Hubble sees a 'behemoth' bleeding atmosphere around a warm exoplanet (Update)

Red dwarf burns off planet's hydrogen giving it massive comet-like tail
"What we can see is a large cloud of hydrogen gas absorbing the light from a red dwarf star as its exoplanet, GJ 436b, passes in front. The cloud is created as of result of x-rays emitted from the red dwarf burning off GJ 436b's upper atmosphere."The cloud forms a comet-like tail as a result of ultraviolet light coming from the star pushing on the hydrogen and causing it to spiral outwards. "Around 1000 metric tonnes of hydrogen are being burnt off from GJ 436b's atmosphere every second; which equates to only 0.1 percent of its total mass every billion years. The same process is likely to be much stronger on other exoplanets, where the entire atmosphere could be removed or evaporated to destruction". Credit: Mark Garlick/University of Warwick

Astronomers using NASA's Hubble Space Telescope have discovered an immense cloud of hydrogen dubbed "The Behemoth" bleeding from a planet orbiting a nearby star. The enormous, comet-like feature is about 50 times the size of the parent star. The hydrogen is evaporating from a warm, Neptune-sized planet, due to extreme radiation from the star.

This phenomenon has never been seen around an exoplanet so small. It may offer clues to how other planets with hydrogen-enveloped atmospheres could have their outer layers evaporated by their parent star, leaving behind solid, rocky cores. Hot, rocky planets such as these that roughly the size of Earth are known as Hot-Super Earths.

"This cloud is very spectacular, though the evaporation rate does not threaten the planet right now," explains the study's leader, David Ehrenreich of the Observatory of the University of Geneva in Switzerland. "But we know that in the past, the star, which is a faint red dwarf, was more active. This means that the planet evaporated faster during its first billion years of existence because of the strong radiation from the young star. Overall, we estimate that it may have lost up to 10 percent of its atmosphere over the past several billion years."

The planet, named GJ 436b, is considered to be a "Warm Neptune," because of its size and because it is much closer to its star than Neptune is to our sun. Although it is in no danger of having its atmosphere completely evaporated and stripped down to a rocky core, this planet could explain the existence of so-called Hot Super-Earths that are very close to their stars.

These hot, rocky worlds were discovered by the Convection Rotation and Planetary Transits (CoRoT) and NASA's Kepler space telescope. Hot Super-Earths could be the remnants of more massive planets that completely lost their thick, gaseous atmospheres to the same type of evaporation.

Red dwarf burns off planet's hydrogen giving it massive comet-like tail
Artist impression showing the warm, Neptune-size exoplanet GJ 436b at the beginning of its transit across the surface of its parent star, a red dwarf that is half the diameter of the Sun. The planet is 33x closer to its parent star than the Earth is to Sun, heating the atmosphere to the point it expands and escape the planet attraction. The star is, however, 40x fainter than the Sun, allowing the evaporating atmosphere to form a giant cloud surrounding and trailing the planet, much like a comet. Credit: D.Ehrenreich / V. Bourrier (Université de Genève) / A. Gracia Berná (Universität Bern)

Because the Earth's atmosphere blocks most ultraviolet light, astronomers needed a space telescope with Hubble's ultraviolet capability and exquisite precision to find "The Behemoth."

"You would have to have Hubble's eyes," says Ehrenreich. "You would not see it in visible wavelengths. But when you turn the ultraviolet eye of Hubble onto the system, it's really kind of a transformation, because the planet turns into a monstrous thing."

Because the planet's orbit is tilted nearly edge-on to our view from Earth, the planet can be seen passing in front of its star. Astronomers also saw the star eclipsed by "The Behemoth" hydrogen cloud around the planet.

Ehrenreich and his team think that such a huge cloud of gas can exist around this planet because the cloud is not rapidly heated and swept away by the radiation pressure from the relatively cool red dwarf star. This allows the cloud to stick around for a longer time. The team's findings will be published in the June 25 edition of the journal Nature.

The video shows the result of a computer simulation performed to explain the observations made with the Hubble Space Telescope. When the planet passes across the surface of its star (a "transit”), Hubble detects a large dimming in the star ultraviolet luminosity (by more than 50%). This is caused by a huge hydrogen cloud resulting from the evaporation of the planetary atmosphere. We use numerical simulations to determine the precise size and shape of the cloud, and how fast the hydrogen gas escapes from the planet Credit: D. Ehrenreich / V. Bourrier (Université de Genève) / A. Gracia Berná (Universität Bern)

Evaporation such as this may have happened in the earlier stages of our own solar system, when the Earth had a hydrogen-rich atmosphere that dissipated over 100 to 500 million years. If so, the Earth may previously have sported a comet-like tail.

GJ 436b resides very close to its star - less than 2 million miles—and whips around it in just 2.6 Earth days. In comparison, the Earth is 93 million miles from our sun and orbits it every 365.24 days. This exoplanet is at least 6 billion years old, and may even be twice that age. It has a mass of around 23 Earths. At just 30 light-years from Earth, it's one of the closest known extrasolar planets.

NASA's Hubble sees a 'behemoth' bleeding atmosphere around a warm exoplanet
This artist's concept shows "The Behemoth," an enormous comet-like cloud of hydrogen bleeding off of a warm, Neptune-sized planet just 30 light-years from Earth. Also depicted is the parent star, which is a faint red dwarf named GJ 436. The hydrogen is evaporating from the planet due to extreme radiation from the star. A phenomenon this large has never before been seen around any exoplanet. Credit: NASA, ESA, and G. Bacon (STScI)

Finding "The Behemoth" could be a game-changer for characterizing atmospheres of the whole population of Neptune-sized planets and Super-Earths in ultraviolet observations. In the coming years, Ehrenreich expects that astronomers will find thousands of this kind of planet.

The ultraviolet technique used in this study also may also spot the signature of oceans evaporating on smaller, more Earth-like planets. It will be extremely challenging for astronomers to directly see water vapor on those worlds, because it's too low in the atmosphere and shielded from telescopes. However, when water molecules are broken by the stellar radiation into hydrogen and oxygen, the relatively light hydrogen atoms can escape the planet. If scientists spot this hydrogen evaporating from a planet that is slightly more temperate and less massive than GJ 436b, it could be an indication of an ocean on the surface.

Explore further

Helium-shrouded planets may be common in our galaxy

More information: A giant comet-like cloud of hydrogen escaping the warm Neptune mass exoplanet GJ 436b, Nature, DOI: 10.1038/nature14501
Journal information: Nature

Citation: Hubble sees a 'behemoth' bleeding atmosphere around a warm exoplanet (Update) (2015, June 24) retrieved 16 June 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jun 24, 2015
Relatively cool red dwarf, big planet orbiting 2 million miles out, not 93 million, and just now losing hydrogen?

Jun 25, 2015
I don't understand the statement that the planet GJ 436b is 33x closer to its parent star GJ 436 than the earth is to our sun. If I assume an average distance of 93 million miles (earth-sun distance), 1/33rd the distance is nearly 3 million miles, but the article states that it is less than 2 million miles, which would make it approximately 48x closer. What am I assuming incorrectly?

Jun 25, 2015
What would really be interesting is if it also had an ion tail. Then comet "like" may not be accurate enough, might have to call it a comet.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more