark matter, the mysterious material that dominates the matter ...

Recommended for you

New space industry emerges: on-orbit servicing

November 17, 2018

Imagine an airport where thousands of planes, empty of fuel, are left abandoned on the tarmac. That is what has been happening for decades with satellites that circle the Earth.

SpaceX gets nod to put 12,000 satellites in orbit

November 16, 2018

SpaceX got the green light this week from US authorities to put a constellation of nearly 12,000 satellites into orbit in order to boost cheap, wireless internet access by the 2020s.

Electric blue thrusters propelling BepiColombo to Mercury

November 16, 2018

In mid-December, twin discs will begin glowing blue on the underside of a minibus-sized spacecraft in deep space. At that moment Europe and Japan's BepiColombo mission will have just come a crucial step closer to Mercury.

Overflowing crater lakes carved canyons across Mars

November 16, 2018

Today, most of the water on Mars is locked away in frozen ice caps. But billions of years ago it flowed freely across the surface, forming rushing rivers that emptied into craters, forming lakes and seas. New research led ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Bob West
1 / 5 (6) Sep 10, 2018
Dark matter is a supersolid that fills 'empty' space, strongly interacts with ordinary matter and is displaced by ordinary matter. What is referred to geometrically as curved spacetime physically exists in nature as the state of displacement of the supersolid dark matter. The state of displacement of the supersolid dark matter is gravity.

The supersolid dark matter displaced by a galaxy pushes back, causing the stars in the outer arms of the galaxy to orbit the galactic center at the rate in which they do.

Displaced supersolid dark matter is curved spacetime.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 11, 2018
Could both so called dark energy and dark matter be the result of antimatter particles that have negative mass, so cause gravity to push rather than pull.
These antimatter particles would fill the space between galaxies and may be the missing antimatter from the big bang (supposedly created in equal amounts to normal matter).
3 / 5 (8) Sep 11, 2018
Could both so called dark energy and dark matter be the result of antimatter particles that have negative mass, so cause gravity to push rather than pull.
These antimatter particles would fill the space between galaxies and may be the missing antimatter from the big bang (supposedly created in equal amounts to normal matter).

No, for a really wide variety of reasons.
Read the Wikipedia page on antimatter for a start.
3.4 / 5 (5) Sep 11, 2018
Nice, that dark energy likely is simply vacuum energy needs to be checked by independent means.

@Colbourne: Some obvious problems with that suggestion:
- Antimatter obeys gravity in experiments such as when antiprotons are made and trapped in magnetic bottles. (Though to be fair people are still checking, I think.)
- Dark matter is 5 times matter, not equal amounts.
- We know most matter and antimatter annihilated each other. This nicely makes for the cosmic background photons at 10^9 times the remaining matter and dark matter amount.
- Dark energy is not pushing by somehow curving space "the other way". (How? Gravity is monopolar seen as charge in a quantum field approximation, and simply curves space in a more general [sic] general relativity approximation.) It puts a decreasing pressure differential in a GR stress-energy tensor before/after comparison, sometimes roughly thermodynamic modeled as how you pull a plunger in a closed tube decreases pressure inside.
not rated yet Oct 01, 2018
I posit this hypothesis that does away with both dark matter and also dark energy. I posit that at a distance of approximately 1.5 million light-years gravity becomes slightly repulsive, gradually increasing with distance to achieve a peak repulsion, and then decreasing with distance to zero.

Thus, cosmological expansion is caused by galaxies pushing against each other, and galactic rotation can be explained by the fact that each galaxy is surrounded by a "womb" of dust, gas, and other galaxies, and this "womb" pushes with repulsive gravity upon the outer stars of a galaxy to keep them in orbit at a higher speed than expected.

I give a cosmological / mathematical justification for this behavior in my Reddit article:


At the bottom, in the responses, I explain how General Relativity can be adjusted so as to retain time dilation while rejecting curved space and retaining flat, 3D, Euclidean space.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.