Study reveals two seismic processes by which hydraulic fracturing induces tremors

November 18, 2016
The researchers' image of seismic activity reveals a pre-existing but previously undetected fault system running parallel to two horizontally drilled wells. In one strand of the fault, hydraulic fracturing in both wells triggered small earthquakes by imposing mechanical stresses on the rock formations beneath the hydrocarbons-bearing zone — causing the fault to slip. However, in another strand of the fault — and more than two weeks after hydraulic fracturing injections had stopped — the magnitude 3.9 earthquake occurred at a calculated depth of just over four kilometres. This places the event within the upper levels of Precambrian basement rocks. Subsequent smaller seismic events persisted for a few months afterward, as the seismic activity migrated slowly from the basement back up toward the injection zone.  Credit: University of Calgary

In some parts of western Canada, small-to-moderate earthquakes have been induced by oil and gas hydraulic fracturing operations. In Alberta, this type of induced seismicity is mainly concentrated within an area located about 30 kilometres west of the town of Fox Creek. 

Although a correlation between hydraulic fracturing and has been documented for over four years, a detailed mechanism has not been clearly understood — until now.

Indirect evidence has pointed to activation of pre-existing faults as the underlying physical mechanism, but precise delineation of these features has been elusive. Without this deeper understanding, formulation of strong mitigation and prevention strategies has been a challenge for regulators and operating companies alike. 

Now, a new University of Calgary study, "Fault Activation by Hydraulic Fracturing in Western Canada," is reported in Science, one of the world's leading academic journals. In the most detailed study of this phenomenon to date, Faculty of Science researchers in the Department of Geoscience have successfully imaged some of the pre-existing fault architecture near hydraulic fracturing operations and discovered that activation can occur through two distinct processes.

"This study has provided extraordinary new details about processes of fault activation by pore pressure increase or stress changes. We can now begin to address important questions — the 'how' and 'why' of seismicity induced by hydraulic fracturing — that previously were not discernible," says David Eaton, professor of geophysics and co-author of the study, with former postdoctoral scholar Xuewei Bao. 

The research holds promise for establishing new ways to assess risk and mitigate the hazards of earthquakes induced by hydraulic fracturing, and to help in developing science-informed regulations for such operations.

'Exquisitely detailed' picture

Eaton and Bao collected and analyzed seismic data going back to the winter of 2015, when the first seismic event exceeding magnitude 4 on the Richter scale, occurred in the Fox Creek area. They compiled data from private and public seismograph stations in the area, monitors they installed after the earthquake, and also a comprehensive database of hydraulic fracturing data from each well in the area.

Using state-of-the-art techniques, Bao and Eaton created a database of 905 distinct events, most of which were too small to be part of existing seismicity catalogues. They were able to link seismic events to specific operations at individual wells, thanks to Repsol Oil and Gas Canada Inc. and Canadian Discovery Ltd., which provided data for the study. This university-industry partnership is crucial for researchers to gain access to data and to understand the fundamental processes.

Credit: University of Calgary

"The combination of precise micro-earthquake locations and uniquely comprehensive data gave us an exquisitely detailed picture of the timing and dynamics of rupture nucleation," Eaton says.

Bao, who did the "painstakingly detailed" data analysis, has since joined the faculty at Zhejiang University in China.

Two distinct seismic processes revealed

Their image of reveals a pre-existing but previously undetected fault system running parallel to two horizontally drilled wells. In one strand of the fault, hydraulic fracturing in both wells triggered small earthquakes by imposing mechanical stresses on the rock formations beneath the hydrocarbons-bearing zone — causing the fault to slip.

In this case, movement on the fault effectively terminated when hydraulic fracturing operations ceased, consistent with existing regulatory protocols to halt operations under certain conditions, Eaton notes. 

Study reveals two processes by which hydraulic fracturing induces tremors
Former University of Calgary postdoctoral scholar Xuewei Bao, co-author of the study, did the “painstakingly detailed” data analysis that provided an exquisitely detailed picture of the timing and dynamics of rupture nucleation. Credit: University of Calgary

However, in another strand of the fault — and more than two weeks after injections had stopped — the magnitude 3.9 earthquake occurred at a calculated depth of just over four kilometres. This places the event within the upper levels of Precambrian basement rocks. Subsequent smaller seismic events persisted for a few months afterward, as the seismic activity migrated slowly from the basement back up toward the injection zone. 

The researchers' findings indicate that this persistent activity appears to be associated with infiltration of fracturing fluids into one strand of the

Distinction between stress-induced and fluid-induced seismicity

"We didn't expect to observe contrasting signatures for stress-induced and fluid-induced seismicity," Eaton says. "This distinction may have important ramifications for hazard mitigation, depending on which process is inducing seismic activity."

Explore further: Fracking—not wastewater disposal—linked to most induced earthquakes in Western Canada

More information: X. Bao et al. Fault activation by hydraulic fracturing in western Canada, Science (2016). DOI: 10.1126/science.aag2583

Related Stories

Hydraulic fracturing linked to earthquakes in Ohio

October 14, 2014

Hydraulic fracturing triggered a series of small earthquakes in 2013 on a previously unmapped fault in Harrison County, Ohio, according to a study published in the journal Seismological Research Letters.

Fracking risks, fact or fiction?

February 17, 2012

A Simon Fraser University researcher known for his expertise on naturally occurring hazards will participate Friday in a shake down of the truth about a new form of human-induced earthquakes.

Recommended for you

New research could predict La Nina drought years in advance

November 16, 2017

Two new studies from The University of Texas at Austin have significantly improved scientists' ability to predict the strength and duration of droughts caused by La Niña - a recurrent cooling pattern in the tropical Pacific ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Anonym
1 / 5 (1) Nov 19, 2016
Could use some context here. There are an estimated 30,000 sub-5 earthquakes per year. How many are attributed to fracking? How much damage was caused? Most importantly, how did the data link the tremors that occurred miles beneath and weeks later to fracking that had already ended? The scientists seem to be claiming that the fracking fluid migrated down a couple of miles where it "lubed" the fault, causing slippage, then migrated back toward the surface, causing "micro-earthquakes" --- an oxymoron, btw. They cite a correlation, but seem to claim causation without having the long-term data on local seismic events to support causation. I am reminded of the '80s asbestos scare (when new hi-res tools showed school kids were inhaling asbestos, a then "known" carcinogen: billions were spent remediating schools, only then to discover
that the air outside had even higher asbestos levels than that inside --- no one had thought to look at that --- except in the newly remediated schools).
TheGhostofOtto1923
3 / 5 (2) Nov 20, 2016
Could use some context here. There are an estimated 30,000 sub-5 earthquakes per year. How many are attributed to fracking?
In Oklahoma, all of them.
https://earthquak...Anull%7D

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.