Title for 'Earth's first animal' likely goes to sea sponges

February 23, 2016 by Jennifer Chu, Massachusetts Institute of Technology

The first animal to appear on Earth was very likely the simple sea sponge.

New genetic analyses led by MIT researchers confirm that sea sponges are the source of a curious molecule found in rocks that are 640 million years old. These rocks significantly predate the Cambrian explosion—the period in which most took over the planet, 540 million years ago—suggesting that sea sponges may have been the first animals to inhabit the Earth.

"We brought together paleontological and genetic evidence to make a pretty strong case that this really is a molecular fossil of sponges," says David Gold, a postdoc in MIT's Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences (EAPS). "This is some of the oldest evidence for ."

The results are published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Gold is the lead author on the paper, along with senior author and EAPS Professor Roger Summons.

Ancient molecular clues

Paleontologists have unearthed an extraordinary number of fossils from the period starting around 540 million years ago. Based on the fossil record, some scientists have argued that contemporary animal groups essentially "exploded" onto Earth, very quickly morphing from single-celled organisms to complex multicellular animals in a relatively short geological time span. However, the fossils that are known from before the Cambrian explosion are peculiar in many respects, making it extremely difficult to determine which type of animal was the first to the evolutionary line.

Summons' lab has been looking for the answer in molecular fossils—trace amounts of molecules that have survived in ancient rocks long after the rest of an animal has decayed away.

"There's a feeling that animals should be much older than the Cambrian, because a lot of animals are showing up at the same time, but fossil evidence for animals before that has been contentious," Gold says. "So people are interested in the idea that some of these biomarkers and chemicals, molecules left behind, might help resolve these debates."

In particular, he and his colleagues have focused on 24-isopropylcholestane, or 24-ipc for short—a lipid molecule, or sterol, that is a modified version of cholesterol. In 1994, Summons was part of a team, led by Mark McCaffrey PhD '90, that first found 24-ipc, in unusually high amounts, in Cambrian and slightly older rocks. They speculated that sponges or their ancestors might be the source.

In 2009, a team led by University of California at Riverside Professor Gordon Love, then a postdoc in Summons' lab, did the first detailed study of rocks in Oman. The researchers confirmed the presence of 24-ipc in 640-million-year-old rock samples, potentially representing the oldest evidence for animal life. That work utilized high precision uranium-lead dating techniques developed by EAPS Professor Samuel Bowring.

"This research topic has a 20-plus-year history intimately connected to MIT scientists," Summons notes. "Now, in 2016 David Gold has been able to apply his skills and the new tools of the genomic era, to add a further layer of evidence supporting the 'sponge biomarker hypothesis.'"

Growing an evolutionary tree

It's known that some modern sea sponges and certain types of algae produce 24-ipc today, but which organism was around to make the molecule 640 million years ago? To answer this question, Summons and Gold sought to first identify the gene responsible for making 24-ipc, then find the organisms that carry this gene, and finally trace when the gene evolved in those organisms.

The team looked through the genomes of about 30 different organisms, including plants, fungi, algae, and sea sponges, to see what kinds of sterols each organism produces and to identify the genes associated with those sterols.

"What we found was this really interesting pattern across most of eukaryotic life," Gold says.

By comparing genomes, they identified a single gene, sterol methyltransferase, or SMT, responsible for producing certain kinds of sterols depending on the number of copies of the gene an organism carries. The researchers found that and algae species that produce 24-ipc have an extra copy of SMT when compared with their close relatives.

The researchers compared the copies to determine how they were all related and when each copy of the gene first appeared. They then mapped the relationships onto an and used evidence from the fossil record to determine when each SMT gene duplication occurred.

No matter how they manipulated the timing of the evolutionary tree, the researchers found that sea sponges evolved the extra copy of SMT much earlier than algae, and they did so around 640 million years ago—the same time period in which 24-ipc was found in rocks.

Their results provide strong evidence that sea sponges appeared on Earth 640 million years ago, much earlier than any other life form.

"This brings up all these new questions: What did these organisms look like? What was the environment like? And why is there this big gap in the ?" Gold says. "This goes to show how much we still don't know about early animal life, how many discoveries there are left, and how useful, when done properly, these molecular fossils can be to help fill in those gaps."

Explore further: Tiny sponge fossil upsets evolutionary model

More information: David A. Gold et al. Sterol and genomic analyses validate the sponge biomarker hypothesis, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2016). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1512614113

Related Stories

Signs point to sponges as earliest animal life

February 4, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Even Charles Darwin was puzzled by the apparently sudden appearance in the fossil record of a great variety of multicellular creatures — a rapid blossoming known as the Cambrian explosion. Since then, the ...

Oldest known sponge found in China

March 10, 2015

(Phys.org)—A team of researchers with members from China, the U.S. and France has identified an ancient sponge found in a geologic formation in southern China and have dated it to 600 million years ago. In their paper published ...

Which came first—the sponge or the comb jelly?

December 1, 2015

Bristol study reaffirms classical view of early animal evolution. Whether sponges or comb jellies (also known as sea gooseberries) represent the oldest extant animal phylum is of crucial importance to our understanding of ...

Recommended for you


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.3 / 5 (3) Feb 23, 2016
Not comb jellies?
4.5 / 5 (2) Feb 23, 2016
Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. It is a logical fallacy to say that since there is no (recognized) evidence of any earlier animal, that there must have never been any earlier animals.
4 / 5 (1) Feb 23, 2016
Comb jellies (or ancestors thereof) earliest appearance in the fossil record is about 540-510 Mya; they aren't known to be present at 640 Mya. This present work assumes that 24-ipc has sponges as its only source, various other organisms have been suggested as possible sources (such as algae), but this is speculative. So, the "earliest animal" is disputed (naturally). Chemical tracers lack the specificity needed to establish source unless context is well studied/well understood. Proving the negative: "No organism existed, other than sponges, which synthesized 24ipc" is impossible.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.