Meteorite's origins point to possible undiscovered asteroid

November 16, 2017 by Amanda Doyle, Astrobiology Magazine,
The Bunburra Rockhole meteorite was discovered in Australia. Credit: Imperial College London

A new analysis of a meteorite called Bunburra Rockhole has revealed that the rock originated from a previously unknown parent asteroid, allowing scientists to understand the geology of the parent body.

The parent was differentiated, meaning that it was large enough to separate into a core, mantle and crust, and was roughly spherical in shape, though not as large as a planet. Identifying a new differentiated asteroid is vital for understanding the formation of asteroids and planets in the solar system. Most of the large asteroids in the Asteroid Belt are already known, so this means that either the originated on an asteroid that has been eroded, or there is another large asteroid out there.

Bunburra Rockhole was the first meteorite to be recovered using the Desert Fireball Network, a network of cameras across Australia that observe where meteoroids enter the atmosphere. These cameras make it possible to determine the orbit of a meteorite prior to its descent to Earth. Models of the orbit of Bunburra Rockhole placed its origin within the innermost, main , interior to Vesta, the second-largest body in the Asteroid Belt between Mars and Jupiter.

The oxygen isotopes of a meteorite can act as a fingerprint to identify the parent body it originated from. The group of meteorites known as HED (howardite, eucrite, and diogenite) are thought to emanate from Vesta, as their oxygen isotope signatures are the same. Bunburra Rockhole was originally classed as a eucrite, however its oxygen is very different from that of the other HEDs.

In a new study, astro-geologist Gretchen Benedix of Curtin University in Australia and colleagues, performed a more detailed analysis of the meteorite. The paper, "Bunburra Rockhole: Exploring the geology of a new differentiated asteroid," was recently published in the journal Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. The research was funded by the NASA Emerging Worlds and Cosmochemistry programs. Some of the international consortium were also funded by the Australian Research Council (ARC) and some European grants.

Meteorite’s origins point to possible undiscovered asteroid
When an asteroid or a protoplanet accretes enough material, it will start to become roughly spherical in shape. The heaviest material will sink into the core, and the body will be become split up into the core, mantle, and crust. This process is known as differentiation. Credit: Smithsonian Museum of Natural History

"The initial data were collected on one piece, which gave intriguing results, thus, we examined several different pieces to make sure that the original piece wasn't an anomaly," said Benedix.

Their results revealed that all of the different pieces also have anomalous oxygen compositions, showing that the initial analysis on a single piece was correct. The composition measured does not equate to that seen in meteorites from Vesta.

Even though the oxygen composition is different to that of Vesta, the bulk composition of Bunburra Rockhole is remarkably similar, raising even more questions about the meteorite's origin.

Three scenarios were proposed by the scientists in order to attempt to explain the anomalies of this meteorite. The first was that the rock had been contaminated by other material, the second that it originated from a previously un-sampled part of Vesta, and the third that its parent body is an undiscovered differentiated asteroid.

If contamination had occurred, an estimated 10 percent of the material in the meteorite would have to be contaminants in order to explain the anomalous oxygen, and this is something that would have been obvious in computer tomography scans (CT scans) due to the density differences between materials. In addition, fragments of the contaminant should also have been present, and yet none were seen. This evidence was used to rule out the contamination theory.

The main Asteroid Belt, where Vesta resides, is located between Mars and Jupiter. Credit: Lunar and Planetary Institute/NASA

If the meteorite came from an un-sampled part of Vesta, it would imply that Vesta is heterogeneous, meaning the composition varies across the asteroid. However, there is no evidence, based on the HED meteorites, to suggest that Vesta is heterogeneous as all have the same oxygen isotope composition. This means that the oxygen composition was homogenous across Vesta prior to the formation of the basalt that the eucrites come from. Therefore, Vesta cannot be the parent body of Bunburra Rockhole.

This leaves standing the theory that a previously undiscovered, differentiated asteroid is the most likely origin of Bunburra Rockhole.

"The bulk chemical composition of a meteorite tells a lot about how much thermal or aqueous alteration it has experienced," explained Benedix. "This is because heat and water tend to move different elements around at different rates. So if a body has been differentiated, like Earth, it will separate into a metal rich core, a dense mineral rich mantle and a light mineral rich crust because of the elements that make up those minerals."

Bunburra Rockhole is a basalt meteorite, which indicates that melting occurred in the parent body as the layers became separated and the asteroid differentiated. If the parent body hadn't differentiated, then more metals would have been present.

As the bulk composition of Bunburra Rockhole and Vesta are similar, it is likely that the Bunburra Rockhole's parent body and Vesta formed within a similar part of the solar system. However, it is currently impossible to pinpoint which asteroid Bunburra Rockhole originated from.

The Bunburra Rockhole meteorite most likely originated from an asteroid slightly smaller than Vesta. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UCAL/MPS/DLR/IDA

"All the larger asteroids in the belt and in near Earth space are classified," explained Benedix. "So either there is another big asteroid that we haven't found yet or the asteroid that Bunburra Rockhole originated from has evolved over time through space weathering and impact processing."

The parent asteroid would have been a similar size to Vesta, although slightly smaller. Rare earth elements and bulk major elements in the meteorite show similar levels of partial melting, as Vesta does, but the variations in the oxygen isotopes in the meteorite are consistent with quicker cooling than Vesta, indicating a body around 100 kilometers smaller.

Interestingly, another strange meteorite, called Asuka 881394, has similar and chromium isotope abundances to Bunburra Rockhole (though there are enough subtle differences to indicate that it is not the same parent asteroid), which suggests that there could be yet another differentiated body out there that would have formed around the same time and in the same region as the Bunburra Rockhole parent. Analyzing Asuka will be a future project for the team of scientists.

Explore further: Nullarbor meteorite likely fragment of unknown asteroid

Related Stories

Meteorite just one piece of an unknown celestial body

December 15, 2010

( -- Scientists from all over the world are taking a second, more expansive, look at the car-sized asteroid that exploded over Sudan's Nubian Desert in 2008. Initial research was focused on classifying the meteorite ...

Opal discovered in Antarctic meteorite

June 28, 2016

Planetary scientists have discovered pieces of opal in a meteorite found in Antarctica, a result that demonstrates that meteorites delivered water ice to asteroids early in the history of the solar system. Led by Professor ...

Recommended for you

Astronaut and moonwalker Alan Bean dies at 86

May 26, 2018

Former Apollo 12 astronaut Alan Bean, who was the fourth man to walk on the moon and later turned to painting to chronicle the moon landings on canvas, has died. He was 86.

APEX takes a glimpse into the heart of darkness

May 25, 2018

The 12 m radio telescope APEX in Chile has been outfitted with special equipment including broad bandwidth recorders and a stable hydrogen maser clock for performing joint interferometric observations with other telescopes ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Nov 16, 2017
Not being conversant in orbital dynamics (or Kerbal Space Program), is it possible that this is from an interstellar visitor that collided with something in our solar system, broke a couple of chunks off, and then continued on its way?
1 / 5 (2) Nov 16, 2017
C, improbably possible that the remnants tested are debris from an interstellar rock. However, until a confirmed suprasolar traveler can be sampled, there is no way (I know of) to prove or disapprove such speculation.

In addition, the accumulating evidence seems to confirm that the first batch of Banburra pieces and the Asurka meteorite all share similar metallic composition to Vesta. Except for the oxygen isotopes. Simplest explanation, these meteorites got knocked off smaller asteroids that formed in a general range of Vesta.

At the extreme speed an interstellar rock would have to be traveling at to pass close to this system, then through and escape away?

If it ran into any of this system's flotsam? Hard enough to leave debris behind? I would think that the specimens found would be showing excessive heat and shock damage.
5 / 5 (1) Nov 18, 2017
THAT is a very pretty stone with a very cool name.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.