Researchers discover real reason why turtles have shells

July 15, 2016, Denver Museum of Nature & Science
Artistic rendering of the early proto turtle Eunotosaurus (foreground) burrowing into the banks of a dried up pond to escape the harsh arid environment present 260 million years ago in South Africa. Meanwhile, a herd of Bradysaurus (background) congregates around the remaining muddy water. Credit: Andrey Atuchin

It is common knowledge that the modern turtle shell is largely used for protection. No other living vertebrate has so drastically altered its body to form such an impenetrable protective structure as the turtle. However, a new study by an international group of paleontologists suggests that the broad ribbed proto shell on the earliest partially shelled fossil turtles was initially an adaptation, for burrowing underground, not for protection. Paleontologist Tyler Lyson from the Denver Museum of Nature & Science is among the scientists that helped make this discovery.

"Why the evolved is a very Dr. Seuss-like question and the answer seems pretty obvious – it was for protection," said Dr. Lyson, lead author of Fossorial Origin of the Turtle Shell, which was released today by Current Biology. "But just like the bird feather did not initially evolve for flight, the earliest beginnings of the turtle shell was not for but rather for digging underground to escape the harsh South African environment where these early proto turtles lived." 

The early evolution of the turtle shell had long puzzled scientists. "We knew from both the fossil record and observing how the turtle shell develops in modern that one of the first major changes toward a shell was the broadening of the ," said Dr. Lyson. While distinctly broadened ribs may not seem like a significant modification, it has a serious impact on both breathing and speed in quadrupedal animals. Ribs are used to support the body during locomotion and play a crucial role in ventilating the lungs. Distinctly broadened ribs stiffen the torso, which shortens an animals stride length and slows it down, interfering with breathing.

A new fossil of the oldest proto turtle, Eunotosaurus, discovered by then 8-year-old Kobus Snyman on his father's farm in the Karoo of South Africa suggest the turtle shell initially evolved not for protection, but rather as an adaptation for burrowing. The broadened ribs and the beginnings of the turtle shell provided Eunotosaurus with a stable base from which it could use its large hands and spatula shaped claws to burrow into the ground to escape the harsh arid environment found in South Africa 260 million years ago. Credit: Tyler R. Lyson
"The integral role of ribs in both locomotion and breathing is likely why we don't see much variation in the shape of ribs," said Dr. Lyson. "Ribs are generally pretty boring bones. The ribs of whales, snakes, dinosaurs, humans, and pretty much all other animals look the same. Turtles are the one exception, where they are highly modified to form the majority of the shell."

Computed Tomography scan of a 260 million year old proto turtle, Eunotosaurus, from South Africa. Credit: Gabriel S. Bever

A big breakthrough came with the discovery of several specimens of the oldest (260- million-year-old) partially shelled proto turtle, Eunotosaurus africanus, from the Karoo Basin of South Africa. Several of these specimens were discovered by two of the study's coauthors, Drs. Roger Smith and Bruce Rubidge from the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg. But the most important specimen was found by a then 8-year-old South African boy on his father's farm in the Western Cape of South Africa. This specimen, which is about 15 cm long, comprises a well preserved skeleton together with the fully articulated hands and feet.

"I want to thank Kobus Snyman and shake his hand because without Kobus both finding the specimen and taking it to his local museum, the Fransie Pienaar Museum in Prince Albert, this study would not have been possible," said Dr. Lyson.

The study includes authors from the United States, South Africa, and Switzerland.

A recent study on the oldest proto turtle, Eunotosaurus (left), suggests the broadening of the ribs in turtles was initially an adaptation for burrowing to escape the extremely arid environment of South Africa 260 million years ago. Later the ribs were incorporated into the modern protective turtle shell as found in Pelusios (right). Credit: Luke Norton

Explore further: Evolutionary origin of the turtle shell

More information: Current Biology, DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2016.05.020

Related Stories

Evolutionary origin of the turtle shell

May 30, 2013

Through careful study of an ancient ancestor of modern turtles, researchers now have a clearer picture of how the turtles' most unusual shell came to be. The findings, reported on May 30 in Current Biology, help to fill a ...

Origin of the unique ventilatory apparatus of turtles

November 7, 2014

Through the careful study of modern and early fossil tortoise, researchers now have a better understanding of how tortoises breathe and the evolutionary processes that helped shape their unique breathing apparatus and tortoise ...

Scientists discover key clues in turtle evolution

September 2, 2015

A research team led by NYIT scientist Gaberiel Bever has determined that a 260-million year-old fossil species found in South Africa's Karoo Basin provides a long awaited glimpse into the murky origins of turtles.

Tough turtles survive cretaceous meteorite impact

July 12, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- New fossil localities from North Dakota and Montana have produced the remains of a turtle that survived the 65 million-year-old meteorite impact that wiped out the dinosaurs. The resulting study, published ...

Key link in turtle evolution discovered

June 25, 2015

An international team of researchers from the United States and Germany have discovered a key missing link in the evolutionary history of turtles. The new extinct species of reptile, Pappochelys, was unearthed in an area ...

The origin of the turtle shell: Mystery solved

July 9, 2013

A team of RIKEN researchers has finally solved the riddle of how the turtle shell originated. By observing the development of different animal species and confirming their results with fossil analysis and genomic data, researchers ...

Recommended for you

Why do Hydra end up with just a single head?

January 18, 2019

Often considered immortal, the freshwater Hydra can regenerate any part of its body, a trait discovered by the Geneva naturalist Abraham Trembley nearly 300 years ago. Any fragment of its body containing a few thousands cells ...

How our cellular antennas are formed

January 17, 2019

Most of our cells contain an immobile primary cilium, an antenna used to transfer information from the surrounding environment. Some cells also have many mobile cilia that are used to generate movement. The 'skeleton' of ...

10 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

carbon_unit
1.8 / 5 (18) Jul 15, 2016
Another incomplete article. How is broadening of the ribs an adaptation for burrowing? Why did turtle ancestors take that path, but not other borrowing animals?
viko_mx
Jul 16, 2016
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
TrollBane
4.2 / 5 (10) Jul 16, 2016
The carbon_unit should look beyond the body... beyond the body of the article to the expanded caption for the second image: "...The broadened ribs and the beginnings of the turtle shell provided Eunotosaurus with a stable base from which it could use its large hands and spatula shaped claws to burrow into the ground to escape the harsh arid environment found in South Africa 260 million years ago." You may need to click on the 'More' link.
qquax
4.2 / 5 (5) Jul 17, 2016
@viko_mx, indeed somebody frequenting a science site who does not believe in science makes for an excellent example.
jonesdave
2 / 5 (4) Jul 17, 2016
Personally, I think it is blindingly obvious why turtles developed shells. It saved our ancestors from having to carry a dinner plate around with them.
gculpex
3 / 5 (2) Jul 18, 2016
Do other burrowing animal have turtle-like shells? I don't know of any off hand.


The Armadillo?
antialias_physorg
3 / 5 (2) Jul 18, 2016
Do other burrowing animal have turtle-like shells? I don't know of any off hand

Since the shell is what defines a turtle ...
antigoracle
1 / 5 (3) Jul 19, 2016
So, it's not more plausible that being cold-blooded and lived in or near water, they grew wider to better absorb the sun's heat,t during their more active periods on land. You know, like the modern turtles do.
BongThePuffin
Jul 20, 2016
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
BongThePuffin
Jul 20, 2016
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.