Children negatively impacted by early intervention restrictions

December 8, 2017, University of Sydney
Credit: University of Sydney

As the government extends its income management program, new research indicates the original rollout in the Northern Territory did not improve school attendance and birth outcomes, and had negative short-term effects.

Analysis reveals the federal government's initial scheme – first introduced in 2007 during the Northern Territory Emergency Response (NTER) or 'intervention', and now commonly known as Cashless Debit Card – coincided with significant negative outcomes for children in the short term, and no noticeable improvements in the long run. Income management restricts a large portion of welfare payments to being spent only on essentials such as food, housing and clothing.

The research team, from the School of Economics at the University of Sydney and the Menzies School of Health Research in Darwin, examined daily attendance records of children attending NT government schools in the 73 Aboriginal communities and 10 town camps affected by the policy. As income management was introduced to communities in stages between September 2007 and October 2008, the researchers used this as a 'natural experiment' and compared the pre- and post- attendance outcomes for children in each of these communities. The researchers found declined by four percent on average in the first five months, after which attendance rates eventually returned to their initial levels.

In a second study, the research team compared the birth weights of babies born in communities affected by income management with babies born in communities not yet affected by the policy. The study showed the average birthweight of babies who were in utero when income management was introduced to their community was over 100 grams lighter, and that the babies were at slightly higher risk of low birthweight (less than 2500 grams).

"Our studies focussed on school attendance and birth outcomes because they are good proxies for child wellbeing; the data measured them accurately and frequently, important given the policy was rolled out in such a short time frame," said lead investigator of the studies Associate Professor Stefanie Schurer, from the University of Sydney's School of Economics and Charles Perkins Centre.

"It was only possible to do this analysis by the linkage of de-identified attendance and birth outcome data provided by the NT Departments of Health and Education," she added.

Professor Sven Silburn, a co-investigator from the Menzies School of Health Research and leader of the NHMRC-funded Northern Territory data linkage partnership through which access to the data was facilitated, said: "We don't know whether the negative impact we found was because of the policy itself, because of administrative challenges and implementation problems – for which we find some evidence in the data – or because of negative sentiment surrounding its compulsory introduction in these communities.

"We know from the data that the negative impacts of income management on were not due to an increase in mothers' smoking or drinking during pregnancy – in fact these behaviours were unaffected," he added.

Associate Professor Schurer explained: "We are now looking at alternative data sources to try to explain our findings. A preliminary analysis of data from the Longitudinal Study of Indigenous Children (LSIC) showed that a transition into income management was associated with an increase in the mother's experience of being 'humbugged', or receiving excessive demands for money, and reporting that children were being upset by family arguments."

"Income management changes the way household resources are allocated and consumed and therefore may affect the dynamics of family decision-making. It would seem important to ensure this doesn't inadvertently lead to additional stress and conflict in the household," she added.

"Considering our findings, we are concerned that the federal government's intended extension of income management, even in an amended form, may have similar unintended consequences," Professor Silburn concluded.

Explore further: Prenatal Medicaid benefits boost health gains across generations

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Study reveals patterns in STEM grades of girls versus boys

September 25, 2018

A new study, led by UNSW Sydney Ph.D. student Rose O'Dea, has explored patterns in academic grades of 1.6 million students, showing that girls and boys perform very similarly in STEM—including at the top of the class.

Chinese Cretaceous fossil highlights avian evolution

September 24, 2018

A newly identified extinct bird species from a 127 million-year-old fossil deposit in northeastern China provides new information about avian development during the early evolution of flight.

The first predators and their self-repairing teeth

September 24, 2018

The earliest predators appeared on Earth 480 million years ago—and they even had teeth capable of repairing themselves. A team of palaeontologists led by Bryan Shirley and Madleen Grohganz from the Chair for Palaeoenviromental ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.