Footprints of baby planets in a gas disk

May 24, 2016, National Institutes of Natural Sciences
ALMA image of the dust disk around HL Tauri. Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO)

A new analysis of the ALMA data for a young star HL Tauri provides yet more firm evidence of baby planets around the star. Researchers uncovered two gaps in the gas disk around HL Tauri. The locations of these gaps in the gas match the locations of gaps in the dust found in the ALMA high resolution image taken in 2014. This discovery supports the idea that planets form in much shorter timescales than previously thought and prompts a reconsideration of alternative planet formation scenarios.

In November 2014, ALMA released a startling image of HL Tauri and its disk. This image, the sharpest ever taken for this kind of object, clearly depicts several gaps in the dust disk around the star.

Astronomers have not yet reached a definitive answer for what makes the gaps in the dust disk. Because these disks are the sites of planet formation, some suggest that infant planets are the key; the dark gaps are carved by planets forming in the disk that attract or sweep away the dust along their orbits.

But others doubt the planet explanation because HL Tauri is very young, estimated to be only about a million years, and classical studies indicate that it takes more than tens of millions of years for planets to form from small dust. Those researchers propose other possible mechanisms to form the gaps: changes in the dust size through coalescence or destruction; or the formation of dust due to gas molecules freezing.

More data was needed to determine which theory is correct. We know that the disks around young stars contain gas in addition to the dust. In fact, in general the amount of gas is 100 times larger than that of dust. The research team led by Dr. Hsi-Wei Yen at Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics in Taiwan and Professor Shigehisa Takakuwa at Kagoshima University, Japan, focused on the distribution of gas in the disk to better understand the true nature of the disk. If the dust gaps are caused by the variance of the dust properties, that wouldn't directly affect the gas, so no gaps would be seen in the gas distribution. If on the other hand, the gaps in the dust are caused by the gravity of forming planets, the gravity would be expected to created gaps in the gas as well.

HCO+ gas (blue) and dust (red) distributions in the disk around HL Tauri. The ellipses show the locations of the gaps (radii of 30 and 70 au). Credit: ALMA (ESO/NAOJ/NRAO), Yen et al.

Even with ALMA's unprecedented sensitivity, it was not easy to reveal the distribution of gas in the disk. The team extracted the emissions from HCO+ gas molecules in the publicly available 2014 ALMA Long Baseline Campaign data and summed up the emissions in rings around the star to increase the effective sensitivity. This novel data analysis technique yielded the sharpest image ever of the gas distribution around a young star.

The image of HCO+ distribution reveals at least two gaps in the disk, at the radii of 28 and 69 astronomical units. "To our surprise, these gaps in the gas overlap with the dust gaps," said Yen, the lead author of the paper that appeared in the Astrophysical Journal Letters. "This supports the idea that the gaps are the footprints left by baby planets." The fact that the gaps in the dust and the gas match-up implies that the amount of material in the gaps likely decreases. This disfavors some of the theories that tried to explain the gaps solely by changes in the . A decrease in the amount of material in the gaps supports the planet formation theory, in spite of HL Tauri's young age. "Our results indicate that planets start to form much earlier than what we expected." Yen added.

The team also found that the gas density is high enough to harbor an infant planet around the inner gap. Comparing the structure of the inner gap to theoretical models, the team estimates the planet has a mass 0.8 times that of Jupiter.

Artist's concept of HL Tauri. The star is surrounded by the disk (shown in red) and thick envelope. The star ejects a bipolar collimated jet. Credit: Yin-Chih Tsai/ASIAA EPO

On the other hand, the origin of the outer gap is still unclear. The team suggested the possible existence of a planet 2.1 times more massive than Jupiter, but the present research cannot eliminate the possibility that the gap is made by the drag between the dust particles and the . To solve this question, more data are needed.

"Our research clearly demonstrates that applying new data analysis techniques to existing data can uncover important facts, further increasing ALMA's already high scientific potential," commented Takakuwa. "Applying the same method to the datasets for other young stars, we expect to construct a systematic model of ."

Explore further: Speedy planet birth: Astronomers observe a clump of dust in the disk around star HL Tauri

More information: Hsi-Wei Yen et al, GAS GAPS IN THE PROTOPLANETARY DISK AROUND THE YOUNG PROTOSTAR HL TAU, The Astrophysical Journal (2016). DOI: 10.3847/2041-8205/820/2/L25

Related Stories

ALMA reveals planetary construction sites

December 16, 2015

Astronomers using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) have found the clearest indications yet that planets with masses several times that of Jupiter have recently formed in the discs of gas and dust around ...

Planetary influences on young stellar disks

December 14, 2015

A newborn star typically has a disk of gas and dust from which planets develop as the dust grains collide, stick together and grow. Stars older than about five million years lack evidence for these disks, however, suggesting ...

VLA shows earliest stages of planet formation

March 17, 2016

New images of a young star made with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) reveal what scientists think may be the very earliest stages in the formation of planets. The scientists used the VLA to see unprecedented detail ...

Recommended for you

New space industry emerges: on-orbit servicing

November 17, 2018

Imagine an airport where thousands of planes, empty of fuel, are left abandoned on the tarmac. That is what has been happening for decades with satellites that circle the Earth.

SpaceX gets nod to put 12,000 satellites in orbit

November 16, 2018

SpaceX got the green light this week from US authorities to put a constellation of nearly 12,000 satellites into orbit in order to boost cheap, wireless internet access by the 2020s.

Electric blue thrusters propelling BepiColombo to Mercury

November 16, 2018

In mid-December, twin discs will begin glowing blue on the underside of a minibus-sized spacecraft in deep space. At that moment Europe and Japan's BepiColombo mission will have just come a crucial step closer to Mercury.

Overflowing crater lakes carved canyons across Mars

November 16, 2018

Today, most of the water on Mars is locked away in frozen ice caps. But billions of years ago it flowed freely across the surface, forming rushing rivers that emptied into craters, forming lakes and seas. New research led ...

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

wduckss
1 / 5 (6) May 25, 2016
"Applying the same method to the datasets for other young stars, we expect to construct a systematic model of planet formation."

Leaving the expression of proto star is a small step from a delusions. The same should be done with the term "proto" related to the disk of gas.

"Why is there a ring, an asteroid belt or a drive around the celestial objects?" http://www.svemir...hy-there and
http://www.svemir...e-causal

In the presentation of results should be avoided allegations of age (inaccurate) the stars (and generally on the age of the body).
torbjorn_b_g_larsson
5 / 5 (5) May 25, 2016
@wduckss: I can't understand what you are truing to say, but it seems you question the status of the star, planet candidate and the age of the system.

Those are all verified by comparative studies unless I am mistaken (I can't be arsed to look it up since you haven't been arsed to look into the study itself either), except of course the new planet candidate presented here.
john berry_hobbes
2.6 / 5 (5) May 25, 2016
duckass has to post some inane crap first in every astronomy piece. I've yet to see any meaningful content in his ramblings. Best ignored, I say.
wduckss
not rated yet May 26, 2016
@wduckss: I can't understand what you are truing to say, but it seems you question the status of the star, planet candidate and the age of the system.

Those are all verified by comparative studies unless I am mistaken (I can't be arsed to look it up since you haven't been arsed to look into the study itself either), except of course the new planet candidate presented here.


If the platform or base wrong after all works are also incorrect.
Are using common sense (if not using physics), there is no possibility that the same principle of two bodies (asteroids of 1/2 kg and star) formed for the same time. What kind of collapse of gas that has millions of different separate parts? Units have nothing in common (chemical composition, mass, structure, etc.), although originating from "the same cloud of gas" that per composition does not resemble never once resulting whole.
We see this exactly in HL Tauri, there is a star and the rest of the body in forming.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.