New analysis shows damage to monarch butterfly colonies in 2016 storm worse than thought

September 15, 2017, Entomological Society of America
A tangle of downed Oyamel first shows the damage sustained in the Sierra Chincua overwintering area of the monarch butterfly in Mexico during a severe winter storm in March 2016. New analysis estimates 30-38 percent of the monarch butterflies there at the time perished in the storm. Credit: David Kust/Entomological Society of America

A much greater number of monarch butterflies perished in a snowstorm in March 2016 in Mexico than previously estimated, according to new research. Analysis of damage from the storm—and the ensuing salvage logging—sheds further light on the precarious state of the famed butterflies' overwintering colonies.

Approximately 30-38 percent of the (Danaus plexippus) in the Sierra Chincua and Cerro Pelón overwintering colonies died in the storm, says a team led by Lincoln Brower, Ph.D., research professor of biology at Sweet Briar College, far more than the estimated 7 percent mortality rate cited in initial media reports after the storm that struck between March 7 and March 11, 2016. The researchers' findings are reported in the latest issue of the Entomological Society of America's American Entomologist.

The storm was a severe combination of rain, snow, sleet, and hail along with strong winds and sub-freezing temperatures that downed several thousand Oyamel firs within the forests of the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve, declared a World Heritage Site by the United Nations in 2008. Typically, the dense forest creates a favorable "microclimate" for the monarchs, protecting them from exposure to intense winds, rain, and cold temperatures.

"The prolonged severe storm destroyed the normal microclimatic protection provided by the intact Oyamel forest and led to freezing in all the colonies," Brower says. "This awakened us to the realization that the forest surrounding the butterfly colonies also needs to be protected, as a generalized wind buffer."

A severe winter storm that hit the overwintering areas of the monarch butterfly in Mexico in March 2016 has been estimated to have killed 30-38 percent of the butterflies present at the time. Here, dead butterflies can be seen amid storm debris in a photo taken two weeks after the storm. Credit: David Kust/Entomological Society of America

Brower and colleagues counted dead butterflies in random plots within the colonies to estimate the total mortality rate from the storm: 31 percent in the Sierra Chincua and 38 percent in the Cerro Pelón colony. The true impact may still have been greater, however, as the researchers' analysis of weather data from stations within and surrounding the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve, measured against existing research on monarch butterfly mortality in freezing temperatures, "support the conclusion that the March 2016 storm mortality ... was substantially greater than 40 percent," the researchers report.

Following the , the Mexican government permitted salvage logging to remove downed trees, due to concerns over potential fire or insect damage. Brower and colleagues argue, however, that the logging process was "profoundly disturbing and detrimental to the environment," decreasing the forest's ability to return to maturity and provide safe haven for the butterflies. A volume of 60,000 cubic meters of timber was approved for removal—equivalent to several thousand trees—which follows an incident of illegal logging occurring in the monarch reserve in 2015, reported in American Entomologist last year.

Brower was recently named a Fellow of the Entomological Society of America, in recognition of his career devoted to studying and raising awareness of the monarch butterfly and its overwintering colonies. Since the 1996-1997 overwintering season, the monarchs' colonies have declined in size by 90 percent. After more than 60 years, Brower's work carries on, he says. "We hope to carry out a drone study, photographing the colonies from a standard height above the butterflies and then using photometric analysis to estimate changing colony densities," he says. "We are concerned that the current methodology of reporting only total colony areas is underestimating the decline of monarchs overwintering in Mexico."

"Butterfly Mortality and Salvage Logging from the March 2016 Storm in the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve in Mexico" will be published online on September 15 in American Entomologist.

Explore further: Monarch butterfly numbers drop by 27 percent in Mexico

More information: Lincoln P Brower et al, Butterfly Mortality and Salvage Logging from the March 2016 Storm in the Monarch Butterfly Biosphere Reserve in Mexico, American Entomologist (2017). DOI: 10.1093/ae/tmx052

Related Stories

Monarch butterfly numbers drop by 27 percent in Mexico

February 9, 2017

The number of monarch butterflies wintering in Mexico dropped by 27 percent this year, reversing last year's recovery from historically low numbers, according to a study by government and independent experts released Thursday.

Monarch butterflies disappearing from western North America

September 7, 2017

Monarch butterfly populations from western North America have declined far more dramatically than was previously known and face a greater risk of extinction than eastern monarchs, according to a new study in the journal Biological ...

Recommended for you

Study shows city rats eat better than country rats

October 17, 2018

A pair of researchers, one with Trent University in Canada, the other the University of Manchester in the U.K. has found evidence that rats living in cities have a much richer diet than rats living in the country. In their ...

A curious branch of plankton evolution

October 17, 2018

Planktonic foraminifera (forams) - tiny, shelled organisms that float in the sea—left behind one of the most complete fossil records of evolutionary history in deep sea deposits. Consequently, evolutionists have a relatively ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.