Why do consumers pay more? Research finds the surprising effect of consumer local identity

October 25, 2016, Rice University
Credit: shutterstock.com/Rice University

New research by a Rice University marketing professor debunks a long-held belief by companies that they could charge more for locally produced goods and services because of consumers' sense of attachment to their community. The study, published in the Journal of Marketing, determined consumers with a local identity will pay more than consumers with a global identity even when a product's country of origin is unknown.

Rice's Vikas Mittal, the J. Hugh Liedtke Professor of Marketing at the university's Jones Graduate School of Business, examined differences between consumers with a local versus global identity in the study "How Does Local-Global Identity Affect Price Sensitivity?" Those with a local identity view themselves as local citizens identifying with their community, traditions and culture. In contrast, consumers with a global identity view themselves as world citizens and identify with worldwide traditions and cultures.

Along with co-authors Huachao Gao of the University of Victoria and Yinlong Zhang of the University of Texas at San Antonio, Mittal conducted several studies with more than 5,000 customers. In these studies, they used different approaches to measure and experimentally manipulate consumers' local or global identity. They also measured using different metrics, such as purchase quantity, willingness to pay and purchase likelihood.

"On average, we found a 17.38 percent decline in price sensitivity among local than global consumers" Mittal said. "Interestingly, the results persisted when we did not mention where the products were produced."

The most powerful evidence came from a randomized field study in a grocery store in Hefei, China. As customers entered the store, half randomly received a local-identity brochure that described a "Think Local Movement" supporting the local community and focusing on local news. The other half received a "Think Global Movement" brochure supporting the global community, focusing on global news and highlighting global cultures.

Results of this study showed that overall sales could be boosted by 13 percent from applying a local communication strategy. A follow-up study determined this occurred because local-identity customers were more prone to making sacrifices. To the extent that paying more is akin to a sacrifice, they displayed lower price sensitivity.

The authors also analyzed a country-level dataset spanning 142 countries. Controlling for factors such as country culture, per capita income and competitiveness, the authors found that the less globalized a country—or the higher its local identity—the less price-sensitive its citizens were to food prices.

"Why does this happen?" Mittal asked. "A local identity seems to trigger a sacrifice mindset that increases a consumer's willingness to pay. By triggering this sacrifice mindset via a local identity, a company can improve its revenue without having to offer more features or product modifications."

The authors also tested whether this effect of localism on price sensitivity was robust to consumer ethnocentrism, a tendency to pay more for local products out of a sense of patriotism. "Reassuringly, we found that local identity reduces price sensitivity for products whose country of origin is unknown—even after controlling for ethnocentrism," Mittal said.

As the studies show, a local identity can be activated in simple, inexpensive yet effective ways. These include messages that remind consumers of their local roots, simple activities that trigger local associations and measurements of trait identity. A communication-based approach to appeal to consumers' local identity is likely to use fewer resources while being more effective than altering a company's supply chain to set up local manufacturing in host countries.

Does this imply that global companies can drive out local competition? Not necessarily, Mittal said. "First, if low-cost global companies can reduce consumer price sensitivity, local producers and manufacturers do not have to lower their prices to be competitive; the latter can compete better by differentiating on factors other than price," he said. "Second, companies can further reinforce their customers' local identity and desire to pay more by being good citizens of local communities. These include supporting local causes that are endemic to consumers with a local identity."

Explore further: National identity: Does buying local mean shunning global?

More information: Huachao Gao et al. How Does Local-Global Identity Affect Price Sensitivity?, Journal of Marketing (2016). DOI: 10.1509/jm.15.0206

Related Stories

National identity: Does buying local mean shunning global?

June 23, 2015

U.S. consumers are often urged to "buy American," and some special interest groups even claim that buying foreign products is inappropriate, or even immoral. But when it comes to buying domestic products, positive feelings ...

Thinking globally linked to optimism

October 3, 2016

As the world becomes increasingly global, people often respond one of two ways: They start to consider themselves part of the larger global community, or they strengthen their association with their smaller national or local ...

Recommended for you

Solving the mystery of an unusual medieval text

July 20, 2018

When historian Rowan Dorin first stepped onto the Stanford campus in early 2017, he made it a habit to visit Green Library every week to dig through its collection of medieval documents and objects.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Oct 25, 2016
if you don't support your 'neighbours' jobs can you expect them to support yours?
Besides, how much slave labour do you want in your clothes, and petrol miles on your plate?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.