Gamer culture remains crude, rude and male-dominated, study finds

May 1, 2015, University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee
Gamer culture remains crude, rude and male-dominated, UWM study finds
UWM doctoral students Ben Baker and Arrington Stoll say their study of the experiences of female gamers shows that the culture is still male-dominated, and can be crude and rude.

Misogyny is a defining characteristic of gaming culture, even though half of the players now are female.

Women who game face unwelcome sexual advances and crude condemnations of their skills, say Benjamin Baker and Arrington Stoll, UWM doctoral students who recently completed a study on the topic.

"Video games have historically been steeped in hypermasculine culture," said Baker, 31, a lifelong gamer. "Games have been developed by men and marketed to men."

While the audience has evolved, the sexualized characterization of women has not. The streets, dungeons and battlefields are more realistic than ever but still populated by brawny males and a few women clad in cleavage-revealing costumes.

Stoll, 28, began playing about six years to stay connected with her younger brother when he went off to college. She played a character with masculine traits in the online Xbox 360 Call of Duty, but her feminine username and voice were immediate giveaways (players wear headsets and communicate with one another).

"It was terrible at first," said Stoll, who was berated in crude language when, as a newcomer, she didn't perform well. "My brother would stick up for me," she said. "He'd say 'Hey, that's my sister!'"

Gamer culture remains crude, rude and male-dominated, UWM study finds
UWM doctoral student Arrington Stoll got into gaming as a way of keeping in touch with her brother when he went off to college. Now she’s working on a study of female gamers’ experiences.

The two agreed that the study benefitted from having a man and woman involved.

"You have to look at this from an unbiased viewpoint," Stoll said. "Some might have said that of course I'd come to a certain conclusion. He (Baker) brought another viewpoint."

Twenty gamers between the ages of 18 and 52 participated in the study, describing similar experiences. All had assigned popular gaming names to preserve anonymity.

"(M)ale players will sometimes be very rude and inappropriate in general chat channels – making comments about things like rape, for instance, or racial comments," wrote one player.

Another respondent talked about harassment that went further. "When my character walked away, they followed me and continued to emote that they were restraining me or touching me in a sexual nature. I felt violated and upset…"

Yet another talked about being stalked after giving identifying information to a male player.

UWM doctoral student Ben Baker has been studying the often-negative experiences of female gamers. But he says gaming has a positive side too, with many gamers developing friendships across long distances.

Media critic and blogger Anita Sarkeesian experienced the wrath of misogynists last year when she waded into the culture wars of the gaming world. Some players took the argument offline and threatened Sarkeesian with rape and death. At least one of her speaking engagements was cancelled because of threats of mass violence. That incident and another involving a Washington Post blogger who faced similar scorn after writing about the state of gaming became known as Gamergate.

But there can be another side to the gaming world.

Female gamers spoke warmly about the community they found online. Baker said he knew of one couple who met through online gaming, connected in real life and married.

Gamer culture remains crude, rude and male-dominated, UWM study finds
UWM doctoral students Ben Baker and Arrington Stoll say their study of the experiences of female gamers shows that the culture is still male-dominated, and can be crude and rude.
"For every negative experience, there are far more positive," he said. "I've talked to people who have met in these games and have become friends even though they live on the other side of the country."

Baker and Stoll hope to have the paper published in a publication read not just by the gamers but also the gatekeepers, such as developers and producers, of the games. "That way it could have more impact as we continue to talk about the issues," Baker said.

Explore further: Video game world tensions erupt in 'GamerGate'

Related Stories

Video game world tensions erupt in 'GamerGate'

November 7, 2014

The horrific misogynistic abuse of female figures within the video game industry has triggered debate over whether women are being accepted as equal partners in the sector.

Study finds gaming augments players' social lives

March 27, 2014

New research finds that online social behavior isn't replacing offline social behavior in the gaming community. Instead, online gaming is expanding players' social lives. The study was done by researchers at North Carolina ...

Sexualized avatars affect the real world, researchers find

October 10, 2013

(Phys.org) —A Stanford study shows that after women wear sexualized avatars in a virtual reality world, they feel objectified and are more likely to accept rape myths in the real world. The research could have implications ...

Videogames boost skills, but also harmful

April 1, 2015

Good news and bad news for video gamers: new research shows game play boosts visual and cognitive skills, but that too much of the activity is linked to behavioral problems.

Not all gamers are low scorers on friendships, relationships

December 20, 2012

Not all video game players are destined for lives filled with failing relationships and dwindling friendships, according to Penn State researchers, who say that a lot depends on the role of the game-playing activity in the ...

Recommended for you

Study: Social media sways exercise motivation

January 17, 2019

It's January – a time when students are looking for that extra bit of oomph. For some, time spent on social media might provide the necessary inspiration to get up and exercising – but that time can come with consequences, ...

5 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Returners
3 / 5 (2) May 01, 2015
This is so true. I am a 34 years old and I am disgusted by the way other guys behave towards women and even one another in interactive online games.
jwozniak
not rated yet May 03, 2015
I'm 57, and have been a gamer since games were text adventures played between mainframes. And I must say, if some snotty nosed child spoke like that to my face, he'd be picking up his teeth. If the parents never learned respect and tolerance, why do we expect it from their equally self-absorbed offspring?
aqueous_null
5 / 5 (1) May 03, 2015
This article has to be one of the most one-sided I've ever read on the internet, and that is saying something.

Firstly, noone can deny with a straight face the industry is male-dominated, you don't need to conduct a study to find that out. However, I'm not sure how "rude and crude" comments or behaviour equate to "misogyny" - a sensationalist use of the term that dilutes it, which actually means "hatred of women". "Hate" is a very strong word and I expect most individuals who "hate" someone or something would direct more than just "rude and crude" language at them.

Secondly, the mention of Sarkeesian from a victim's perspective just seals the deal. The "abuse" she received was in RESPONSE to her own actions: she has, on more than one occasion, plastered every male individual within gaming with the same accusations. According to her, because I am male and a gamer, I am automatically "the problem". I love how this information is accidentally-on-purpose missing from the article.
EWH
not rated yet May 04, 2015
This is a political advocacy piece, propaganda. A sample size of 20, particularly for a survey that was nothing more than a push-poll, just gives a pretense of science. This is not science.
antialias_physorg
not rated yet May 04, 2015
For the most part I don't see girl gamers treated any more badly than guys. The insults may be more contextual to the female gender...but the hatred/rage-issues of the one spouting them does not seem to vary when it comes to insulting a girl or a guy.

On the "plus" side: (Good looking) female gamers seem to earn way more cash on twitch than their male counterparts (and are somewhat underestimated in E-sports which is an edge that can be helpful). So there are ways to leverage the girl-gamer image to their advantage.

But in the end: Games are (mostly) played by kids. Expecting mature behavior in such an environment is not realistic.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.