Study identifies factors that affect state-owned enterprises' welcome overseas

February 24, 2016
Study identifies factors that affect state-owned enterprises' welcome overseas
Credit: University

When a multinational company is a state-owned enterprise, the choice of where to expand may hinge on more than just economic considerations, according to a new paper by strategic management experts at Rice University's Jones Graduate School of Business.

"A Geopolitical Perspective Into the Opposition of State-Owned Enterprises in Target States" argues that potential opposition from target countries can also play a role. Most notably, the authors said, these countries may see the foreign enterprises as agents of their home countries and the enterprises' expansion onto their soil as a threat to their national security. The United States, for example, in 2005 blocked a Chinese state-owned oil company, China National Offshore Oil Corp., from acquiring the U.S. firm Unocal on the grounds that the company represented the interests of the Chinese Communist Party, according to the paper.

The paper was co-authored by Wei Shi, a doctoral candidate in strategic management at the Jones School; Robert Hoskisson, the George R. Brown Professor of Management; and Yan "Anthea" Zhang, the Fayez Sarofim Vanguard Professor of Management. It was published in Global Strategy Journal.

"Our foundational argument in this paper is that the geopolitical perspective can provide new insights into understanding the level of opposition faced by globalizing state-owned enterprises as well as their location choices," the authors wrote. "Such a perspective is important because global financial turmoil has spurred governments throughout the world to take ownership in what previously were private businesses and more and more traditional state-owned enterprises are expanding beyond their national borders."

The authors created a conceptual model to analyze the level of potential opposition from target countries. Their model proposed five geopolitical factors that can shape the level of welcome a state-owned enterprise can expect from its potential new home:

Geographic distance

From a geopolitical standpoint, close neighbors may pose greater threats to each other's national sovereignty than countries that are comfortably far apart. Neighbors may also have a track record of conflict. For a state-owned enterprise, moving into a nearby neighborhood may threaten the target country's sense of sovereignty or even national security and thus spark opposition.

Similarity of religious beliefs

Shared can boost levels of trust, and dissimilar belief systems can sow distrust and conflict, the authors said. When a state-owned-enterprise's home country and its target destination share religious beliefs, the path to expansion may be smoother.

Similarity of governments

In today's world, government types range from full autocracies to full democracies, with a variety of models in between. Countries with similar government forms, however, are more likely to identify with each other and agree upon how governments should work. That mutual identification and acceptance can lower opposition to a foreign state-owned enterprise's investment.

Resource complementarity

Resource complementarity refers to the degree to which a target country needs resources that a foreign state-owned enterprise can offer. They might be natural resources, such as sources of energy; they might be technological savvy or financial strength. If the state-owned enterprise has resources that the target country wants, a welcome is more likely, the authors said.

Nationalist politics in the target country

A target country's political leaders can muffle or amplify the other four factors to influence their country's reception of the foreign state-owned enterprise. For example, if a state-owned enterprise is seen as a threat, the target country's might urge official visits or foster economic cooperation. If they can calm nationalistic friction, these leaders can help open the doors to the state-owned enterprise. Political leaders can also use the nationalistic feelings to stoke opposition.

"Increasing global expansion by state-owned enterprises suggests the need for a more systematic framework to examine these enterprises' location choices in international business," the authors said. They believe that their geopolitical model focused on state-owned enterprises' global expansions and potential opposition from target states "not only adds value to understanding the global distribution of state-owned enterprises' business activities, but also can shed light on private multinational companies' global location choices."

Explore further: Windows 10 tuned for Chinese government

More information: Wei Shi et al. A Geopolitical Perspective into the Opposition to Globalizing State-Owned Enterprises in Target States, Global Strategy Journal (2016). DOI: 10.1002/gsj.1105

Related Stories

Windows 10 tuned for Chinese government

December 18, 2015

Microsoft is forming a joint-venture in China to tailor a version of its new Windows 10 computer operating system for use by the Chinese government.

Multinational companies perform majority of US business R&D

February 5, 2016

Multinational companies perform the majority of all research and development (R&D) done by companies located in the Unites States, according to a new report from the National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics ...

US firm's Chinese subsidiaries to pay $14.5M to resolve case

February 16, 2016

Chinese subsidiaries of a Massachusetts software company have agreed to pay more than $14.5 million to resolve the federal government's allegations that they illegally provided recreational travel to Chinese government officials.

Recommended for you

Averaging the wisdom of crowds

December 12, 2017

The best decisions are made on the basis of the average of various estimates, as confirmed by the research of Dennie van Dolder and Martijn van den Assem, scientists at VU Amsterdam. Using data from Holland Casino promotional ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.