Searching for the roots

September 7, 2017, Kiel University
Dr. Giddy Landan, Fernando Tria und Prof. Tal Dagan (left to right) visualize the rooting of an evolutionary tree. Credit: Ryszard Soluch

What are the closest relatives of humans? What is the common origin of multicellular life? What is the source of disease-causing germs that can lead to devastating epidemics? Since the beginnings of modern research into evolution, questions as to the origin of organisms and their ancestor–descendent relationships have played a central role in the field of biology. However, most methods of analysis used have not been developed further for decades - unlike, for example, the genetic and molecular investigation techniques, which have been refined on an ongoing basis. The Genomic Microbiology working group at the Institute of General Microbiology at Kiel University (CAU) has now developed a new procedure which could revolutionise evolutionary biological research, and answer key questions in the history of how life developed. The CAU researchers Fernando Tria and Dr. Giddy Landan describe their universally-applicable bioinformatic method for the analysis of evolutionary lineage and ancestor–descendent relationships in the scientific journal Nature Ecology and Evolution.

The scientists, led by Professor Tal Dagan, member of the evolutionary biological research centre "Kiel Evolution Center" (KEC) at Kiel University, have named their newly-developed method "Minimal Ancestor Deviation" (MAD). Using various evolutionary data, and without assumptions about the relationships of the organisms involved, it is able to accurately determine their common evolutionary . With comparatively little effort, MAD achieved unprecedented precision: using this method, the evolutionary origin of a set of organisms could be determined with over 70 percent accuracy. "Our process is based on a mathematical approach that can compensate for specific interference factors, which have previously caused significant imprecision in the investigation of evolutionary roots," explained Fernando Tria, first author of the study and doctoral researcher in the Genomic Microbiology working group at the CAU.

Existing rooting methods were always hampered by various fundamental problems: for example, some approaches used were based on the assumption that evolution takes place at regular intervals - i.e. that the time period between each developmental step always remains the same. The more the actual evolutionary development rate differed from this theoretical expectation, the more inaccurate were the reconstructions - to date. On the other hand, other approaches require prior knowledge about the ancestor–descendant relationships of the studied organisms, which is not always available.

Here, the Kiel researchers suggest a new approach: the MAD method aims to determine the common ancestor from which all the organisms descend, in trees with unknown roots. To achieve this, MAD analyses the length of the branches in the tree; the distance between two organisms provides insight into their relationship. The closer together they are, the more closely related they tend to be. From the analysis of all pairs of organisms included in the tree, MAD can then determine the location of the common ancestor. The analysis of pairs of organisms is the key to bypass the known interference factors - and in so doing it achieves unprecedented precision.

In order to verify this accuracy, the Kiel research team led by Dagan tested the MAD method on evolutionary trees that have already been studied in detail, in which the respective original is regarded as proven. To do this, they used around 1,500 example trees, which they had reconstructed from the protein sequences of 31 different . In comparison with the two most commonly-used reconstruction procedures, MAD provided the best results by far, with an accuracy of over 70 percent. "Our highly-precise has the potential to definitively answer the long-discussed theories in the field of evolutionary biology - the key questions of origin in the development of life," said group leader Tal Dagan optimistically. In the future, the Kiel research team could, for example, contribute to resolving the controversial origin of . "What is also fascinating is that our procedure is actually universally applicable. From the origin and development of languages to the evolution of pathogens, we can reconstruct completely different types of origin stories," continued Dagan.

Explore further: Researchers discover evolutionary origin of redox regulation in plants

More information: Fernando Domingues Kümmel Tria et al. Phylogenetic rooting using minimal ancestor deviation, Nature Ecology & Evolution (2017). DOI: 10.1038/s41559-017-0193

Related Stories

Parasite revealed—new insights into dicyemida

July 18, 2017

Revealing the origin and evolutionary history of the world's manifold life forms is one way in which we seek to understand them. Even the smallest creature can yield fascinating insights. For example, take the Dicyemida, ...

A short jump from single-celled ancestors to animals

October 13, 2016

The first animals evolved from their single-celled ancestors around 800 million years ago, but new evidence suggests that this leap to multi-celled organisms in the tree of life may not have been quite as dramatic as scientists ...

New insights into the ancestors of all complex life

May 26, 2017

A team of scientists led by the University of Bristol has provided new insights into the origins of the Archaea, the group of simple cellular organisms that are the ancestors of all complex life.

Recommended for you

Humans account for little next to plants, worms, bugs

May 21, 2018

When you weigh all life on Earth, billions of humans don't amount to much compared to trees, earthworms or even viruses. But we really know how to throw what little weight we have around, according to a first-of-its-kind ...

How animals holler

May 21, 2018

While humans can only broadcast about one percent of their vocal power through their speech, some animals and mammals are able to broadcast 100 percent. The secret to their long-range howls? A combination of high pitch, a ...

Profiling the genome hundreds of variations at a time

May 21, 2018

Geneticists have been using model organisms ranging from the house mouse to the single-cell bakers' yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, to study basic biological processes that regulate human development and physiology, and ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.