Shields with optical illusion to revolutionise riot policing

Shields with optical illusion to revolutionise riot policing
Ben Palmer has redesigned the police riot shield. Credit: Nottingham Trent University

Smart riot shields that appear see-through one-way could allow police to hide their numbers during potentially violent clashes.

The design – by Nottingham Trent University undergraduate Ben Palmer - may help diffuse or prevent disorders, as protestors would have little or no knowledge of who they face.

The 21-year-old – who's studying BA Product Design - interviewed rioters and to help shape his product.

"Riot police have a difficult job to do, and can regularly face very intense situations", said Ben, who's studying at the School of Architecture, Design and the Built Environment.

"So I wanted to use my degree to explore how smart technology could be used to enhance the tools they have at their disposal.

"By interviewing rioters, it became very clear that police could gain a psychological advantage if their shields incorporated one-way privacy.

"Not only would it allow police to mask their numbers, but rioters wouldn't know who or what they were facing."

Ben's designs recently went on show for Nottingham Trent University's 2016 Art & Design Degree Show. The show was one of the largest collections of graduating art and design talent in the UK, with more than 1,300 works on public display.

Shields with optical illusion to revolutionise riot policing
Ben with his prototype riot shield. Credit: Nottingham Trent University

Made from polycarbonate - a light but strong, heat resistant plastic – the long shields are covered in a film of perforated vinyl which prevents protestors from looking in, but allows officers to look out.

Perforated vinyl works by way of an optical illusion by featuring a pattern of tiny holes.

The outside of the vinyl is light-coloured and appears opaque as a person's eyes naturally focus on the bright surface, rather than on the holes and the darker shade images behind.

By contrast the inside of the vinyl is dark which leads the eye to focus on the light and motion on the other side of the shield.

Ben, who is from Wymondham in Norfolk, who has ambitions to be a police officer, watched riot police training sessions to understand how the shields were used and interviewed officers.

His long shields can lock together to create an impermeable wall. Missiles thrown over the top can be deflected when other long shields are locked into place overhead.

Shields with optical illusion to revolutionise riot policing
Ben behind his riot shield. Credit: Nottingham Trent University

Ben also designed a shield for animal control, a round shield and an intermediate length shield.

James Dale, principal lecturer in Product Design at Nottingham Trent University, said: "Ben has shown how existing smart technology can be applied to help police officers who can face very impassioned situations.

"It's a great example of how modern design can used to help support those on the frontline in face of potentially difficult situations."

PC Simon Clarke, of the Public Order and Officer Safety Training department at Nottinghamshire Police, said: "We're always keen to welcome new and innovative thinking in the fight against crime. It was great for our officers to work with Ben and provide him with feedback on his ."

Explore further

Designer uses his head to tackle rugby's concussion problem

Provided by Nottingham Trent University
Citation: Shields with optical illusion to revolutionise riot policing (2016, June 30) retrieved 20 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jun 30, 2016
For some reason no one ever thinks about the consequences of police not having to worry about being identified in situations like this. Anonymity in riot situations leads to abuses. Nice idea, but the end result will be more pain and suffering, not less.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more