Seismometers are giving scientists a clearer look at a giant scar under the American Midwest

September 27, 2016 by Diana Lutz
Most of the gravity highs on this map (hot colors for high; cool ones for low) correspond with mountains or other topographical features. But the long snake-like gravity high heading south from the tip of Lake Superior is another story. There's nothing on the surface to explain its buried presence. Credit: USGS

When Doug Wiens approached Minnesota farmers to ask permission to install a seismometer on their land, he often got a puzzled look. "You could tell they were thinking 'Why are you putting a seismometer here?,' " said Wiens, professor of earth and planetary sciences in Arts & Sciences at Washington University in St. Louis. "'We don't have earthquakes and we don't have volcanoes. Do you know something we don't?' "

Actually, he did. Deep beneath the fertile flat farmland, there is a huge scar in the Earth called the Midcontinent Rift. This ancient and hidden feature bears silent witness to a time when the core of what would become North America nearly ripped apart. If the U-shaped rip had gone to completion, the land between its arms—including at least half of what is now called the Midwest—would have pulled away from North America, leaving a great ocean behind.

Weisen Shen, a postdoctoral research associate with Wiens, will be presenting seismic images of the rift at the annual meeting of the Geological Society of America (GSA) Sept. 25-28. The images were made by analyzing data from Earthscope, a National Science Foundation (NSF) program that deployed thousands of seismic instruments across America in the past 10 years.

What is that thing?

The Midcontinent Rift was discovered by geophysicists who noticed that gravity was stronger in some parts of the upper Midwest than in others. In the 1950s and 1960s, they mapped the gravity and magnetic anomalies with airborne sensors. Shen is contributing to a session at the GSA dedicated to Bill Heinze, a geophysicist who helped discover and map the Midcontinent Rift.

But understanding of the rift then stalled until 2003, when the NSF funded Earthscope, a program whose mission is to use North America as a natural laboratory to gain insight into how the Earth operates.

The USArray consisted of 400 seismometers that rolled across the United States from 2004 until 2015. The instruments are currently in Alaska. Credit: Washington University in St. Louis

As part of Earthscope, the Incorporated Research Institutions for Seismology (IRIS) installed a network of 400 seismometers, called the USArray, that rolled across the United States from west to east, gathering data at each location for two years before moving on. USArray was installed on the West Coast beginning in 2004, and had advanced to the Midwest by 2010.

Earthscope also made available a pool of seismometers, called the flexible array, for more focused field experiments. A consortium of universities, including Washington University in St. Louis, installed 83 of these stations along and across the rift in 2011, creating a dense array called SPREE.

A telescope looking down

Seismologists had never before been able to blanket the landscape with seismometers in this way, and so the USArray has stimulated many innovations in the manipulation of the seismic data to extract information about Earth's crust and upper mantle.

Seismic interpretation is a thorny version of what is called an inverse problem. If the Earth's interior were of uniform composition, seismic waves would travel in straight lines. But instead, underground structures or differences in temperature and density refract and reflect them. The problem is to figure out mathematically which obstructions could have produced the wave arrivals that the seismometers recorded.

It's a bit like trying to figure out the shape of an island in a pond by throwing a pebble into the lake and recording the ripples arriving at the shore.

The SPREE array. East-west rows cross the rift and north-south ones run along it. Washington University scientists installed the southern part of the array, and scientists from Northwestern University and the University of Minnesota took the northern arm. Credit: Washington University in St. Louis

The data wizard on the Washington University team is Shen, who has devised new techniques for combining many types of seismological data to create sharper images of Earth's interior.

The farmers in Minnesota have a point when they wonder what an "earthquake sensor" could detect in an area where there are no earthquakes. The answer is that the seismometers record distant earthquakes, such as those on the Pacific Ring of Fire on the opposite side of the planet, and ambient noise, caused by activity such as powerful storms slamming into the Jersey Shore.

Shen has seasoned the mix with several other measurements that can be extracted from the seismic record as well. By inverting all of these data functions simultaneously within a Bayesian statistical framework, he is able to obtain much clearer images of Earth's interior than one type of data alone would produce, together with estimates of the probability that the images are correct.

Not just a scar, a keloid scar

What have the scientists learned about the rift?

"When you pull apart a continent, like a piece of taffy, it starts to stretch and to thin," said Michael Wysession, professor of and planetary sciences and a member of the SPREE team. "And as it sags, the dip fills with low-density sediment.

Ghassan Alequabi (left), a seismic installation specialist, and Shawn Wei (right), then a doctoral student, next to a newly installed SPREE seismic station. Digging in seismometers is a lot of hard work, but Alequabi enjoyed talking to the landowners and has many stories to tell about people raising pistachios, alpacas, hogs and Clydsedale horses, besides the more usual crops. Credit: Washington University in St. Louis

"So if you go over a rift with a gravity sensor, you expect to find a negative gravity anomaly. Mass should be missing. But that's not what happened with the Midcontinent Rift. Instead of being thinner than the surrounding crust, it is thicker.

"We know that lava comes out at rifts," Wysession said. "The East African rift zone, for example, includes a number of active and dormant volcanoes, such as Mount Kilimanjaro. But the Midcontinent Rift was flooded with lava, and as it sank under the weight of the cooling basaltic rock, even more lava flowed into the depression.

"A huge volume of lava erupted here," Wysession said. "It was perhaps the largest outflowing of lava in our planet's history. And then, after the eruptions ended, the area was compressed by mountain building event to its east, thickening the scar by squeezing it horizontally.

Shen published images of the rift made with USArray data in the Journal of Geophysical Research 2013. But at that time, he had only sparse coverage in the rift's vicinity. At the 2016 GSA meeting he will present images made with both USArray and SPREE data (especially many more "receiver functions," a type of seismic data that is particularly sensitive to seismic boundaries) that show what lies beneath the rift more clearly.

Miles beneath the Earth's surface, there is a seismic boundary called the Mohorovičić discontinuity, or Moho. At the Moho, seismic waves hit higher density material and suddenly accelerate. But beneath the rift, Shen said, the Moho is blurred rather than sharp. "Its structure has been destroyed," he said.

He also sees evidence of something called magmatic underplating. "We think magma might have trapped, or stalled out, at the Moho or within the crust during its rise to the surface," he said. This might explain why the Moho is so disrupted, although Shen can think of alternative explanations and expects there to be lively discussions at the GSA.

SPREE array stations (red triangles) run along and across the gravity anomaly (blue) that is the rift. These stations are much closer together than the USArray ones (blue triangles). Processing the data, Shen sees a graded rather than a sharp Moho (top right), which he thinks may be due to magma trapped at the Moho or in the crust (bottom right). Credit: Weisen Shen

He compares images of the Midcontinent Rift made with the SPREE array to images of the Rio Grande rift made with a similar seismic array called La Ristra. The La Ristra images show that the Rio Grande rift is thinner than the surrounding crust, not thicker. The Moho is clear and rises rather than sinks under the rift.

"I think we're looking at different stages of rifting," Shen said. The Rio Grande Rift is still active, still opening, but the Midcontinent Rift is already dead and has been squeezed shut.

Wiens commented that the tremendous outpouring of magma at the Midcontinent Rift might also have disrupted its structure, making it look different from other rifts.

"My goal," Shen said, "is to provide basic seismic models of interesting tectonic regions like this one for geologists, geochemists and scientists from other disciplines to use—to help them interpret their results and also help the public to better understand the story of the land they live on."

Rural Minnesota is already onboard. "Some landowners were quite interested in what we were doing," Wiens said. "We got into one or two small town newspapers. 'So-and-so now has a on his farm,' the headline would read."

Explore further: Mysterious Midcontinent Rift is a geological hybrid

More information: Weisen Shen et al. A 3-D model of the crust and uppermost mantle beneath the Central and Western US by joint inversion of receiver functions and surface wave dispersion, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth (2013). DOI: 10.1029/2012JB009602

Related Stories

Mysterious Midcontinent Rift is a geological hybrid

October 16, 2014

An international team of geologists has a new explanation for how the Midwest's biggest geological feature—an ancient and giant 2,000-mile-long underground crack that starts in Lake Superior and runs south to Oklahoma and ...

Solving the Midwest's biggest geologic mystery

March 11, 2014

(Phys.org) —Geologists from Northwestern University, the University of Illinois at Chicago, the University of Oklahoma and Purdue University have a new explanation for the Midwest's biggest geologic mystery: What caused ...

The geography of Antarctica's underside

December 8, 2015

Planetary scientists would be thrilled if they could peel the Earth like an orange and look at what lies beneath the thin crust. We live on the planet's cold surface, but the Earth is a solid body and the surface is continually ...

Off-rift volcanoes explained

March 23, 2014

Volcanoes often develop outside the rift zone in an apparently unexpected location offset by tens of kilometers has remained unanswered. An international team of scientists has shown that the pattern of stresses in the crust ...

Oculus boosts Rift VR gear availability

July 12, 2016

Oculus on Tuesday announced it is ramping up availability of its Rift virtual reality gear and planning a major conference in October for developers making software for it.

Recommended for you

Carbon coating gives biochar its garden-greening power

October 20, 2017

For more than 100 years, biochar, a carbon-rich, charcoal-like substance made from oxygen-deprived plant or other organic matter, has both delighted and puzzled scientists. As a soil additive, biochar can store carbon and ...

Cool roofs have water saving benefits too

October 20, 2017

The energy and climate benefits of cool roofs have been well established: By reflecting rather than absorbing the sun's energy, light-colored roofs keep buildings, cities, and even the entire planet cooler. Now a new study ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.