Penalties don't work with insider trading

October 20, 2015 by Terry Kosdrosky, University of Michigan

As Congress kept increasing the civil and criminal penalties for illegal insider trading, nothing happened.

New research by University of Michigan Ross School professors Cindy Schipani and Nejat Seyhun shows that vague legal definitions and a recent court decision have hamstrung prosecutors trying to ensure trades are on the level. This can erode confidence in public markets and harm all investors.

Schipani, a business law professor, and Seyhun, a finance professor, offer a solution that would allow regulators to clearly define what constitutes a suspicious trade, and put the onus on traders to show it's legitimate.

Their study, "Defining 'Material, Nonpublic:' What Should Constitute Illegal Insider Information?" looks at decades of trades filed by registered insiders. They showed ambiguous wording of the law has led to a significant and abnormal profits.

"Increasing civil and criminal penalties does not work as a successful deterrent if there is substantial ambiguity about what is illegal insider trading," Schipani said. "This ambiguity allows insiders to not only trade successfully but also to fend off attempts by the SEC and the U.S. Justice Department to discipline them after the fact."

From 1975 to 1984, for example, the researchers found 60,000 transactions that showed almost immediate abnormal profitability, beating the general stock market more than 5 percent during the first five days after the trade date. Over the next three decades, that number shot up. From 2005 to 2014, more than 200,000 large-volume transactions show immediate profitability by day five.

"Our evidence indicates that insiders are taking advantage of this vagueness of the law to exploit their material, nonpublic information," Seyhun said.

Exacerbating the situation is a recent ruling from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals that makes it harder for prosecutors to establish quid pro quo between people who share nonpublic information and then trade on it.

To combat this, Schipani and Seyhun propose a three-step method for investigators to establish an insider trading case:

  • The kind of information giving rise to the trade is significant enough to require disclosure on an 8-K form.
  • The announcement must lead to abnormal stock returns.
  • The alleged insider trading must have occurred two months before announcing the information.

Because companies file quarterly earnings reports every three months, this would effectively limit trades by insiders to a one-month period after earnings. If an investigator can show all three elements, then the burden of proof shifts to the traders to show their transaction does not meet the material, nonpublic information requirement.

The clarity should help both regulators and investors, because insiders will know exactly when they can safely trade.

"The benefit of this additional clarity should enable courts to separate routine from opportunistic trading and increase the confidence in the public equity markets," Seyhun said.

Explore further: Media can restrict insider trading

More information: Schipani, Cindy A. and Seyhun, H. Nejat, Defining 'Material, Nonpublic': What Should Constitute Illegal Insider Information? (September 2015). Fordham Journal of Corporate and Financial Law, Forthcoming; Ross School of Business Paper No. 1287. Available at SSRN:

Related Stories

Media can restrict insider trading

May 7, 2015

New ANU research has found the media can have a strong effect in reducing corporate insider share trading by repeating existing information about trades.

Former Qualcomm executive sent to prison for insider trading

June 26, 2015

A former Qualcomm Inc. executive was sentenced Friday to 18 months in prison and fined $500,000 for an insider trading scheme to profit off the wireless technology company's confidential information and then covering up his ...

Insider trading study shows stronger enforcement

October 23, 2014

The first major study of the enforcement of Australia's insider trading laws has shown the number of insider trading cases brought by the Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) is increasing, and the regulator ...

Insider trading: Another glass ceiling?

October 8, 2008

( -- Martha Stewart notwithstanding, female executives who legally trade on inside information make nice, tidy profits—but not as much as men in the same positions, say researchers at the University of Michigan's ...

Study finds insiders profit as companies falter

March 24, 2011

( -- Insiders have reaped substantial profits from increased trading of a faltering company’s stock when the firm is renegotiating its debt, according to a study by researchers at the University of Otago ...

Recommended for you

Meteorite source in asteroid belt not a single debris field

February 17, 2019

A new study published online in Meteoritics and Planetary Science finds that our most common meteorites, those known as L chondrites, come from at least two different debris fields in the asteroid belt. The belt contains ...

Diagnosing 'art acne' in Georgia O'Keeffe's paintings

February 17, 2019

Even Georgia O'Keeffe noticed the pin-sized blisters bubbling on the surface of her paintings. For decades, conservationists and scholars assumed these tiny protrusions were grains of sand, kicked up from the New Mexico desert ...

Archaeologists discover Incan tomb in Peru

February 16, 2019

Peruvian archaeologists discovered an Incan tomb in the north of the country where an elite member of the pre-Columbian empire was buried, one of the investigators announced Friday.

Where is the universe hiding its missing mass?

February 15, 2019

Astronomers have spent decades looking for something that sounds like it would be hard to miss: about a third of the "normal" matter in the Universe. New results from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory may have helped them ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.