Huddled mice could change the way we think about evolution

November 16, 2016 by Stuart P Wilson And James V Stone, The Conversation
Credit: Pixabay

Adapt or die. That's the reality for an animal species when it is faced with a harsh environment. Until now, many scientists have assumed that the more challenging an animal's environment, the greater the pressure to adapt and the faster its genes evolve. But we have just published new research in Royal Society Open Science that shows that genes might actually evolve faster when the pressure to adapt is reduced.

We built a simple computer model of how evolution may be affected by the way interact with each other when they're in groups. Specifically, we looked at what happens to animals that huddle together to keep warm.

We found that when animals huddle in larger groups, their for regulating temperature evolve faster, even though there is less pressure to adapt to the cold because of the warmth of the huddle. This shows that an organism's evolution doesn't just depend on its environment but also on how it behaves.

When animals such as rats and mice huddle together in groups, they can maintain a high body temperature without using as much energy as they would on their own. We wanted to understand how this kind of group behaviour would affect a species' evolution.

To do this, we built a computer model simulating how the species' genes changed and were passed on over multiple generations. When the effects of huddling were built into the , the reduced pressure to adapt was actually found to accelerate evolution of the genes controlling heat production and heat loss.

Why was this? Well, when there's less pressure to evolve, the genes are freer to experiment. When two related genes (or sets of genes) are well adapted to the environment, mutation of one gene may have catastrophic consequences for the species unless the other gene mutates at the same time in a complementary way.

For example, newborn babies' head size and female pelvic size depend on each other. If head sizes get bigger then so should pelvic sizes. If genetic pairs do not change simultaneously then evolution can get stuck, unable to fully explore the space of possible combinations of genes and so unable to discover better adaptations to the environment.

Pressure to evolve. Credit: Shutterstock

But when selection pressure on a gene is relaxed, the consequence of a mutation in that gene is not catastrophic for the species. This makes it possible for evolution to explore new combinations of genes that might eventually lead to fitter organisms. And huddling is a great example of how selection pressure can be relaxed.

Mutations that cause animals to generate too much or too little heat can be tolerated because the animals can simply huddle a bit more or less to adjust. So, according to our model, huddling allows evolution to explore the space of possible genes more freely to find the best combination.


This result is particularly interesting for two reasons. First, it shows that behavioural adaptations that happen within the lifetime of an animal, such as huddling, could alter the course of evolution. This is not obvious given that the genetic information we possess essentially remains fixed throughout our lifetimes.

Second, because huddling is an example of self-organising behaviour among a group of animals, our results suggest that this example may be ideal for exploring how self-organisation affects evolution more generally. Self-organisation describes how a collection of simple entities (like a group of cold rats) can create something more complex (like a huddle) without any instruction. Like , self-organisation shapes everything in the natural world, from the formation of snowflakes to the translation of genetic code into bodies and brains.

Certain aspects of self-organisation are reasonably well understood, but how self-organisation interacts with natural selection is not one of them. So understanding how huddling affects the of temperature regulation might help shed light on one of the most fundamental questions in biology: how do self-organisation and natural selection interact to shape the ?

Explore further: Huddling rats behave as a 'super-organism'

More information: Royal Society Open Science, rsos.royalsocietypublishing.or … /10.1098/rsos.160553

Related Stories

Huddling rats behave as a 'super-organism'

September 3, 2015

Rodents huddle together when it is cold, they separate when it is warm, and at moderate temperatures they cycle between the warm center and the cold edges of the group. In a new study published in PLOS Computational Biology, ...

Feral chickens spread light on evolution

September 30, 2016

Different genes are involved during the adaptation of a domestic animal to life in the wild than when a wild animal becomes domesticated. This is the conclusion of a study led by a researcher at Linköping University in Sweden ...

In the firefly's flash, seeking new insights on evolution

July 13, 2016

From loud calls to flashing lights, animals use a wide array of signals to attract mates. Although these signals play a very important role in whether the organisms will mate and reproduce, scientists don't fully understand ...

Penguin huddling found to be more complicated than thought

December 9, 2015

(—A team of researchers from several institutions in France and one in Germany has found that emperor penguin huddles are more complicated than has been thought by many in the science community. In their paper ...

Recommended for you

These shrews have heads that shrink with the season

October 23, 2017

If any part of the body would seem ill equipped to shrink, it would probably be the head and skull. And, yet, researchers reporting in Current Biology on October 23 have found that the skulls of red-toothed shrews do shrink ...

Single-molecule dissection of developmental gene control

October 23, 2017

Scientists at EPFL and Max Plank have made significant discoveries on how developmental genes are controlled by the methyltransferase enzyme PRC2. The study is published in Nature Structural & Molecular Biology.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Nov 16, 2016
We would expect speciation to occur in times of abundance when even the least viable variations are able to survive, that is, the bridging species (partially adapted to an alternative environment or life style). When conditions become harsher, the between variations disappear leaving speciation (or varieties of the same species).

That's how I always thought it was...
5 / 5 (1) Nov 16, 2016
"..when there's less pressure to evolve, the genes are freer to experiment..."

This reminds me of Donald Knuth's statement about software, "Premature optimization is the root of all evil."
not rated yet Nov 20, 2016
We would expect speciation to occur in times of abundance when even the least viable variations are able to survive, that is, the bridging species (partially adapted to an alternative environment or life style).

Speciation is most often just a result of geographical isolation [ https://en.wikipe...eciation ].

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.