Determining whether climate change made Hurricane Harvey worse

September 4, 2017 by Sarah Fecht, Earth Institute, Columbia University, Earth Institute, Columbia University
Determining whether climate change made Hurricane Harvey worse
Temperature departure from average for Dec. 25, 2015. Note the swath of red colors across the eastern U.S. indicating much warmer than average temperatures. Credit: Climate Change Institute.

After rapidly scaling up in strength, Hurricane Harvey has dumped an 'unprecedented' amount of rainfall onto Houston, Texas. Lives have been lost, homes flooded, and officials estimate the damages may make this one of the costliest natural disasters in U.S. history.

But inevitably, Americans want to know just how 'natural' this disaster really was, and what role change may have played.

Climate scientists are fairly certain that climate change will, on average, make hurricanes stronger. "We know the atmosphere is getting warmer, and the oceans are getting warmer," explains Chia-Ying Lee, who studies tropical cyclones at Columbia's International Research Institute for Climate and Society.

Hurricanes are driven by ocean heat, and some scientists have pointed out that the Gulf of Mexico was warmer than average this year. Hurricane Harvey rapidly transformed from a tropical to a Category 4 behemoth as it sucked energy off those particularly warm waters. Making matters worse, warmer air is able to hold more water, and more water vapor can lead to more rain, so scientists expect that a warming world will have more heavy downpours.

For now, that's about all that anyone can say with much certainty. It sure seems as if climate change contributed to Hurricane Harvey, but it's not certain yet, and if it did, scientists would want to know by how much? "It's just very hard to say much without more study," says Lee.

Climate scientists will never be able to say that climate change "caused" a particular extreme weather event. A popular analogy is a baseball player on steroids: we know doping makes the player stronger, but we can't say for sure whether any particular home run was the result of the steroids. What climate scientists can do is calculate the likelihood that climate change made an extreme weather event stronger.

So how are those studies done?

Weather is constantly fluctuating, influenced by a variety of factors, and this can create a lot of noise in the data that climate scientists work with. But by carefully analyzing the statistics, they can start to pull out trends that can't be explained by regular day-to-day weather changes.

Climate scientists have a few ways of determining whether Harvey bears the fingerprints of climate change. One way is to ask what would happen if this particular event had occurred in a climate without human-induced warming, says Lee. For that, investigators use regional models to simulate the storm (or other extreme weather event). By plugging in different climate conditions, they can see how the storm behaves both with and without climate change. Comparing the two scenarios shows just how much climate change impacted the storm. If there's no difference, then probably climate change didn't play a major role. However, if the storm is stronger under the conditions of climate change, then scientists can estimate that today's warmer climate strengthened the storm by some particular percentage. Or they can estimate how the storm would behave in 2100, when the world is expected to have heated up by another two to six degrees Celsius.

These simulations, of course, depend on the accuracy of the models, so in general it's best to run them on multiple climate models, which can take time. And hurricanes can be particularly difficult to study in this regard, because they're relatively short-lived. Still, Lee estimates that within a year or less, scientists will have a clearer idea of how much climate change contributed to some of Harvey's behavior.

"In the case of Harvey, as with other specific events, now have the capability to perform attribution studies which make more quantitative statements about how influenced that event," Suzana Camargo and Adam Sobel from Columbia's Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory wrote in a Fortune op-ed this week. And although it's reasonable to expect those studies will find that amplified Harvey's rainfall by a modest amount, they write, "We should not make detailed statements presupposing their outcomes before those studies are done."

Explore further: Scientists say Harvey may be the soggy sign of future storms

Related Stories

Scientists say Harvey may be the soggy sign of future storms

August 29, 2017

By the time the rain stops, Harvey will have dumped about 1 million gallons of water for every man, woman and child in southeastern Texas—a soggy, record-breaking glimpse of the wet and wild future that global warming could ...

Is Hurricane Harvey a harbinger for Houston's future?

August 28, 2017

Over the past week we have seen two major tropical storms devastate different parts of the world. First Typhoon Hato struck Hong Kong and Southern China killing at least a dozen people. And over the weekend Hurricane Harvey ...

Hurricanes and typhoons: cyclones by another name

August 25, 2017

No matter what they are called—cyclones, hurricanes or typhoons—the giant tropical storms that form in oceans near the Americas and Asia can be deadly, destructive and terrifyingly capricious.

Video: How will climate change impact shelter?

August 15, 2017

Around the globe, extreme events such as floods, droughts, hurricanes, tornadoes, and heat waves increasingly result in forced migration and loss of life, property, and security. Hot days are becoming hotter and more frequent, ...

Recommended for you

Death near the shoreline, not life on land

December 13, 2018

Our understanding of when the very first animals started living on land is helped by identifying trace fossils—the tracks and trails left by ancient animals—in sedimentary rocks that were deposited on the continents.

The long dry: global water supplies are shrinking

December 13, 2018

A global study has found a paradox: our water supplies are shrinking at the same time as climate change is generating more intense rain. And the culprit is the drying of soils, say researchers, pointing to a world where drought-like ...

New climate model to be built from the ground up

December 13, 2018

Facing the certainty of a changing climate coupled with the uncertainty that remains in predictions of how it will change, scientists and engineers from across the country are teaming up to build a new type of climate model ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.