How new evidence of sex reversals helps show how sex chromosomes are maintained over evolutionary time

January 30, 2018, Oxford University Press
A new study of the European common frog, Rana temporaria, published in the advanced online edition of the journal Molecular Biology and Evolution, offers some fresh clues that challenge the conventional scientific wisdom on sex-chromosome evolution. Credit: Nicholas Perrin

When it comes to sex, frogs, just like in people, exhibit a similar XX (female) and XY (male) sex chromosome pattern of inheritance.

In humans, while the X chromosome maintains a large number of genes similar to all the other non-, the poor male-associated Y has been shriveling up over eons of time. In frogs however, the Y shows no sign of degeneration, looking just like the X chromosome.

But what keeps this Y chromosome from degeneration?

A new study of the European common , Rana temporaria, published in the advanced online edition of the journal Molecular Biology and Evolution, offers some fresh clues that challenge the conventional scientific wisdom on sex-chromosome evolution.

The prevailing view is that the Y chromosome is shrinking in males because XY is suppressed by either chromosomal inversions or nonhomologous regions.

In frogs however, genetic control over sex determination can vary both within and among populations, resulting in the occurrence of regular sex reversals ('leaky' genetic sex determination).

Nicolas Perrin's research group at the University of Lausanne, including work from lead author Nicolas Rodrigues, has found the first direct evidence that these sex reversals help maintain the Y over evolutionary time.

Perrin has called this the "fountain of youth" hypothesis, and the new evidence helps bring frogs some fresh "water" to his theory.

A key point of this model is that in sex-reversed XY females—-a shuffling of the genomic deck—-known as recombination between the X and the Y chromosomes can take place.

In the study, Perrin's team used a total of 314 adult frogs from a small breeding pond, the Swiss Alpine locality of Meitreile, from which mating pairs were brought to a special outdoor facility at the Lausanne University campus, where frogs laid eggs.

One of the keys to the study was finding among the breeding adults not only a few sex-reversed XX males, but also an extremely rare, XY sex-reversed female. "Our sampling was lucky enough to get one such individual (actually the only XY individual among the 54 sampled females)," said Perrin.

Using 16 sex-linked genetic markers, they carefully measured the number of recombination events, or chromosome crossovers that occurred in their progeny.

They found that recombination in sex chromosomes depends on the phenotypic sex, but not on the genetic sex.

All that seems to matter is being male or female.

"As we show here by including sex-reversed males and females in the analysis, recombination patterns are entirely explained by phenotypic sex, with no detectable effect of genotypic sex, either alone or in interaction. Males, in particular, had strongly reduced recombination independent of sex-chromosome differentiation," said Perrin.

"More importantly (as far as evolutionary consequences are concerned), our present results provide the first direct field evidence that X and Y chromosomes recombine in XY females," said Rodrigues.

They conclude that occurrence of XY-sex reversed female followed by recombination between X and Y chromosomes may be involved in maintaining the state of sex chromosomes in this species and others as well.

"Our results, therefore, bring strong support for the fountain-of-youth model, by showing that X and Y recombine in naturally-occurring sex-reversed XY females," said Perrin. "This result has the potential to account for the lack of sex-chromosome differentiation in Rana temporaria, and by extension in other lineages of amphibians, fishes and non-avian reptiles where sex reversal events have alsobeen documented."

Explore further: The Y chromosome is disappearing – so what will happen to men?

More information: Molecular Biology And Evolution (2018). DOI: 10.1093/molbev/msy008

Related Stories

DNA which only females have

June 4, 2015

In many animal species, the chromosomes differ between the sexes. The male has a Y chromosome. In some animals, however, for example birds, it is the other way round. In birds, the females have their own sex chromosome, the ...

New genes on "deteriorating" Y chromosome

October 25, 2017

The Y chromosome, which is found only in males, is difficult to decode even with the latest sequencing technologies. Among evolutionary biologists, the question as to which genes lie on the male sex chromosome and where they ...

Recommended for you

Computing the origin of life

December 14, 2018

As a principal investigator in the NASA Ames Exobiology Branch, Andrew Pohorille is searching for the origin of life on Earth, yet you won't find him out in the field collecting samples or in a laboratory conducting experiments ...

Black widow spiders dial up posture for survival and sex

December 14, 2018

A new study led by Western University's Natasha Mhatre shows that body dynamics and posture are crucial to how black widow spiders decode the important vibrations that travel through their webs and up their legs. Black widows ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.