NASA survey seen as steppingstone for astronomy

April 2, 2018 by Emily Walla, University of Arizona
NASA survey seen as steppingstone for astronomy
An artist's impression of exo-zodiacal light viewed on an alien world . Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

Imagine trying to see a firefly next to a distant spotlight, where the beams from the spotlight all but drown out the faint glow from the firefly. Add fog, and both lights are dimmed. Is the glow from the firefly still visible at all?

That is the question the Hunt for Observable Signatures of Terrestrial Systems, or HOSTS, Survey was tasked with answering, albeit on a cosmic scale. Using the Large Binocular Telescope Interferometer, or LBTI, in Arizona, the HOSTS Survey determines the brightness and density of warm floating in nearby ' habitable zones, where liquid water could exist on the surface of a planet.

This research will contribute to a once-per-decade report on the field of astrophysics, produced by the National Academies, that NASA uses to help chart a course for future missions, some of which could continue the search for around other stars, known as exoplanets. But before telescopes for prospective exoplanet-hunting missions can be designed, astronomers must know if there is a fundamental limit to their ability to see a tiny, dim planet next to a bright star when the system is shrouded in dust.

"Our result is that there is no fundamental problem," said Steve Ertel of the University of Arizona's Steward Observatory, instrument scientist for the Large Binocular Telescope Interferometer and lead author on the paper, "The HOSTS Survey - Exo-Zodiacal Dust Measurements for 30 Stars," which is published in the in the Astronomical Journal. "Now it is a technical challenge."

A potential mission to search for terrestrial planets probably would include a space-based telescope, and the HOSTS Survey will help determine its size.

"The more dust there is, the bigger the telescope has to be to image a planet," Ertel said. "It is important to know what telescope size is required, so the costs can be minimized."

The dust that orbits in the plane of our solar system is known as "zodiacal dust." The HOSTS Survey has determined that the typical level of zodiacal dust around other stars—called "exo-zodiacal dust"—is less than 15 times the amount found in our own solar system's habitable zone. Stars with more than that amount of dust make poor targets for future exoplanet imaging missions, as planets would be difficult to see through the haze. One such star with a prominent dust disk, called Epsilon Eridani, is one of the 10 nearest stars investigated by the HOSTS Survey.

"It is very nearby," Ertel said. "It's a star very similar to our sun. It would be a very nice target to look at, but we figured out that it would not be a good idea. You would not be able to see an Earth-like planet around it."

'That's Our Best Guess'

If dust and debris make finding rocky worlds challenging, then why search for planets in dusty systems?

The Large Binocular Telescope, located on Mount Graham . Credit: Phil Hinz/LBT)
"There is dust in our own solar system," said Philip Hinz, the lead for the HOSTS Survey team and associate professor of astronomy at the UA. "We want to characterize stars that are similar to our own solar system, because that's our best guess as to what other planetary systems might have life."

The pattern of dust distribution around a host star also can tell astronomers something about the potential planets in a star system. Some stars have wide, continuous disks that fill the whole system. This is considered a standard model, as dust is formed during asteroid collisions far from the star and then spirals inward toward the star so that it is evenly distributed throughout the system.

"This is something that we expected to see, but we also saw some surprises," Ertel said.

Take Vega, one of the brightest stars in the night sky. For more than 30 years, astronomers have known that Vega has a massive belt of far from the star, analogous to our solar system's Kuiper Belt. The star also has a disk of very close to it.

"We were thinking that Vega must have dust in the habitable zone as well, because it has dust very close and dust farther away," Ertel said. "But we looked at Vega's habitable zone and we didn't find anything."

Vega's habitable zone is devoid of detectable dust, which could indicate that the system has planets that prevent dust from collecting there. Planets have not yet been detected around Vega, but current observations are not even sensitive enough to detect a planet as large as Jupiter near the star, let alone Earth-like planets.

"This could be an indication of a planet we cannot see," Ertel said. "It could be a massive planet outside the , or it could be several Earth-mass planets."

Other stars had different dust distributions: nothing far away or very close, but huge amounts of bright, warm dust in their habitable zones. If a star does not have a Kuiper Belt analogue producing dust, but it still has a ring of warm dust, there must be another mechanism at play in the system.

"There might be giant planets like Jupiter and Saturn in that system, but that system's asteroid belt has a lot of mass to it, so you're getting a lot of collisions that make large amounts of dust," Hinz said.

Studying these dust disks provides astronomers with more pieces to the puzzle of planetary architecture. While past studies have looked for planets very close to, and very far away from, stars to determine where planets are typically located in star systems, the HOSTS Survey is determining how dust and asteroid belts appear in the average star system.

The LBTI is the most precise interferometer to date. Credit: Phil Hinz/LBTI
"The survey is ongoing, so we have more questions than answers," Hinz said. "We are in the early days for trying to figure out how it all fits together."

Detection Methods

Exo-zodiacal dust has been warmed to room temperature by its host star, so it glows when viewed in infrared wavelengths—that is, in infrared light, emitted by heated objects. However, at those wavelengths, stars glow 10,000 times brighter than the dust. To see how much dust was swirling around their chosen 30 stars, the HOSTS Survey detected the dust disks using a technique called "Bracewell nulling interferometry," after Ronald Bracewell, the astronomer who first suggested the method.

"Interferometry means 'measuring the interference between two wave trains,'" Hinz said.

The Large Binocular Telescope, or LBT, has the unique capability to perform this interferometry, as it is designed so that its twin telescopes can each detect light waves that are perfectly out of phase with each other. When waves are out of phase, they cancel each other out, causing their peaks and troughs to flatten.

"The result is that you cancel out the light from the star," Hinz said.

A similar technique was introduced in 1998, using the Multiple Mirror Telescope on Arizona's Mount Hopkins.

"It took almost 20 years to refine the technique so it is precise enough so that we could get rid of the star and sensitive enough so that we could see the remaining light from the dust," Hinz said.

Achieving this cancellation requires that the LBT be adaptable. After light bounces off the telescope's 8-meter primary mirrors, it reflects off the secondary mirrors and into detectors. The secondary mirrors are deformable so that they can correct for the distortions of light caused by ripples in the atmosphere. In order for the interferometry to work, these corrections must be accurate to one one-hundredth of the width of a human hair.

Explore further: Very Large Telescope Interferometer detects exozodiacal light

More information: The HOSTS Survey - Exo-Zodiacal Dust Measurements for 30 Stars,

Related Stories

Very Large Telescope Interferometer detects exozodiacal light

November 3, 2014

By using the full power of the Very Large Telescope Interferometer an international team of astronomers has discovered exozodiacal light close to the habitable zones around nine nearby stars. This light is starlight reflected ...

Telescope to seek dust where other Earths may lie

January 22, 2015

The NASA-funded Large Binocular Telescope Interferometer, or LBTI, has completed its first study of dust in the "habitable zone" around a star, opening a new door to finding planets like Earth. Dust is a natural byproduct ...

Planetary influences on young stellar disks

December 14, 2015

A newborn star typically has a disk of gas and dust from which planets develop as the dust grains collide, stick together and grow. Stars older than about five million years lack evidence for these disks, however, suggesting ...

Giant exoplanet hunters: Look for debris disks

October 11, 2017

There's no map showing all the billions of exoplanets hiding in our galaxy—they're so distant and faint compared to their stars, it's hard to find them. Now, astronomers hunting for new worlds have established a possible ...

Telescopes find evidence for asteroid belt around Vega

January 8, 2013

(—Astronomers have discovered what appears to be a large asteroid belt around the star Vega, the second brightest star in northern night skies. The scientists used data from NASA's Spitzer Space Telescope and the ...

ALMA discovers cold dust around nearest star

November 3, 2017

The ALMA Observatory has detected dust around Proxima Centauri. These observations reveal the glow coming from cold dust in a region between one to four times as far from Proxima Centauri as the Earth is from the Sun. The ...

Recommended for you

In colliding galaxies, a pipsqueak shines bright

February 20, 2019

In the nearby Whirlpool galaxy and its companion galaxy, M51b, two supermassive black holes heat up and devour surrounding material. These two monsters should be the most luminous X-ray sources in sight, but a new study using ...

When does one of the central ideas in economics work?

February 20, 2019

The concept of equilibrium is one of the most central ideas in economics. It is one of the core assumptions in the vast majority of economic models, including models used by policymakers on issues ranging from monetary policy ...

Research reveals why the zebra got its stripes

February 20, 2019

Why do zebras have stripes? A study published in PLOS ONE today takes us another step closer to answering this puzzling question and to understanding how stripes actually work.

Correlated nucleons may solve 35-year-old mystery

February 20, 2019

A careful re-analysis of data taken at the Department of Energy's Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility has revealed a possible link between correlated protons and neutrons in the nucleus and a 35-year-old mystery. ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.