Protecting our coasts naturally

February 16, 2018 by Dr Rebecca Morris, Dr Teresa Konlechner, Dr Marco Ghisalberti And Professor Stephen Swearer, University of Melbourne
Mangroves planted within concrete cultivars will be placed within Port Phillip Bay as part of a trial of nature-based coastal defences. Credit: Reefball

As sea levels rise and coastal communities face the threat of erosion and flooding, coastal defence structures, often built with concrete, have become the norm in many parts of the world.

But these hard engineered structures, like seawalls, breakwaters and groynes, are both expensive and bad for the environment.

Our team of University of Melbourne scientists is joining a growing number of international researchers looking at whether natural coastal defence structures could be a better option. We are trialling mussel reefs and in Melbourne's Port Phillip Bay to see how well they protect our shorelines.

Natural coastlines have in-built coastal defence in the form of sand dunes and beaches, saltmarsh, mangroves, seagrass and kelp beds, and coral and shellfish reefs.

These natural structures can reduce the height of waves as they approach the shore and trap sediment, increasing the height of the land relative to sea level. This reduces flooding and erosion.

Mussel reefs and mangrove forests are particularly important in Port Phillip because they are native habitats that have suffered significant declines historically. We are creating the mussel reef from recycled shell and natural basalt rock, and we expect it to reduce wave height and promote accretion of the eroding foreshore.

For the mangrove forests we will use a 'hybrid' approach, which involves planting the mangroves within concrete cultivars that attenuate waves, accrete sediment and provide the right conditions for the forests to grow.

Elsewhere, other natural habitats are being used to protect shorelines. For instance, in the United States, oyster reefs have been widely restored on the east coast to provide erosion control. Oysters need something hard to attach to, and lots of creative reef designs have been engineered to replace lost habitats and enhance oyster populations.

Mussel reefs have significantly declined in Port Phillip Bay, but some will be re-introduced as part of a trial of nature-based coastal defences. Credit: Anna Barnett/Flickr

In contrast, artificial structures are expensive to build and maintain and cause significant ecological damage. In particular, they lead to a loss of biodiversity through the replacement of natural habitats and are often hotspots for invasive species.

Determining value for money

Given the threats our shorelines are facing, protecting them into the future needs to be both financially and ecologically sustainable.

Nature-based coastal defence systems present an effective alternative to because they can adapt to changes in climate and self-repair after things like storms—which means they could be cheaper in the long run.

But we don't know yet which option offers better protection for local communities, or the best value for money.

To try and understand this better, we recently published a review of the scientific studies in this field in the journal Global Change Biology.

We found that, although nature-based coastal defence is advocated in the literature, there is a lack field study data on their impact on wave height reduction or building up the shoreline.

Some habitats, like dunes, have been used historically for coastal defence, but data on their effectiveness at reducing shoreline loss is not always reported, making evaluation difficult.

Oyster reefs have been widely restored on the east coast of the United States to help protect shorelines. Credit: Restore our Shores

We need to know which habitats are effective at providing coastal defence, the types of environments in which they work best and the best designs for achieving long-term protection.

This research is only possible through collaborations among scientists, coastal managers and engineers.

A better way of protecting our shorelines

It is particularly important because natural coastal defence systems offer more than just protection from extreme weather events; they also help create ecosystems—certain habitats offer a benefit to humans, like filtration by mussels leading to an increase in water quality.

These need to be taken into consideration in any cost-benefit analyses, and they are an important consideration in our current Port Phillip Bay trial.

Finding a way of using to perform a function previously served by engineered structures is going to require a big shift in our collective mindset; as it demands changes to how we design and evaluate coastal defence infrastructure.

Designing a like a concrete wall based on engineering resilience, constancy and predictability, is in direct contrast to ecological resilience, which promotes variability.

While ecological resilience may not offer the visible reassurance of a solid wall, for example, it offers so much more. Perhaps we need to trust nature to do its job, and allow ecosystems to absorb disturbances and remain in a stable state.

Adapting Australia's coast to climate change is a big challenge that we must address in coming years. After all, 85 per cent of us live within 50km of the coast. This research offers a way of navigating this challenge, while respecting our marine diversity.

Explore further: Innovative restoration of coral reefs helps protect Caribbean islands

More information: Rebecca L. Morris et al. From grey to green: Efficacy of eco-engineering solutions for nature-based coastal defence, Global Change Biology (2018). DOI: 10.1111/gcb.14063

Related Stories

Shellfish reefs: Australia's untold environmental disaster

February 15, 2018

Virtually all of Australia's shellfish reefs have disappeared, making them the country's most threatened ocean ecosystem, scientists said Thursday, calling for more investment to rescue the important marine habitats.

How living structures can better protect our coastline

March 15, 2017

Waves, tides, storms and hurricanes can all take a toll on the coastline, eroding the land and rewriting the shoreline. Those changes can put infrastructure and communities at risk. But researchers are rolling out new guidelines ...

Military turns to oyster reefs to protect against storms

December 26, 2017

Earle Naval Weapons Station, where the Navy loads some of America's most sophisticated weapons onto warships, suffered $50 million worth of damage in Superstorm Sandy. Now the naval pier is fortifying itself with some decidedly ...

Recommended for you

Palm oil: The carbon cost of deforestation

June 19, 2018

A recent study by EPFL and the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research (WSL) shows that intensive farming of palm oil has a major impact on the environment. Both short- and long-term solutions exist, ...

Coral reef 'oases' offer glimmer of hope

June 18, 2018

The identification of small 'oases' in the world's oceans, where corals appear to be thriving, could offer vital insights in the race to save one of the world's most threatened ecosystems.

Checking China's pollution by satellite

June 18, 2018

Air pollution has smothered China's cities in recent decades. In response, the Chinese government has implemented measures to clean up its skies. But are those policies effective? Now an innovative study co-authored by an ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.