Living mulch, organic fertilizer tested on broccoli

Living mulch, organic fertilizer tested on broccoli
An experiment at the University of New Hampshire's Woodman Horticultural Research Farm (NH Agricultural Experiment Station) evaluated the effects of living mulch and fertilizer on broccoli production. Pictured are broccoli grown in plastic-covered raised beds with either living mulch or bare soil between bed-rows. Credit: Nicholas Warren

Cover crops provide many benefits to agricultural production systems, including soil and nutrient retention, resources and habitat for beneficial organisms, and weed suppression. In regions where short growing seasons can hinder the establishment of productive cover crops between cash crop growing periods, living mulch systems may provide vegetable crop growers with opportunities to establish cover crops earlier in the growing season, thereby increasing the duration of cover crop growth.

Living mulch (LM) systems are a form of intercropping that involves growing a cover crop or mixture simultaneously with a cash crop for part or all of the cropping season. Despite their benefits, however, living mulches can also result in reduced yields if they compete with the vegetable crop for limited resources. Nicholas Warren, Richard Smith, and Rebecca Sideman from the University of New Hampshire published a study in the February 2015 issue of HortScience that examined the effects of an Italian ryegrass-white clover living mulch on yield and yield components.

"In New Hampshire and other northern New England states, broccoli is often planted in the summer in raised beds and harvested in the fall. This production schedule means that it can be especially challenging to establish fall-sown cover crops in these systems," explained Nicholas Warren, corresponding author of the study. "Growing cover crops as living mulches concurrently with broccoli in a plasticulture system may both include or expand the use of cover crops in broccoli production systems in short-season regions, and reduce the need for soil disturbance in the spaces between beds," Warren said. The study reported on experiments designed to assess the performance of irrigated, summer-sown broccoli grown in plasticulture with and without living mulches under different rates of organic fertilizer application.

The scientists conducted two experiments in Durham, New Hampshire; the experiments were conducted in separate fields to avoid additive effects of LM and broccoli-specific pathogens. "Our hypothesis that LM reduces broccoli marketable yield in the absence of fertilizer addition was supported in both experiments," the authors said. "The hypothesis that the observed broccoli yield reductions resulting from LM were a consequence of competition for nitrogen was only partially supported; only experiment 1 was consistent with broccoli yield reductions in LM being the result of N limitation, as evidenced by the fact that LM yield reductions were ameliorated by the addition of fertilizer nitrogen. No such patterns were observed in experiment 2, where LM reduced broccoli yield even at rates that were equivalent to applying 2.5 times higher nitrogen than recommended."

The authors concluded that the results of both experiments provided "little support" that broccoli yield reductions resulting from LM can be attributed solely to competition for nitrogen, or improved by increasing organic fertilizer nitrogen rates. "Although we observed evidence that living mulch reduces yield of broccoli, some growers may be willing to accept some level of yield loss given the other potential ecosystem benefits associated with LM systems," they said.


Explore further

Hydrolyzed fish fertilizer tested in organic vegetable production

More information: HortScience: hortsci.ashspublications.org/c … nt/50/2/218.abstract
Journal information: HortScience

Citation: Living mulch, organic fertilizer tested on broccoli (2015, April 6) retrieved 17 October 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2015-04-mulch-fertilizer-broccoli.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
55 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Apr 06, 2015
Ya..they missed it.. the living mulch is supposed to be a marketable commodity that is picked based on profitability projections....

And you do it with perennial crops..broccoli wouldn't work out. But then again, I happen to live in a region that produces primary broccoli for processing.

What these guys saw was alleopathy not competition for nutrients.. You can pair for boosted or reduced performance. I''d like to work on the idea (I'd call it multicropping), but I wasn't born as a property owner and refuse to contribute to improving their ability to persist on land they are not the best fit to be on.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more