You've heard of string theory. What about knot theory?

February 10, 2016 by Charlotte Hsu
UB knot theorist Bill Menasco’s personalized license plate. Credit: Douglas Levere

You may not have heard of knot theory.

But take it from Bill Menasco, a knot theorist of 35 years: This field of mathematics, rich in aesthetic beauty and intellectual challenges, has come a long way since he got into it.

It involves the study of mathematical , which differ from real-world knots in that they have no ends. You can think of each one as a string that crosses over itself a given number of times, and then reconnects with itself to form a closed loop.

"It was considered a very esoteric field when I started in it, but it has grown immensely and grown in all different directions," says Menasco, a professor of mathematics in the University at Buffalo College of Arts and Sciences.

Today, we know the study of knots could have applications in surprising areas. It could enable security firms to create better encryption systems, or elucidate the mysteries of how the body unravels DNA, Menasco says.

He's a researcher who loves what he does: His office is filled with knot paraphernalia, and he can draw and build 3-D versions of complex knots from memory. Neighbors know him by his license plate: KNOTPROF. But in the world of mathematics, Menasco is perhaps best known, with Morwen Thistlethwaite, for solving the Tait Flyping Conjecture, one of three famous problems posed in the late 1800s by Peter Guthrie Tait, a father of .

Blue and sea green beads form two interlocking knots. UB knot theorist Bill Menasco uses the beads, which can be snapped apart and rejoined, to research the structure of different knot formations. “It’s a very physical thing,” he says, regarding the study of knots. Credit: Douglas Levere

Below, Menasco reflects on the evolution of knot theory, from its whimsical, 19th-century beginnings to its uses in the modern world.

Why do you think people are so curious about knots?

"It seems to be somehow buried in our humanity that we're interested in these things," Menasco says. "You have to think that knots were some of the first technologies that our ancestors invented early on.

"You find knots in cultures all over the world. You see them in Asian art. You see them in Celtic crests. Sailors know the figure-8 knot, which crosses over itself four times. They call it the stopper."

What do knot theorists study?

"The central question is pretty much the same as when I started: How do you tell two knots apart?" Menasco says.

Even when two knots look very different, it's often possible to physically manipulate them by pulling or flipping sections of the string until the two knots are twins. (Cutting, which Menasco calls "cheating," is not allowed.)

Knot theory seeks to encode information about knots—including what happens when they are altered in some way—into algebraic expressions that can distinguish one knot from another. While experts have devised expressions that can differentiate some knots from others, a formula capable of describing every knot uniquely remains elusive.

How are knots relevant in the real world, besides being frustrating for people?

Knot theory has uses in physics, biology and other fields, Menasco says. He elaborates on two examples.

First, when cells divide, the DNA inside them must be replicated. This requires the DNA's double-helix structure to unfurl, generate a second copy of itself that's intertwined with the first, and then get untangled. To achieve this, enzymes help to cut, unknot and reconnect the strands. Knot theory provides insight into how hard it is to unknot and reknot various types of DNA, shedding light on how much time it takes the enzymes to do their jobs.

In the realm of security, Menasco and his graduate students are partnering with the firm SecureRF to further develop the Algebraic Eraser, a security protocol that uses knots in cryptography. The protocol weaves mathematical information from knots into encryption keys that allow users to decipher secret data encoded in security badges, mobile payment devices and more.

Do people ask you about your work all the time?

"My wife is always asking me to unknot her jewelry," Menasco jokes.

Do knot theorists have any insight on preventing real-life knots?

Menasco says while this isn't his forte, scientists have done experiments in which they tumbled strings around in a box to figure out what causes tangling. The research suggests that one solution to preventing knots is to store ear buds, phone chargers and other annoying cables in smaller boxes.

What are the origins of knot theory?

Knots first came to prominence in the 1860s, when scientists were trying to understand the nature of matter, Menasco says.

At the time, people didn't know that atoms were nuclei surrounded by electrons, so Lord Kelvin proposed a different theory: He hypothesized that the basic building blocks of matter were knots in the ether, a hypothetical substance that permeated space. He postulated that every element—hydrogen, oxygen, gold, and so on—was made from a different kind of knot.

"So the knots are stable: They have certain properties," Menasco says. "You can heat them up. You can cool them down. You can do certain things to them, but gold is gold, and oxygen is oxygen."

The theory tantalizingly fulfilled some key requirements for a system of building blocks for matter, Menasco says. For example, many types of knots could exist, comprising many elements, and knots could be linked to form molecules.

How did fellow scientists respond to Kelvin's theory of atoms as knots?

"Scientists like to classify things—to make a comprehensive list of the objects they're working on, without repetition," Menasco says. "So that's exactly what happened here."

Peter Guthrie Tait, a Scottish physicist, began an extensive study and tabulation of knots, with the goal of understanding how to tell different knots apart from one another, Menasco says.

Tait created, in essence, the basis for a periodic table of knots in which hydrogen would be the "unknot"—the unknotted circle—and heavier elements would be knots whose filaments crossed over themselves an ever-higher number of times.

But the theory was wrong…

"It was," Menasco says. "But when the physicists lost interest in Kelvin's work, the mathematicians stepped in and said, 'Wow.' Tait tabulated all the knots up to those with 10 crossings, and it was an amazing feat because this table remained mostly unchanged for 100 years."

One of the last corrections to Tait's table happened in 1973, when Kenneth Perko discovered that two of Tait's 10-crossing knots were actually the same, Menasco says. These knots became known as the Perko Pair, reducing the number of known 10-crossing knots from 166 to 165.

How did you become interested in knots?

"Knot theory is beauty," Menasco says. "I think geometrically, and it fed into my strengths.

"I did my graduate work at Berkeley, and I still remember within the first week going into Evans Hall and seeing people drawing all these crazy pictures on the blackboard. I thought, 'People get paid to do this? I want to do this.'"

What are you working on now?

Menasco is writing a textbook on mathematical discoveries that resulted from a 30-plus-year research partnership with Joan Birman of Columbia University and Barnard College. He hopes to finish the book, co-authored with his former PhD student, Doug LaFountain, an assistant professor at Western Illinois University, this year.

The topic? Two-dimensional surfaces associated with knots and links, which are chains of multiple knots joined together.

The subject is difficult to explain to a non-mathematician, but here is how Menasco describes it: "Our work was on understanding surfaces associated with knot and links when they are positioned in (x,y,z)-space as a closed braid that winds around the z-axis."

Explore further: Scientists confirm existence of quantum knots and create them in a quantum-mechanical field

Related Stories

A revolution in knot theory

November 10, 2011

In the 19th century, Lord Kelvin made the inspired guess that elements are knots in the "ether". Hydrogen would be one kind of knot, oxygen a different kind of knot---and so forth throughout the periodic table of elements. ...

New model predicts the force required to tie simple knots

September 8, 2015

Got rope? Then try this experiment: Cross both ends, left over right, then bring the left end under and out, as if tying a pair of shoelaces. If you repeat this sequence, you get what's called a "granny" knot. If, instead, ...

The electric slide dance of DNA knots

July 23, 2014

DNA has the nasty habit of getting tangled and forming knots. Scientists study these knots to understand their function and learn how to disentangle them (e.g. useful for gene sequencing techniques). Cristian Micheletti, ...

Recommended for you

Quantum internet goes hybrid

November 22, 2017

In a recent study published in Nature, ICFO researchers led by ICREA Prof. Hugues de Riedmatten report an elementary "hybrid" quantum network link and demonstrate photonic quantum communication between two distinct quantum ...

Enhancing the quantum sensing capabilities of diamond

November 22, 2017

Researchers have discovered that dense ensembles of quantum spins can be created in diamond with high resolution using an electron microscopes, paving the way for enhanced sensors and resources for quantum technologies.

Study shows how to get sprayed metal coatings to stick

November 21, 2017

When bonding two pieces of metal, either the metals must melt a bit where they meet or some molten metal must be introduced between the pieces. A solid bond then forms when the metal solidifies again. But researchers at MIT ...

Imaging technique unlocks the secrets of 17th century artists

November 21, 2017

The secrets of 17th century artists can now be revealed, thanks to 21st century signal processing. Using modern high-speed scanners and the advanced signal processing techniques, researchers at the Georgia Institute of Technology ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 10, 2016
A classic infatuation w/Knots over their abstract properties, but more fascinating are models of `elementary particles as Knots', recently been proposed by physicists at the Perimeter Inst. Far deeper in their physical implications, I would think these would be the alpha-male of the Math-KnotPhysics world & dominate interest in the field, but apparently `knot'..
5 / 5 (2) Feb 11, 2016
A string walks into a bar a says to the bartender,'gimme a whiskey'. The bartender sneers back,'we don't serve string in here'. The string walks away, ties a loop in his neck and messes his hair up and turns around back to the bar, walks in and says 'gimme a whiskey'. The bartender says,'hey ain't you that string that was just in here to which the string replies ,

'I'm afraid not.'
Feb 12, 2016
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
not rated yet Feb 15, 2016
Nice article; I wonder what he would reply when it is pointed out that his first practical "example" (DNA) violates his only rule, "no cutting."

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.